Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Changing motor speed with pulleys

Posts

Changing motor speed with pulleys

#1

Changing motor speed with pulleys

ScottM

>I have come across a good deal on a motor that is 1750 rpm but the machine I need to put it on requires a 3500 rpm. The machine I am putting this on is high horsepower and I don't want to lose any horse power or torque. I know it is possible to change the pulleys to increase the rpm but what is the disadvantage to doing that. Do you lose torque?

Thanks

Scott

Re: Changing motor speed with pulleys

#2

It's high school physics

Forrest Addy

>It's high school physics. Torque and RPM are inverse fulctions for a given HP. Torque is a measure of twisting effort like you'd twist at at something immovable. RPM is the number of revlutions a shaft makes in a minute. If there is no torque transmitted at a million RPM there is no HP present. If there are a million ft lb of torque at zero RPM no HP again. The formula goes HP = T x 5252 / RPM where T iss expressed in ft lb.

That's all theory.

Here's practicality: The pulley ratio has no effect on the HP transmitted; as the RPM increases the torque decreases but the HP stays constant (neglecting losses for the moment). So if you have a 3450 RPM motor and you want to replace it with a 1750 RPM motor, you'll have to double the size of the motor pulley for the driven load RPM to stay unchanged - and most likely change the belt to one that's a bit longer. The transmitted HP will remain the same of both motors were otherwise identical.

Clear as mud?

Re: Changing motor speed with pulleys

#3

Re: It's high school physics

Brian Philipp

>excellent explanation !!

Always remember: F=MA and you can't push a rope !

Re: Changing motor speed with pulleys

#4

Re: It's high school physics

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>A minor point, Forrest.

According to your formula, zero RPM would give "infinite" HP. Anything divided by zero is infinite (actually it is undefined.)

Since HP is a measure of work(force times distance), done by a rotating shaft, in this case, you are correct that there would be no HP with zero RPM.

I wanted to get this post in today so if it is in error, it would be chalked up to June along with all my others. I hate to start off a new month with an error.

Happy sawdust,

Ken

Re: Changing motor speed with pulleys

#5

the way I teach it

Andrew F in Australia

>is that work = force times distance moved = change in energy over time

So, if there's no distance moved, there's no work done.

If there's no force required, there's no work done.

If there's no work done, there's no energy used.

The torque requirements of the original setup don't change - at the end of the day, the new motor has to be able to produce the same torque at the cutterhead, and will need a similar Hp rating/full load current rating to do so.

Cheers,

Andrew

Addy protocol: Another engineer, touching vaguely on the fringes of his training here.

Re: Changing motor speed with pulleys

#6

Re: the way I teach it

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hi Andrew, sounds good to me.

I remember an example from college physics: if you carry a suitcase across a room, no work is done.

Regardless, my arm knows it has done work after moving a suitcase. :-)

Enjoy your winter. Instead of summer, we are having monsoons.(I'll blame it on global warming.)

Regards, Ken

Re: Changing motor speed with pulleys

#7

There could be another problem

Don C.

>You have probably already considered this, but to retain the proper RPM at your machine you will either have to double the size of the pulley on the motor or put a pulley on your machine that is one-half the size of the current pulley.

Depending on the machine and where the motor is located, this may not be possible due to lack of room.

Also, if too small a pulley is required on the machine, it may not provide adequate belt contact.