Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Dust Collectors

Posts

Dust Collectors

#1

Dust Collectors

Josh in VA

>I am starting to look at different dust collectors for the shop. I believe I have narrowed it down to 2. Either the Grizzly 3HP G0441 or the Oneida 3HP Super Dust Gorilla System.

I did consider the Clear Vue Cyclones, but I just can't get over what the system is made of.

All of the 3HP systems are in my budget, just a matter of deciding which one will hold up better. FWIW...I am currently up near Muncy and would have the opportunity to get the 3HP Grizzly without the $95 freight charge.

Any comments on either or other systems I should look into?

Thanks

Josh

Re: Dust Collectors

#2

Re: Dust Collectors

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have the GO-441, 3 hp cyclone - installed it a couple of years age. I can't compare it to others, as it is the only (small shop) unit I have used or watched in action. However, I can say it does what I expected, I have it installed on a wall, and installed an 8" home fabricated "Y" joining it to 2 - 6" main runs (on the 10' high shop ceiling), with 4" and 6" drops various places on the walls. I have about 35' of 6" PVC + 10' of 6" flex hooked up to my 20" Yorkcraft planer. It will remove ALL dust and chips from the planer with one other 4" gate open. It is a bit noisy - I see Griz has a muffler as an option for my unit now. I did have a problem with the motor, (Starting switch and capacitors) but Grizzly sent me replacement parts without any problems. Grizzly also sent out a retrofit kit (free) for the canister filter brush cleaning system, which I installed. As my shop is 30' X 30' most of my runs are pretty long. I have everything on mobile bases so also have at least 10' of flex on each machine. (Will eventually figure out where I want some things and cut off some excess). With this layout, the collector does an excellent job with one 4" and one 6" open at the same time. I am satisfied with the system, at the time I purchased it, the Grizzly was the only system in my price range. Since then, Oneida has reduced their prices to compete. I might have done more comparison had they decided to compete earlier. All in all, I would buy the Grizzly again.

Re: Dust Collectors

#3

Great to here your experience

Bartee (metro Atlanta)

>I am making this same decision.

At this point it will be the G0441 3hp Grizz.

Someone on another forum did the math to add up all you had to spend on the ClearVue and the Grizz came out about the same.

You description of your installation is excellent. I will have much the same design, so it is great to hear that it is working well for you.

I live in Atlanta so I am going to get my pvc stuff from mcMaster-Carr. I can pick it up and save the shipping expense.

Re: Dust Collectors

#4

Re: Some piping experience Long

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Be sure you get the sewer and drain type - about half the price and easier to handle. I purchased all my parts locally at plumbing contractor stores and the borgs. However the 8" fittings were out of sight as far as price. To set up a "Y" using the 8" inlet and reducing it to 6" for the runs was going to cost over $120 for the one fitting and reducers. My son had a (about 6') piece of regular 8" pvc pipe, so I cut a 45 deg ends on a short section of 6" - blended the angled ends to fit the od of the 8" using a router and a clone of the rotary microplane with a air die grinder - also used a rasp, saber saw etc. After I had the pipes fairly well mated (took me an hour of fiddling), I traced around it and cut the hole in the 8". I inserted the 6" into the 8" and glued it using pvc cement. I saved some of the shavings and melted them into a paste - used it to blend the joint and seal some openings where my fit wasn't perfect. I then cut some rings off the 8" pipe about 3" wide. I split them, heated them in my wifes oven at about 140 deg F for a few minutes - they became quite soft and flexible in a short time. I glued them into the ID of the 8" in steps until I had a fairly good fit for my 6" pipe. Had to do a little die grinding for it to fit.( think I had to make one ring set from the thinner 6" S&W to end up with the right (close) fit. I then glued in a short section of 6" pipe, and sealed all gaps with my homemade filler. -Vola a 8X6X6-Y - for about $10.

Re: Dust Collectors

#5

Re: Dust Collectors

bob heveri

>If you go with the Clearvue you won't regret it. I installed the Clearvue almost a year ago and you won't believe the suction produced by this cyclone. It is easy to install and if you have any problems Ed is very helpful.

Bob Heveri

Re: Dust Collectors

#6

Re: Dust Collectors

Stuart Hough

>What is the web address for the Clear-Vue systems manufacturer? I stumbled across it last year, but didn't write down or save it. It looks/sounds very efficient.

Re: Dust Collectors

#7

http://www.clearvuecyclones.com/ *LINK*

Bartee (metro Atlanta)

>Link !


http://www.clearvuecyclones.com/

Re: Dust Collectors

#8

Re: Dust Collectors

Grant in Iowa

>John,

I went through the same decision about two years ago when Griz first came out with their Cyclone line. After flip-flopping for a while between it and the Oneida offerings, I finally ordered a Grizzly 3HP cyclone with a canister filter. I waited for 6 weeks for it to ship, calling them weekly for a status or update which they couldn't provide. Finally I cancelled my order since, given the delayed delivery circumstances I couldn't be sure how quickly they could ship a replacement part should one be needed.

I hung up the phone and called Oneida. Much more personable, helpful, and professional on the phone. The phone tech gave me her email address so if I had any problems I could correspond with her at my convenience. I ordered their(then) newly introduced 2HP Dust Gorilla with the Baldor motor and it shipped the following morning via UPS. I had it in another two days. It was very well packed, very well designed and built and went together easily. It runs quietly and smoothly yet with authority.

I have used it extensively in the time since I bought it and have zero regrets or complaints. the 2HP is mucho plenty power to suck dust from whatever size home shop you are likely to devise. No comparison whatsoever to the average 2HP bag DC's, which pale by comparison. I can imagine upgrading almost any other tool in my shop ...Unisaw, 18" Bandsaw, 8" jointer, 15" planer, etc....except that is for the Gorilla. It greatly exceeded my expectations.

One thing to think about is that your Dust Collector motor will run as much as ALL of your other tools combined, and it will always start up under the load of the heavy blower fan. So get good one with a quality motor. I would be suspicious of Pacific Rim motors for this purpose, but that is just me.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Dust Collectors

#9

Re: http://www.clearvuecyclones.com/

Stuart Hough

>Thanx!

Re: Dust Collectors

#10

Re: http://www.clearvuecyclones.com/

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I put in a ClearVue Cyclone about 6 weeks ago, and am slowly converting from 4" to 6" ducting. One of the best tool buying experiences of my life.

Mark

Re: Dust Collectors

#11

Re: Dust Collectors

Josh in VA

>Grant,

Thanks for the info as I have really been flip flopping lately. I did get to put my hands on the Grizzly and was not disappointed. I am leaning more towards the Oneida route, but thinking about the cost difference as I could take the money saved and put into other tools. If I do go with the Grizzly I will pick it up off of the showroom floor so I will not have the delay in shipping (hopefully). Oneida has called me twice since I requested info which shows their commitment to the customer.

I do have some time before I install the Cyclone so I can kick it around some more, just was looking for some good info other than I bought XXXX and really like it.

Thanks for sharing your experience. It will weigh in my decision process.

Josh