How I stain walnut
Bill Tindal, E.TN
>This post is in response to some questions on staining walnut. I always stain walnut to keep it from bleaching. I use a pigmented oil stain. For years I used Sherwin Williams pigmented stain. Finally, I gave up because they reformulated every few years and I had to figure out a new color to order. Now I grind Lee Valley pigments in linseed oil. For walnut I use about half each of burnt umber and raw umber. Put the pigments in a mortar and pestle with linseed oil and grind away until thoroughly homogenized- 5 min or so.
I apply stain with a rag. Dip rag in stain and rub stain on until most of the stain is transfered from rag to wood and then repeat. My rag size just covered my index finger so were are talking about picking up a very small amount of stain each time. I expect to experiment with a shellac pad (a ball of wool in a rag) next time. When a surface covered by stained, wipe thoroughly with a clean rag. Be sure the pores get stain, best seen on low angle light. I only used about 5 mL of stain to do 10 sqft of drawer fronts.
People complain that stain "muddies" the appearance. I don't see this problem on a properly sanded surface. I sand walnut to 180 grit. When sanding with 180 there should be no dull spots. Dull spots mean the grain is roughed up and it is catching dust. Any place that catches sanding dust will catch stain and be blotchy. I suspect improper sanding is the cause of some objections to staining.
I always sand before staining, even if I have a perfectly hand planed surface. A planed surface has open pores and it will soak up stain like a sponge. I find it hard to control depth of staining on such a surface.
The picture is a drawer I stained yesterday. You can judge if it is blotchy or whether it has a muddy appearance and decide if you want to stain in the future or not.




