Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Posts

OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#1

OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Don in Northern Arizona

>A neighbor asked me to ask you guys for advice about noise-insulating the room where he practices guitar and drums. He has a 15 month old child and he wants to keep from disturbing the baby and mom while he becomes a rock legend. The room is about 12x14 and has two exterior cinder block walls and two interior sheet rock walls. He knows about acoustical foam, but wonders if he can do something more to the walls to keep sound totally in his fortress of solitude. Any ideas are welcome.

Thanks,

Don

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#2

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>There is an acoustics science with real experts in performing just the sound control your friend needs. It's important to a musician to not just contain the noise, but also not detract from the sound in the room. Is there a local college with a music department? They may have a facility with acoustic design features and may be able to suggest a resource person. There have been a couple of "music room" programs on Norm's TOH. Otherwise, I guess Google is your best bet.

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#3

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Paul Woolson

>Acoustic foam doesn't insulate, it just keeps the sound from bouncing around in the room. Very common misconception. To insulate, you want very hard, dense surfaces. The cement blocks are doing a good job but are wasted as the outside is not where they need the sound deadening.

It's a pretty tough job to soundproof a room. The best that can be done it to go over all the drywall with cement board (as thick as can be found) as well as doing the floor and ceiling. One of the big problems is that unless your friend does EVERY surface, it's wasted money. Also, don't let them buy acoustic foam unless they are using the room for a recording studio. That would be a complete waste of money.

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#4

How much money do they have budgeted?

Brian in Brighton

>You can get some really great sound deadening mats called Dyna-mat, but it would be very expensive. I also heard many layers of tar paper can be effective since the tar acts as a sound deadener.

I have a grand piano above my office and added Owens Corning Bagged insulation before the drywall went up and it is amazing the difference it can make. I would suggest as much thickness and he can stand. Maybe even build a second wall layer with insulation over a cement board and tar paper covered original wall.

Like I said, what is the budget?

Brian in Brighton.

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#5

Build a room within the room.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Prettymuch that's what you would have to do. All of the walls, ceiling, and new floor would have to have an airgap from the original walls of the room. The new floor would have to float from the original floor to keep the low end base drum freq. contained. Even with all that there would be a chance for a sound leak or vibration coupling somewhere.

There was an article, earlier this year, in "Fine Homebuilding" on a media room construction. There are some new metal rails that have rubber isolators to support the additional walls that were required.

It seemed like an expensive proposition.

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#6

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>I've got no expertise in this area at all but did provide a tiny bit of help for a neighbor building a sound recording studio in his home last year. He's the expert, not me.

He put sound insulation in the walls and cieling of the original room and then lined them with high density sheetrock. He then built another room within that room for the sound-proof booth where the recording artists do their magic. The booth is about 8ft x 10ft and is lined on all four walls and ceiling with 3-inch thick accoustic panels he bought from a studio being demolished. It has a raised floor that sits about 4 inches above the original floor of the room. He kept the carpet on the original floor, figuring it couldn't hurt and may actually help. There's sound insulation betweeen the raised floor and original carpet. Two double-glazed doors create a dead air-space (and four layers of glass) in the entry to the booth. They each open from opposite sides of the door jamb (i.e. one opens inwards to the booth, and one opens outwards) and they have rubber seals to stop noise leakage. Disaster Area could play in there and not upset anyone in the next room.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#7

Easiest way

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"...He has a 15 month old child and he wants to keep from disturbing the baby and mom while he becomes a rock legend...."

Tell him to grow up, and get a job, and look after his family. He's got a child now, he needs to get serious!

;) ;)

Or do what other musician fathers do: unplug the guitars, put foam in the drums, or go to a single guys place to rehearse.

Or just tell him to grow up. That's easier. ;) ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#8

Re: How much money do they have budgeted?

Don in Northern Arizona

>I think he will budget whatever is necessary to keep things peaceful and continue with his hobby.

Don

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#9

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Ernie Miller

>The best thing to do would be to eliminate any way for the walls celing and floors from viberating to the outside. basicly making the room float in the house sealed to prevent leaking of the sound. Don't attach the sound proofing to any ajoining walls or celing or if you do make it as minimal as possable. Find a way to suspend it inside the room with out attaching. want cheap? try 2" thick industrial air filters They may have enough opposing surfaces to bounce the sound waves every way but thru. The problem will be with the sound that travils thru the walls not the sound thru the air.

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#10

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Loftguy

>"The cement blocks are doing a good job but are wasted as the outside is not where they need the sound deadening."

Hi,

Nearby neighbours would probably disagree with that.

Bob

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#11

Yep. Here's how we did it

Michael Dresdner

>Eddie is right; you need a room within a room. We had to do this years ago for a recording studio on the second floor of an attached series of commercial spaces. Here are the steps we followed.

The floor was set on a 2x4 grid with rubber between all contacts of wood to existing floor and new secondary floor. In other words, no wood touched other wood without a rubber spacer. In between the areas formed by this grid were filled with sand before the second floor was attached. The walls and ceiling were done the same way, framed out with rubber sheet between all attachments and a hard surface (not sheetrock, but something like plywood or OSB) on the surface. The spaces between were filled not with sand but with fiberglass insulation, which my acoustical engineer described as a better (and cheaper) sound absorber than almost anything else.

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#12

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>I am assuming with the cinder block walls that the room in in the basement. First, rip the sheetrock off of the other two walls take the existing door and mount it on the outside of the room opening out. Put fiberglass in the exposed wall. put a layer of heavy rubber down and build another stun wall on it, Insulate that wall with fiberglass and move any electrical to the inside wall. Use fire code sheetrock and double sheet the wall keeping the joints staggard. mount a new solid core fire door on that wall opening in use a roller catch and not a door knop just some handles to open and close the door. line the inside of the outside door and the outside of the inside door with homasote several inches thick (a soft wood fiber sheet) or the like. Insulate the ceiling between the floor joists, rip down the old ceiling if necessary. pat the floor joists with rubber and screw firing strips through the rubber, put fire code sheetrock on the ceiling screwing it to the firing strips. paper tape and spackle all the joints on the walls and ceiling. Hang a suspended ceiling with fiberglass over the grid and acoustic ceiling tiles. put acoustical foam or carpet on the block and sheetrock walls so the music sounds better. It's going to get hot in that room, a self contained air-conditioned will be needed. Lighting should be below the ceiling and not recessed or in the grids. High density rubber can be gotten from conveyer belts or horse stall mats. It can also be ordered as a acoustical insulator If he wants to go the extra distance sheets of acoustical rubber can be hung on the walls and ceiling to further deaden the sound. This rubber could also be used on the floor it the room is not in a basement otherwise the non-basement floor would have to be isolated with rubber pads and an insulated floor built on top, covered with carpet. Or he could just unplug the amps and use rubber pads and deadened cymbles like the other future rock legends do. (but then that was already said)

A room like this was built a few years back to isolate a small orchestra so the microphones would not pick up the sounds from the larger room it was in. Outside the room you could hear that there was music but you could not tell from where it came.

bill

spelling, another art form

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#13

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

Bartee (metro Atlanta)

>This may sound a little odd, but put one of the walls out of square. This help dissipate the bouncing of sound off the ways. With 90 degree walls you can set up a resonance.

dense material does help dampen the sound. But layers of different materials is also necessary since some materials will aborb different frequencies.

Sound goes where air goes..... So you need to stop all the air from the room. This can get trickey when there are air conditioning ducks involved.....

That's just a start. Google for sound proof. You will get more than you can ever read...

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#14

Re: Try home theater forums

Paul Dwight

>Folks who build serious home theater spaces often invest a lot of time and money in making the room as sound proof as possible. Consequently, there's a lot of info about sound proofing in home theater forums and publications. For forums, try www.avsforum.com and www.hometheaterforum.com.

For interior walls, he should frame out a separate free-standing wall -- so that the drywall on the noisey side is not mechanically coupled to the drywall on the quiet side. Insulate with fiberglass bats between the two walls. The new walls should have two layers of sheet rock with joints staggered. Home theater builders often talk about using Green Glue (I think that's the right name) between the drywall layers -- it apparently remains pliable and helps stop vibrations from being transmitted between the layers. Doors should be solid core and thoroughly weatherstripped. Minimize the number of holes in the drywall by using surface mount light fixtures. Use foam sealant or caulk around electrical boxes.

Up to this point, most of what's involved is money and time. The real problem, I think, comes from HVAC. If the music room is going to be serviced by the same HVAC system as the main house, sound will inevitably travel through the duct work. I don't know how you'd stop that (or even effectively minimize it) without seriously degrading the performance of the HVAC system. I suppose the high-end solution would be to install a separate HVAC system for the music room.

So now I have to add a couple of gratuitous questions/suggestions for your neighbor. With one baby in the house and maybe more coming in the future, is he going to be able to hold onto this dedicated space? Every family I know of, mine included, has made significant adjustments to their living spaces to accomodate kids. Normally, this means less room for the adults. When your neighbor has a six-year old and a four-year old and toys spread all over the house, will his wife start to look at his music room and think, "Play room"?

What I'm getting at is that over the long haul, it might be a better investment to build a free standing building. It would be easier to adequately sound proof and might be less likely to be co-opted as play space for the kids or a guest room for the inlaws or whatever. Just a thought.

Hope something here helps. -- Paul

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#15

Great info here. Thanks, guys. I will pass it on

Don in Northern Arizona

>

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#16

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

jmohnike

>Back in the early 1960's I worked and helped convert an old school to a recording studio. Two of the exterior walls were rock the the rest were frame. The building was located at an intersection, with a stop sign, large trucks and other farm equipment created most of the noise to say nothing about the Hotrod Muscle cars of the day. Our objective was not to keep sound from exiting the room, but to keep exterior sounds from entering.

What we used was the old egg crate dividers. We nailed them to the walls,and celings and then covered the walls with 2 layers of "VERY THICK DRAPES" and the system worked very well.

We had various artis using the studio, Roy Orbison, Joe & Rose Mayphus, etc., this was not a back yard operation.

Most people think of the walls when it comes to sound and don't think about the celing. Sounds can go up into the attic where the open space acts like an amplifier so try and tread the celing as well, this can also apply to a floor which has a crawl space.

Joe

Re: OT Need help sound proofing a music room

#17

Just found this link...... *LINK*

Bartee ( Metro Atlanta )

>here it is


http://www.supressproducts.com/