Re: Try home theater forums
Paul Dwight
>Folks who build serious home theater spaces often invest a lot of time and money in making the room as sound proof as possible. Consequently, there's a lot of info about sound proofing in home theater forums and publications. For forums, try www.avsforum.com and www.hometheaterforum.com.
For interior walls, he should frame out a separate free-standing wall -- so that the drywall on the noisey side is not mechanically coupled to the drywall on the quiet side. Insulate with fiberglass bats between the two walls. The new walls should have two layers of sheet rock with joints staggered. Home theater builders often talk about using Green Glue (I think that's the right name) between the drywall layers -- it apparently remains pliable and helps stop vibrations from being transmitted between the layers. Doors should be solid core and thoroughly weatherstripped. Minimize the number of holes in the drywall by using surface mount light fixtures. Use foam sealant or caulk around electrical boxes.
Up to this point, most of what's involved is money and time. The real problem, I think, comes from HVAC. If the music room is going to be serviced by the same HVAC system as the main house, sound will inevitably travel through the duct work. I don't know how you'd stop that (or even effectively minimize it) without seriously degrading the performance of the HVAC system. I suppose the high-end solution would be to install a separate HVAC system for the music room.
So now I have to add a couple of gratuitous questions/suggestions for your neighbor. With one baby in the house and maybe more coming in the future, is he going to be able to hold onto this dedicated space? Every family I know of, mine included, has made significant adjustments to their living spaces to accomodate kids. Normally, this means less room for the adults. When your neighbor has a six-year old and a four-year old and toys spread all over the house, will his wife start to look at his music room and think, "Play room"?
What I'm getting at is that over the long haul, it might be a better investment to build a free standing building. It would be easier to adequately sound proof and might be less likely to be co-opted as play space for the kids or a guest room for the inlaws or whatever. Just a thought.
Hope something here helps. -- Paul