Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

OT: Photo Printer

Posts

OT: Photo Printer

#1

OT: Photo Printer

Dave's Not Here

>In the past I've gotten some great OT advice from the folks here so I'm hoping once again you all can help me out.

Last night my wife announced that she wanted a printer that is made for printing photo quality pictures from her digital camera. Neither of us have any idea what features are important when comparing brands.

A quick Google scan produced an article that stated that almost all the printers out there, from the cheapest to the most expensive, all produce about the same picture quality. It went on to say that the major difference between a $100 printer and a $500 printer was basically the feel good features on the more expensive models. Is this true?

We like the idea of only having to spend around $100 but we're also looking for quality too and are not afraid to spend more if we have to. Does anyone have any suggestions as to what make and models will give us the most bang for the buck? TIA.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#2

Re: OT: Photo Printer

Dan Donaldson

>I don't know about the features of the various photo printers, but when I looked at them, I finally decided that it was not worth buying one for me. I can pick the pictures that I want, upload them online and drive to the local photo place and get them in an hour for less than the ink costs in the printer, plus, they are using much better equipment than I could afford. Just something to think about depending on the businesses available in your area.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#3

Same here

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>I have an Epson blah blah (don't remember the model). It's supposed to have the good print engine. It does a fine job for sure (once you have all the color space setup correctly) but it's costly. Seems I was always buying ink! Pretty pricey to print something.

Then I found Costco...

I was told by a photographer friend of mine that Costco uses (Wal-Mart as well-but I try to avoid that place) a particular brand of printer that is also used by many high end so-called photo labs that print for pro's. For the price and convenience, they do a pretty darn good job. I rarely use my color printer anymore. Isn't worth the cost and hassle to me.

However, if you really want to buy a printer, fwiw I've read the best things on photography forums about Epson printers and photo quality printing.

Joe

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#4

Re: OT: Photo Printer

Dale Warder

>I use an Epson Stylus Photo R300. This is a low cost printer available nationally. I like the six cartridge ink system and the paper handling is much better than the Canon I replaced. As this is my only printer, photo or otherwise I was concerned how it would handle all kinds of print jobs. After a year of use, I can state very well.

Just my experience. YMMV.

Dale

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#5

Re: OT: Photo Printer

David Hay @ Denver

>We had a photo printer for a while, but we found that we never used it. It printed just fine, but in the time between printings, the ink cartridge head would dry out and I'd spend 15-20 minutes running cleaning cycles and printing test pages before I could print a real photo. We also discovered that the inks (or maybe it's the paper too) don't always hold up as well as real photos. After a few months, a photo I had sent my mom had faded pretty badly.

So we gave the printer away. Whenever we want photos, we just send them to the Walgreens down the street from us and they're ready for pick up 30 min later, usually.

David

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#6

Re: OT: Photo Printer

Tony - Memphis

>I think that is true among inkjets especially. I have an HP all in one that I was skeptical of at first because of the "all in one" features. But it prints great pictures (I am a hobby photographer). I forget the model nuumber, but it scans, faxes, prints, and copies. I don't print many pictures, but my wife is an artist and she paints from pictures she prints. She has been real happy with it too. This is our second HP inkjet. The first one printed just as well, but I wanted a scanner. I think the new one was aroud $130. I have some pics hanging here in my cube that sure don't look like something I did at home! My cartridges have never dried out and we don't print much (once a week or less).

Tony

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#7

I've got a couple

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>We've got a inexpensive $79 HP printer that uses two cartridges (color and black) and another "much better" one that uses the 3 cartidges (2 color and one black), which produces better quality photo prints. The cheap one actually does a good enough job.

Thing is we rarely use the "better" printer so the inkjet catridges dry up, and the inexpensive one needs new catridges and they cost almost as much as a new pritner.

So for the last few months, my wife takes the photos to Walmart to get them printed when she needs them. Much more economical and actually easier than fussing with these printers. When you add up the cost of the printer, paper and ink, it's cheaper at Walmart, and when you add up the time fussing with the printers, it's fast to get them done at Walmart since she's there for other things anyways.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#8

Re: OT: Photo Printer

robert davis

>i have an HP all in one for over a year can also recommend it..no problems

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#9

Lee Gordon

Re: OT: Photo Printer

Lee Gordon

>As a general rule of thumb with inkjets, the cheaper the printer, the more expensive the ink (on a cost per picture basis). So it may make more sense to bypass that $100 printer and go for one closer to $200 because it will actually cost you less in the long run.

And if you find that you use your printer so seldom that the ink tends to dry out between uses, it's not a bad idea to get into the habit of printing a single page of something -- anything -- once every week or two just to keep everything flowing.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#10

Lee Gordon

Forgot to mention ...

Lee Gordon

>I've had pretty good luck with HP printers.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#11

Re: OT: Photo Printer

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I have an Epson RX500, top of the line when I bought it. It won't run if any of the cartridges is near empty, even if you want to print a black and white document and the black cartridge is full. However, it will print stunningly good photos and can easily scan and print slides, negatives and black and white or color prints. This is nice for archiving your old stuff on a CD.

The other advantage of a home printer is the ability to print images you've manipulated in your computer using photo-editing software. To get these printed at a vendor's, you need to transfer the image to a disk and take the disk in. So it would save you a step in the process.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#12

Once was an Epson Rep

Craig in Silverdale

>By some strange reason, all our printers are Epson. For pictures, I still think Epson is the best. But before we go any further, do be advised that whether you get a Cannon, Hp or Epson, (these three are the top picks) none of these companies are in the printer business. They carry the printers so they can sell their ink. They make very little, if any profit on the printer itself.

The print engine on an Epson varies the size of the droplet as it heats the ink. The six color printers give absolutely remarkable true color pictures. Plus they give true black, where as the others mix the primary colors together to get a close to black. Stop off at Best buy with your camera disc and see if they have a rep in the store. IF not have one of the Best Buy guys print off your picture on each of the printers you may be interested in. I used too do this all the time and usually sent the customer home with an Epson. Best Buy gets a higher profit margin on HP's, so guess which ones they push?

I have a CX5400 3-in1, and the LOML has an old 820 printer and they both work great. Reason we haven't upgraded is, I still have lots of ink for both.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#13

Re: Once was an Epson Rep

Tony - Memphis

>Both of the HP's I've owned used a two cartridge system with one being black. The new one has the capability to use a tri-color photo cartridge in place of the normal black. The photo cartridge has black also. I experimented with the phot cartridge and it does make a better photo print.

One more thing to add is that the paper makes a HUGE difference in print quality. It amazes me that you can buy a $100 printer and some good paper and get somehting that looks so good out of it. Guess I'm getting old and still remembering the dot matrix days.

Tony

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#14

Re: Once was an Epson Rep

Bill Howatt

>Was at a photo presentation once and the speaker said the pros generally "Shoot Nikon and Print Epson".

Well, another persons opinion, anyway.

Bill

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#15

Re: OT: Photo Printer

Dan Donaldson

>Around here, I can just upload the picture, then go pick it up within an hour or less. Doesn't matter if it is a manipulated one.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#16

Re: actually

RK in Milwaukee

>the pros shoot Canon and print Epson.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#17

Re: OT: Photo Printer -pick your printer after you

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>price the cartridges. I refuse to pay the outrageous prices for the "Brand Name" cartridges. I am currently using an Epson Stylus PHOTO R200. This printer, IMHO does an excellent job of printing photos. I purchased a quantity of cartridges (generic) off the 'bay for less than $2.00 each - printer takes 6 cartridges so a full re-load runs me about $10. I have been using generics for about as long as Ink jets have been manufactured. I did use HP for awhile as we used HP at the Factory I worked for. I would take the empties from work and refill them. HP has the print head incorporated into the cartridge so they only function for so many fills. I got tired of the messy refilling so switched to Epson. I have had some of the higher end printers, and some of the highest end at work. I honestly can't see much difference in the output from the lower / middle class and the highest cost unit. May last longer and have more features - networking, higher speed, more paper capacity etc., none of which make a difference at my home. If I were you, I would look at the reviews at Cnet http://reviews.cnet.com/?tag=hd_ts Then I would look at Ebay and / or do a google search for the ink cartridges for the printer(s) you are interested in, if the cartridges are readily available, I would buy that printer. I use Pricewatch and normally purchase a printer from a vendor there. (If you don't want to buy off the net, at least you will find the actual selling prices) http://www.pricewatch.com/printers/

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#18

Re: OT: Photo Printer *LINK*

Ken Platt

>I noticed that no one mentioned the dedicated 4x6 photo printers, which use a different system for printing than inkjets. IIRC it's called dye-sub. I got a Hiti, (http://www.hitouchimaging.com/) and it's easy enough that my decidedly non-techie wife uses it happily. I haven't compared ink prices lately, but it was a lot cheaper per print than inkjets when I got it a couple years ago. The prints are as good as anything you can get from a photo lab.

Ken


http://www.hitouchimaging.com/

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#19

Thanks Everyone

Dave's Not Here

>Thanks all for the great feedback. Some of the first replies had some very good points where it was pointed out that maybe in the long run we would be better off money wise to just have Walgreen's print our pictures.

Those very valid points drove me to the conclusion that we indeed did not need this type of a printer. $100 saved immediately, happy guy! Well, silly me, I totally forgot about the want/need factor. All the logic in the world goes out the window when the wife decides she needs something. She would have made a terrible Vulcan. Once she has her sights set on something, want immediately turns into need. Of course when it comes to something new for my shop, I never suffer from this want/need syndrome.

So, because we really "needed" one, we now have an Epson Picture Mate PM240. The picture quality is actually very good and according to the propaganda on the $40 Print Pack we can expect to print 250 pictures before we have to replace the cartridge. That's about 16� a picture. The Print Pack also includes the paper to print those 250 pictures.

Re: OT: Photo Printer

#20

Re: actually

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>those are the pro's that are supplied their bodies and lenses by their editors. Their editors are given the equipment by Canon and/or at huge discount. In several years when they want to update to a new body they have no choice but to buy Canon because they have a bunch of Canon glass already. Great marketing by Canon.

Age old question, which is better Canon or Nikon. Who knows, they're all great cameras. Kinda like what's better a Chevy or a Ford? We all know the answer is BMW... :)

Joe