Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT --- installing wood floor

Posts

OT --- installing wood floor

#1

OT --- installing wood floor

Jim O in Davenport IA

>A friend was telling me about the flooring he is getting in a new home he is building. The flooring will be solid oak (3/4 x 5), not prefinished. His builder is telling him that it needs to be glued as well as nailed since it is wide. This sounds like a potential disaster. I recommended he go around to a few flooring stores and get second/third opinions.

Does this make any sense to you folks?

Re: OT --- installing wood floor

#2

Re: OT --- installing wood floor

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Traditional wide board floors are face nailed, often with three (or more) nails across the board. The middle nail prevents the board from crowning in the middle from seasonal humidity changes. Narrow boards are usually made with tongue and groove and nailed on the tongue only so no nails are visible in the finished floor. Since they are so narrow, cupping is not so much an issue.

At five inches, these boards are marginal for nailing on the tongue only, which is the way the builder probably wants to install them. He is worried about coming back to a problem if the boards crown or cup. Also with wider boards the cracks between boards are proportionately larger at low humidity. You are right to make sure gluing is a standard solution. The gluing will limit seasonal expansion and contraction, but I think not much more than nails across the board which also limit contraction in width, occaionally causing cracks at the ends of the board. The glue could possibly creep or fail rather than crack the board.

The problem is that people like the look of wood but do not want to tolerate its seasonal movement.

Re: OT --- installing wood floor

#3

Re: OT --- installing wood floor

Andy Halterman: We need more rain

>I believe the threshold for the glue starts at 6" and wider. I'm pretty sure that's what the Nat. Wood Flooring Assoc. recommends. Biggest issue with wider oak floors is how the wood was dried before milling. I've seem some just about get up and walk about on their own and others that laid down nice an then never moved at all. Other issues to think about are climate control in the new house, crawlspace humidity (around here by far the biggest problem) and what brand is the flooring. I'm not going to name names, but, there are several I simply won't work with anymore due to some seriously bad milling and drying practices.

Hope that helps a bit.

Andy Halterman

Wishing I was taking pictures of hats in compromising poses instead of working in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: OT --- installing wood floor

#4

Re: OT --- installing wood floor

Jim Dillon

>Jim,

Can't add much to the good advice you've gotten. Another option is to screw and plug the wide boards, but if they are all 4 inch wide, that might give you a rather "busy" looking floor, plus that lends to a more rustic look (which may not fit with your friends decor), and lastly, the floor installer might not want to put in the rather labor-intensive effort; personally, I love the look of the floor plugs. Bollinger's book mentions face-nailing or screwing plank flooring WIDER than 4 inches (no mention of adhesive use). So you are kinda in the middle. My gut feeling is that if the wood is well dried, acclimated to the house, and there are no household moisture problems, regular tongue-and-groove nailing should suffice. Speaking of which, you didn't say if this flooring was normal tongue-and-groove flooring or just planks. If the latter, then I would go with face-nailing or screwing; I don't think adhesives would be needed. Keep in mind, I'm just a DIYer, so my advice is worth what you are paying for it 8-).

As an aside, there was a thread on wood floor movement (or non-movement) a day or so ago that might be of interest to you. Good luck.

Jim