Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

PC557: sloppy buscuits

Posts

PC557: sloppy buscuits

#1

PC557: sloppy buscuits

Bob McGovern

>Been having some trouble getting my 557 to cut consistent-gauge slots or maintain proper alignment during the compression stroke. Anyone else here experienced that? Then, recently, it began binding on the in & not retracting properly on the out stroke. The sliding surfaces were clean and lubed with graphite, but I was getting improper-depth slots & kickback when the tool would bind and suddenly release, diving into maple at high speeds. For a tool used in indexing parts and relying for joinery strength on tight tolerances, this is an obvious problem.

Equally obvious is the cause of the problem: the motor unit slides in a keyway -- both bare aluminum. Which builds up oxides, which act as grinding compound, which leads, after many cycles, to slop and binding. Duh. (Doesn't the Lamello have bearing-equipped ways?) PC's 'gibs,' if you can call them that, are not built for tightening as wear occurs.

Two years of occasional use seems a short life span on a $250 tool. Called PC, then regional service rep. Both hinted they were aware of the issue, but wanted $125 plus shipping & tax to repair it. Lovely. It's your design flaw, PC! How about addressing it at your own cost?

So, having nothing to lose, I picked up a hammer. (This will end in tears.) Found judicious peening of the keyways with a centerpunch or nail set will remove the slop from the slides. Trying light machine oil to fend off future oxidation; hope it doesn't get onto the wood. So if you have a balky PC577, it's okay to hit it with a hammer. G'won. You'll fell better. And save a bundle of money.

Re: PC557: sloppy buscuits

#2

For buscuits read biscuits

Bob McGovern

>Two English degrees, wasted.

Re: PC557: sloppy buscuits

#3

Mine still works great

Ellis Walentine, Host

>...after more than 10 years of occasional use, including a real torture test last year on my ipe porch. The only time it got balky was when the ipe dust really started to build up in all the ways. A squirt of compressed air and some silicone spray had it working fine again in no time.

Regarding alignment, I assume you're talking about being out of parallel to the face of the board you're joining. That is a defect that many biscuit joiners have right out of the box. I always tell people to check for this immediately and to return the tool if it isn't within a few thousandths of parallel, because opposing tilted slots make it downright exciting to try to assemble a joint. Maybe yours was a little off to begin with.

Not much help here, but thanks for the peening info.

Ellis Walentine, host

Re: PC557: sloppy buscuits

#4

You Are Keen To Peen

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Thanks Bob,

Well we have a friend in Texas who alters his router's capability by throwing it on the floor! First I heard of P+C biscuit joiner problems, other than the extraordinary cost of replacement blades. I bought the P+C for #3 son, who as a finish carpenter, uses it very often. I'll ask him to examine the tool for ease of plunge and wear of ways. One fifty to fix! I got a recon DeWalt about 10 years ago, and it wasn't much more than that. Its still perfect, mostly because I hardly ever use it.

George

Re: PC557: sloppy buscuits

#5

G&E

Bob McGovern

>Ellis: Nah, I mean the joiner had enough vertical play that two boards would not align flush on their reference faces. You could grasp the carriage with one hand and twist the barrel with the other, and you'd see & feel about 2/100ths" of play. This also led to sloppy biscuit (or buscuit) fit, as the cutter tended to 'widen' the slot on its way back out, due to the lash.

Interesting to read the various reviews on Amazon and such; people either love this tool or hate it, and many have developed tweaks to make it work better.

It's a heavy, solid beastie wih a nifty fence design. I just think aluminum-on-aluminum bearing surfaces is inherently a stupid idea. (For another, PC's cheap pancake compressors hold the cylinder head on with hardened steel cap screws ... tapped into aluminum threads. Heat, vibration, pressure, and galvanic corrosion do the rest. Those cylinder heads fly some distance. Thru bolt 'em, people!)

Re: PC557: sloppy buscuits

#6

Interesting

Ellis Walentine, Host

>So the vertical play is a primary concern... What could that have to do with other than the fence position?

Ellis

Re: PC557: sloppy buscuits

#7

Re: Interesting

Bob McGovern

>Fence is fine. Very rigid on my unit. It's the actual sliding carriage that has developed vertical play. I only use it one or two sessions per week; almost wonder if that promotes oxide buildup? More time for the AlOx to form. But mostly I think I got a sloppy unit to begin with, and it's just gotten sloppier. A real menace when, for instance, trying to achieve perfect seaming of solid-surface countertops.

Here's a snip from the Burns Tool site, explaining why Lamello uses hardened ways/bearings on their slides, to prevent slop (implying it is a problem with, e.g., aluminum slides):

"4. Inner Slides. Lamellos surface treated, high precision slide system makes up and down play almost too small to measure, even after thousands of hours of use.

Other manufacturers offer sloppy inner slides often with as much as 0.20 up and down play right out of the box. Some manufacturers even equip their machines with soft plastic inner slides to get long life at the expense of precision.

Plate joiners are supposed to provide accurate alignment between wood parts.

Can you afford to buy a plate joiner that wont even provide accurate alignment?"

At $150 factory reconditioning for the PC557, I'd say the answer is no. But hammers come cheap. :)

Re: PC557: sloppy buscuits

#8

I fixed a Dewalt one time

Derek

>I bought the part and replaced it myself - pretty easy. You might see what P-C wants for the replacement parts. I bet they are $30-40 which is far less than $125 and certainly less than a Lamelo costs!

I suspect your peening job might not last too long since aluminum is pretty soft.