Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Help needed salvaging a project...

Posts

Help needed salvaging a project...

#1

Help needed salvaging a project...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

Every time I take a pay job, something ends up going wrong. This time iI have really goofed. I am building some bookshelves and I just realized that I cut the rabbet (1/4" wide x 3/8" deep) for the backs of the shelves on the wrong edge of half of my side pieces. The sides are plywood, and there is going to be a face frame on the shelves.

Does anyone have any bright suggestion on what to do?

I could patch it. I still have some strips of plywood laying around that I could piece back together into the groove and then hope no one notices. I would need to splice it once down the length of the upper part of the shleves. At least I would not have to do this with solid wood. Do you think the stain job would look bad doing this?

I could really use some help here. I really do not need to get another piece of plywood for this job.

Thanks in advance,

Rob Hix

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#2

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

DB

>The other night my wife was laying on the bed with her head at the foot of the bed. I said "honey your head is at the wrong end". She responded "no, it has always been that way.

Is it possible to just flip half of the sides over and use what you are calling the top, as the bottom. Maybe to much machining has already been done. Could put a matching dado or was that a rabbit on the other edges and filling it with a different wood as an accent. If it is a rabbit then you might be able to cut it off but then the shelves would not be as deep. Would that be a problem?

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

Dale Lenz

>Hi Rob,

Show me someone that has worked wood for say 5 years and they have done the same thing, or close to it, know I certain have. Two things come to mind: 1. "patch" with a contrasting wood, maybe do the same "edge" affect on the front(?). 2. Patch with plywood and then cover with slightly wider molding or trim. There are many ways of fixing this problem, often the project turns out better than the original idea.

Good luck and let us know how it turns out.

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#4

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

Wess in NJ

>Couldn't you just cut the rabbets off all the pieces and start over. Your bookcase would loose a little depth but is 3/8 really going to matter?

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#5

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

Kirk (KC) Constable

>A paying job? Get another piece of plywood and do it right. There's a time to 'make do' and a time to suck it up.

KC

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#6

Ellis Walentine

Can you explain a little more?

Ellis Walentine

>I'm not visualizing the problem, Rob, so it's hard for me to come up with an answer. Edge of the side pieces? What is the mistake that is visible? You don't have exposed plywood edges, do you?

Slow on the uptake here...

Ellis

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#7

Help us help you

David Yoho

>Rob, I'm with Ellis on this. I can't picture what you're doing.

I just realized that I cut the rabbet (1/4" wide x 3/8" deep) for the backs of the shelves on the wrong edge of half of my side pieces.

There might be a way around this issue but a better explanation is needed on your construction first.

I know you don't want to hear this but you need to be prepared to buy more material if there's no suitable fix. I think it's happened to most of us that make things for paying customers. It's a hard way to learn a lesson but one that will stay with you.

David

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#8

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>1. Rabbet ALL the edges.

2. The two on the back will receive the rear panel as planned.

3. The two front edges will have a strip of solid wood matching the face frame material glued on to fill the notch flush at the edge and flush with the face frame's inner edge. When asked, this is your style to give a stronger face frame because the strip is glued to the face grain of the ply and the face frame is then affixed to more solid wood rather than just to the edge/end grain of the plywood.

The pic shows a cross section of the suggestion. The dotted line is an option .

"Everyone makes mistakes. The measure of a craftsman is how well he can hide his."

Who knows, you might start a whole new contruction style! |;-}}

mm


img

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#9

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>BTDT

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#10

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

Mark in Whitby

>I have to agree with an earlier post. Start again, suck it up.

You might spin the error with a complex WW'ing explanation the client doesn't understand, but they also likely don't care about it either. They agreed to pay for a quality handmade "perfect" bookcase, cheap they can get at Walmart

Perhaps they start to think it looks weird or unusual, or some friend or family member tells them it looks like a patch job to fix your screw up, then they'll be disappointed and your reputation takes the hit.

Of course small indetectable patches here or there that are not visible or central to the construction is a different story( thats the character of handmade!) This sounds bigger more visible?

IMHO throw it on the scrap heap and start again, you'll feel better about the project,the transaction, and have a customer reference you can use if you keep building for pay.

These words of questionable wisdom and limited experience are brought to you from the top of a very high scrap heap constructed with several "scew ups, stupid ,idiotic, how could I do that" build for pay mistakes!

Good luck

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

#11

Re: Help needed salvaging a project...

arw01

>Patch it, then put a piece of moulding down the back edge. Also you could do a faux raised panel that is covered in moulding by wrapping the whole edge with the moulding.

Alan