Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Stapler vs brad nailer?

Posts

Stapler vs brad nailer?

#1

Stapler vs brad nailer?

Robert Henderson

>Rockler has a good price on a reconditioned porter-cable NS100AR staple gun.

I already have a brad nailer, so my question is...

When are stapes better than brads?

If you have one do you need the other?

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

Ellis Walentine

>Staples offer more holding power than brads, because they have two legs and a crown that spans the wood fibers of the piece you are attaching. This makes them great for low-end drawer boxes, picture frames and other constructions that don't need to have the degree of refinement that a discreet brad has.

If you do a lot of utilitarian stuff (and who doesn't?) a stapler will definitely come in handy. You'll quickly figure out when to grab the staple gun instead of the brad nailer.

My 2¢

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#3

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Robert,

A brad nailer is a real staple in my shop/ :<)

George

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#4

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

Rob Sandow

>Well, lets see. My collection includes a 23 ga pinner, a 18 ga brad gun, a 15 ga finish nailer, a framing nailer, an 1/4" crown stapler, and an electric 1/2" crown stapler,

Each one has been useful but if I needed to give one of them up, it would be the 1/4" crown stapler. It's too much for screens and other lightweight stuff that the electric staple gun excels at. It tears right through screens and papers. And like a framing nailer, it's pretty much only for construction grade work because the staple heads are ugly. On the other hand, the staples are too lightweight for a lot of serious construction.

I'm not saying not to buy it, but there are limited situations where it's useful. You'll find it's the perfect tool on occasion, though.

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#5

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

Paul Dwight

>My number one use for my narrow-crown stapler is slapping together jigs for the shop. A little glue, a few staples, and off we go. I love it for this purpose. They've become so inexpensive that if mine died, I'd buy another just for knocking together jigs. -- Paul

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#6

Ellis nailed it.

Barry Irby

>

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#7

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

Don henthorn

>I've got a huge oak entertainment center that is constructed so that the only rack prevention comes from 1/4" masonite panels on part of the back. These are stapled on and really don't do the job. I am thinking of removing the staples, and replacing them with #8 pan head screws placed about every five inches. I don't have a lot of faith in staples. I think they are tenacious enough but have too much give.

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#8

Would anyone recommend a Pin Nailer?

Greg Deavers in Stillwater

>Speaking of Brad nailer could someone recommend a decent pin nailer for the fine "locating" or holding delicate pieces?

Thanks Very Much!

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#9

Re: Would anyone recommend a Pin Nailer?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Don't know how "good" it is but I purchased one from Harbor Freight -on sale it was $12.49. I bought it as information from other here at WC thought it was a fairly good gun. I have used it a few times. Actually use it again today. Seems to do the job fine. I haven't used it a lot - but for less than $15.00, don't think I can go wrong. I sets the 1" pins perfectly in white oak. I would recommend it for the type of use I have - occasional, hobby shop. Heck it may work as well as the $169 units, however it is limited to maximum 1" pins. I can't compare as I don't (and won't) have one. The pin goes in without leaving any mark on the wood surface. Hasn't jammed - don't know what else it should do! If you do want to purchase one at that price use the item number 93656-1BEB. You have to use that number using the "order from catalog" function on their site. Kind of difficult to find the sale priced items from the catalogs. They also have the pins - were on sale for $.99 to $2.99 a box (I think 6,000 per box.

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#10

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

Jim Dillon

>Robert,

I have a narrow crown stapler (as well as a wide crown stapler for upholstery/insulation work) and find it to be occasionally very useful. I used it to attach 1/4 inch plywood back panels to kitchen cabinets and more recently to staple 1/4 inch to 1/4 inch cedar for garden tuteurs. I had to spend some time adjusting the pressure so the staple wouldn't blow through, but once I got that, things worked fine. For applications that require really strong connections and won't be too noticible, they work well. However, I use my brad nailer a lot more. If you can get a good price on a stapler, go for it.

Jim

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#11

Re: Would anyone recommend a Pin Nailer?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Greg,

I use the Harbor Freight gun. It satisfies my needs perfectly. We also have a P+C and Senco pinner in the family, owned by #1 and #3 sons. They all work very well and leave no discernable footprint. I like the way the Senco feels better than the other two--but at the price of the HF pinner, I will live completely happy ever after. :<)

George

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#12

Ellis Walentine

Thought I *stapled* it. :-)

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

#13

Re: Stapler vs brad nailer?

Dan Manturi

>I have not used my stapler for woodworking, but it was great when I redid my kitchen floor. Put in a 1/4" underlayment and banged the staples in - whole thing was done in no time and they held very well. Have since used on two other similar floor projects.

The best part is that is was a real cheap tool (Reliant or something) I got on close out at a store. Works flawlessly!

Dan M.