Re: Debunking the "flooring expansion" issue
Dave Mount, NE Minnesota
>You can fit the flooring tight on all sides of your hearth. The "gap for expansion" thing in wood strip flooring is an interesting convention. The fact is that wood floors don't (under normal circumstances) don't move as a unit -- the expansion is taken up at each individual joint, not at the edges. Think about it; if the floor expanded 3/4" at the edges during the summer (and the expansion would be way more than that if it was a 15' wide board), it would pull the nails at the edges and it would never go back the following winter. Also, you couldn't ever install a floor with a border, because the border would be pushed apart when the floor moved. A direct observation is that (unfortunately) I'm still missing a few pieces of baseboard in the house and the gap at the edge of the floor doesn't change dimension seasonally, it's the same today as it was when I laid it (OK, I don't have a caliper on it, but no perceptible movement). Another example is at the door thresholds where I laid the flooring to within 1/8" of the threshold and caulked the gap -- nothing has ever moved, the whole thing is stable.
Movement being taken up at the joints between individual boards is also why you don't glue the edges of solid wood flooring -- it would panelize the floor and it would start to move like one huge board.
So why does everyone say "leave a 1/2" for expansion"? Good question. Here's my belief of why it may be important. As I've explained, it is not needed under ordinary circumstances. But, it may be needed under extraordinary circumstances, i.e., catastrophic wetting of the floor. The power of expanding wood is incredible, and the amount a floor would expand if it were actually wetted to the fiber saturation point is way more than what would occur under normal seasonal cycles. Using figures from Hoadley's book, I calculate that a flatsawn red oak floor 15' wide would expand by over 12" going from 7% MC to 30% MC. An 80' wide hard maple floor (like gym or ballroom) would expand over 6 feet! I've seen pictures of things like gym floors that got flooded, and it's amazing to see the floor pulled up out of the subfloor and sitting there in "standing waves" as it curls in a sine wave to take up all the expanded width.
So how does this relate to flooring in a house? My thought is that a gap at the edge (and only along the long grain edge, obviously) is there so a catastrophically expanding floor doesn't push the walls out. Sounds crazy, but think about it. If there's a gap, then by the time the flooring edge reaches the sill plate, the nails holding it to the subfloor will be largely pulled from the subfloor (not completely maybe, but largely), which will allow the pressure from the expanding floor to be taken up vertically by buckling. If the floor were still firmly attached to the subfloor, the pressure would be applied more directly outward to the sill plate. The same would be generally true for glued floors -- the flooring to subfloor bond would have to be broken before the flooring reached the sill plates.
So getting back to your question, if you have a hearth in the mix, there's no need to leave a gap around it if it's in the middle of the floor (meaning that the front edge of it has the flooring strips butted into it), you can fit it tight on all sides. If it is at one side of the floor (i.e., you're laying flooring into it or away from it and the flooring is parallel to the front edge of the hearth), then you can still fit it tight, just leave the gap between the back of the hearth and the wall.
I'll caveat all this by saying that it is the only explanation I've ever come up with to explain something that is otherwise nonsensical. I've never had this theory affirmed by anyone with any authoritative knowledge; but then again, I've never had it countered by anyone with any authoritative knowledge. I actually wrote to Fine Homebuilding and presented this argument after they had an article on flooring that had the "1/2" for expansion" bit in it, but they didn't respond. As above I argued above, just the existence of floors with borders completely debunks the idea that the floor is moving perceptibly as a unit under normal circumstances. So if not that, why?
Another possible explanation is that gaps were originally left simply because there was no need to fit it tightly when it would be covered by baseboards and the expansion thing just grew up on its own. However, I hate to invoke an argument that the whole thing is a myth if there could be a rational explanation related to expansion.
If Andy Halterman (or anyone else in the flooring biz) is still hanging around, I'd be interested to hear his take on this. . .
Best,
Dave