Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

More durable, E white or W red cedar?

Posts

More durable, E white or W red cedar?

#1

More durable, E white or W red cedar?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>My sister is building a small deck, and has access to both lumber species. She asked me which one was the most durable (price was similar). I must admit I didn't have an answer. I know both are durable, comparing the two never crossed my mind.

Does anyone know the answer?

TIA,

DC

Re: More durable, E white or W red cedar?

#2

Re: More durable, E white or W red cedar?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I'd vote for western red as being a slight bit more durable. E white seems to be just a bit softer. My deck is w red, and it seems to be holding up pretty well. We just can't get much white around here, although it seems to be preferred for canoe building - a little more flexible.

Bruce

Re: More durable, E white or W red cedar?

#3

Re: More durable, E white or W red cedar?

Steve Schoene

>However, the advantage of white cedar is that it weathers to silvery grey while red cedar weathers to a much darker almost charcoal grey.

Re: More durable, E white or W red cedar?

#4

Re: Depends on the quality *LINK*

Dave Mount

>All other things being equal, Western red is a little stronger and harder by most measures (link to detailed info below). However, things are not always equal. I'd be looking also at the quality of wood you're getting with each species. Wood that was growing slowly will be stronger than wood that was growing fast. Edge grain decking will hold up much better than flatsawn, and will resist cupping and grain separation. And, of course, knots introduce both aesthetic and (potentially) structural issues.

Bottom line, the difference in base properties is not significant compared to the influence of other quality factors.

Best,

Dave


Link to Forest Products Lab handbook