Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Help in resolving workbench design questions

Posts

Help in resolving workbench design questions

#1

Help in resolving workbench design questions

Guy in Cuba

>Hi all,

I am a teacher and traveling to my western Virginia mountain vacation home this weekend to stay for the summer, and I got it in my head to build a woodworking bench. After two months of research, I think I am settling on a bench that is a combination of Christopher Schwarz's Roubo workbench (Woodworking magazine Autumn 2005 and Popular Woodworking June 2007) and Cliff's bench (at www.user.dccnet.com/cedwards/bench/bench.htm). I already purchased the vises and the major tools for the job, but most of my hand tools remain here in Cuba, even though I can still throw one in the suit case if need be.

The major decisions I am still trying to resolve is whether to build the top or buy one? Second, if I make the top, what to make it out of? And third, what size should it be?

Many of the benchtop builders glue and plane the top in sections and then biscuit the sections together. One builder dowels each board so that the boards will remain aligned during glue-up. The school shop teacher says to just nail the boards in the middle to ensure reasonable alignment, to not get a warped fan look. Some slabs I see even have metal rods going through the width. It seems that warping during glue-up is a concern. So, wanting a flat top when I get done, I am a little concerned about whether I should attempt to build a top or buy one. I do have a good router and have considered routing the top with a track and sled arrangement that others have done. I figure my top will be about 40 to 45 board feet, so materials could be anywhere from $100 to $400 before gluing. Perfect Plank (www.perfectplank.com) sells almost what I want in maple, 2 7/8" thick x 25" x 8' for $334. So what should I do, make or buy?

If I do build the top, I was first lured to Christopher Schwarz's article, where he makes his bench out of Southern yellow pine. Fair idea, until the hardness and density of yellow pine is compared to other woods. The hardness of yellow pine is about half that of birch, oak, beech, maple, and almost a third of harder woods like hickory. Yellow pine's density is classified as a light wood. I like Christopher Schwarz's articles, but I am not sure about this choice of wood for my bench, a bench that I would like to think will last a long time and be passed along in the family. I live near Independence, VA. Any information on what I should/could make the bench out of?

Lastly, I am still deciding on the size of the bench top. Again I like Schwarz's rationale for a 24" deep top, perhaps leaning towards a couple of inches more. I have a shop space of 12' x 24', and am tending towards making the top about 75" long, and after the vises are installed would make it about 7' long. I would like the top to be at least 2.25" with 3 to 4" being better. Schwarz makes his 4" thick and that seems to work well with the pinch vise he has, which I also want to include. So folks, what do you think, what size should provide the best benchtop?

Thank-you in advance for all input,

Guy

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#2

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

Jesse in New Mexico

>Hey Guy,

Well, here's my two cents worth... Life is short, buy the top! There's lots of things more fun and more educational in woodworking than gluing up big chunks of maple. Especially if you are limited in what tools you will have in your workshop.

The size of the top depends on what kind of woodworking you do. If you work with wide panels a lot, then a wide bench with extra rows of dogholes would be the cat's meow. If you work on small pieces with lots of handtools, then an easily reachable tool tray on a narrow bench might ring your bell.

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#3

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Guy,

What Schwartz said about the depth of the bench makes a lot of sense if you have to reach over it to access wall hung tools. I think the real message was in the joinery and mass of the trestle undercarriage.

George

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#4

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

Christopher Schwarz

>Guy,

I hope I can help provide some clarity with your bench-building enterprise.

On gluing up a top, it's always time vs. money when you weigh building vs. buying. There is no one answer. If you build the top, there is no need to use mechanical fasteners (biscuit, nail, bolt, spline etc.) to provide strength. Yellow glue is stonger than the wood itself. These mechanical fasteners might help alignment during assembly, but if you work the top lamination in small batches, I know you'll do fine without fasteners.

As to Southern yellow pine, I think you need to look at all the numbers. While yellow pine might be low on the Janka scale (resistance to denting), it has a higher e-value (modulous of elasticity) than European beech or hard maple. In other words, it is stiffer than both species. And its specific gravity (weight compared to water) is similar to that of maple. I think the resistance to denting is less important than stiffness and weight. I've built 10 benches with the stuff and have no long-term complaints.

As to the width, I think you are on the right track. A super wide bench can make things difficult when assembling things.

If you need *any* follow-up here, please send me a message or respond here. I'm always happy to help.

Chris

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#5

The mass of the base was the big message

Guy in Cuba

>Thank-you. You are right, Schwarz based his bench philosophy on mass and stoutness. Since my bench will be resting on a concrete slab, I thought that treated lumber, which is southern yellow pine, might work quite well for the base structure. I was thinking of making the top of something else.

I also think that the 24" depth is a good design and allows better reaching over it.

Now do I make the top or do I buy it?

Guy

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#6

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

Jake (SoMN)

>I disagree on the wide bench. It depends on if you are planning on working from both sides or one. My bench is 42" wide, and I work from both sides. I am also 6'4" and have a very long reach.

I would thnk about shrinking it up if it was going to be against a wall though.

I have benches made from both southern yellow pine and maple. Both have worked out well... I like the look of the pine, it has more charachter. It is really a matter of personal prefference.

Jake

(remove the 2 for email)

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#7

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

Ernie Miller

>A good #6 or #7 hand plane will make that to flat in no time with out any jigs or sleds It took me less than two hours to flatten my top and it is 2 times as wide as Chris suggests. I would go with a narrower top as per heis ideas as I can see merrits to it but with the storage under my bench I will live with what I have. I would just glue tow or three poards together at a time untill it is built. I think there is a place called Balley block out in that area and you can get a nice maple top pretty cheap I would check into that. have fun!

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#8

Re: The mass of the base was the big message

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Guy,

If you lived closer, you could buy a glued up counter-top from Bally Block in Bally PA. Rock Maple, and very nice prices. I would tend to buy the top panel rather than make it, because of the time involved. You can always bore dog and hold fast holes to suit your needs. Its your call.

George

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#9

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

Hank Knight

>Guy,

When I decided to build my bench, the thought of struggling with a huge glue-up for the top was not appealing. I opted to buy a laminated maple slab from Bally Block in Pennsylvania and build my top around it. I glued 8/4 dog hole strips and a 3/4 apron to both sides and added maple end caps to complete the top. It worked great and I'm very happy with the bench top.

Bally Block is located in Bally Pennsylvania, South of Allentown. It is too far for me to drive from SC, so I had to buy my slab through a local distributor and pay full retail price. Even so, I'd do it again if I were building another bench.

Bally manufactures laminated maple couter tops for high-end commercial applications. Any slab that has a cosmetic defect, such as an off-color board in the laminate, is rejected as a "second." These defects do not affect the function of a slab for workbench purposes. More important, Bally sells "seconds" at the factory, dirt cheap. The difference in retail price and the price of a factory second at the plant would probably justify your taking the time to drive to Bally. You could make the trip in a day from W.Va., and it would take you a week to laminate your own top.

As for how wide to make your bench, I believe that is a matter of personal preference; although there is a lot of merit to the comments that a wide top is unwieldy if the bench is pushed up against a wall. My top is 32" wide, but my bench is in the middle of my shop and I can work around it from all sides. If it were pushed up against a wall, I certainly wouldn't want it any wider than that, and narrower would probably be better.

I also think the selection of materials for your bench is a matter of personal preference. If you search this Board, you will find bench tops made of many different kinds of wood - oak, maple, beech, ash, douglas fir, various tropical hardwoods and Southern yellow pine. Chris Schwartz is right about SYP, it gets a bad rap as a "soft wood." It is relatively hard compared to other "soft woods" and it takes abuse well. I personally don't care for it because it is so common here in SC. I wanted something a little different for my bench, so I chose maple. But I think SYP would be fine and it is certainly more economical than other options.

Good luck with your bench. It sounds like a great Summer project.

Hank

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#10

Re: The mass of the base was the big message

Darrin

>Guy,

You don't need pressure treated wood. Whatever design you use; once you have the base built; chamfer ther feet slightly and coat the end grain with epoxy. That is what I did with mine, I have no problems with moisture wicking up from the concrete. FWIW, my bench is totallay DouglasFir.

Darrin


img

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#11

Good point about coating the bottom

Guy Belleman

>Coating the bottom of the legs with epoxy seems like a great idea. Thanks, Guy

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#12

I had looked at Bally Block

Guy Belleman

>...but since their maximum top thickness is 2 1/4" I passed over them. If they have good prices on "seconds" it may be prudent to give them a call.

Thanks, Guy

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#13

Lots of wood numbers to consider

Guy Belleman

>Chris,

After reviewing this site thoroughly

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/fplgtr/fplgtr113/ch04.pdf

I see that many of the numbers for wood characteristics do put pine on an even consideration for use in a workbench.

Thanks, Guy

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#14

Look Again

Hank Knight

>My slab from Bally is 3" thick. It was a standard item, but I special ordered it unfinished with square edges.

Re: Help in resolving workbench design questions

#15

Some decisions made on bench

Guy in Cuba

>Thought I would provide an update.

I made a quicky workbench to work on. Found a local lumber seller, selling rough cut lumber out of a small barn, and purchased about 96 bdft of hemlock 2x4s and 1x6s for $57. The extra mass of real 2x4s made the base heavy and stable. Made the base out of the rough cut following the plan at www.eaa1000.av.org/technic1/worktabl/tablefig.htm Came out great. Making the 2 inch thick top out of planed boards. I will post a picture when it is finished.

Finding a good source of wood for the quality bench I want to build has been problematic. The Lowes stores near my location list their construction boards as "white wood" and on some as "european white wood" so I was pretty sure that is not southern yellow pine.

I think I was lucky to find listing in a local ads weekly paper for some white oak beams from a contractor. 4"x8"x10's and 5"x12"x14's that are s4s and have been drying out for 6 months, that were left over from a construction project. A lot more board feet than I am going to need. Some checking, but not much, and the price was about $.67 per bdft. Seems like a good alternative to making my version of Schwartz's bench.

I know the white oak will have some large grain pores, so any ideas for perhaps filling in the surface of the top, or not, would be helpful.

Thank-you,

Guy