Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Design help: accent table

Posts

Design help: accent table

#1

Design help: accent table

David Hay @ Denver

>I'm thinking of making an accent table that was in WOOD magainze a few years ago. But, as most of us do, I'm tinkering with the design. I wanted to get some feedback on my ideas. Here's the original table as it appeared in the magazine (Issue 150, September 2003):


And my idea is below (compliments of Google SketchUp). Basically, the legs in the original design feel kinda "flat" to me. So I was thinking of thickening them from 3/4" to 1 1/2". I can't quite decide if it makes the table look too clunky or not.

Thoughts?

David


img

Re: Design help: accent table

#2

Top is too small. Needs +4" in diameter

HC Sakman

>

Re: Design help: accent table

#3

Ellis Walentine

A matter of taste

Ellis Walentine

>I think that thickening the legs a bit is a good move, but at 1 1/2" they start looking pretty hefty, especially for a top of that size and thickness. If it were my design, I would probably beef the legs up to 1 1/8" or so, thin the stretchers down a bit and change their curvature. I'd also make the top a bit thicker, but that is not a big factor.

The thing that bugs me about that design is how the rail/leg joints are made. The curve on the underside of the rail stops shy of the tenon shoulder, so you have a step between the leg and rail. In my mind, it would be better to either conjoin those curves or make the stretchers visually independent of the little foot detail.

Ellis

Re: Design help: accent table

#4

Re: Design help: accent table

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon David,

I agree with Chico that the top and leg assembly would be better balanced if the top were larger. I favor your idea about increasing the leg thickness to one inch or a square cross section, however I would seriously consider chamfering the vertical exterior edges between the feet and upper rails. I'd also consider a chamfer on the interior edges of the legs.

I thiink you are going to have a lot of suggestions on this one.

The old addage about too many cook spoiling the broth is applicable. At the end of the day, it'll be your table. Do what is most appealing to you and your wife.

George

Re: Design help: accent table

#5

Re: Design help: One more Cook

Craig in Silverdale

>I agree the legs could use a little fattening up. Perhaps an inch in thickness, however with an 1/8 to 3/16" contrasting wood inlay down the center of the leg. Also, I'd round over the outer edges of the legs. I do agree with George though, in the end it's your piece of work. Have fun with the project.

Re: Design help: accent table

#6

How about phi?

Neal in San Jose

>Can you work in one of the classic proportions? If you are shooting for a height of 30 inches, then divide that by phi (1.618) for a top diameter of 18.54 (18 1/2 would be close enough), so the table would fit into a golden rectangle. Overall proportions are visable from much further away than the size/proportions of individual components.

Re: Design help: accent table

#7

My 2C

Howard In Toronto

>The original looks like the legs taper UPWARD.

If so, that's an interesting touch.

Your rendering makes me think they're a uniform width along their height.

If so, would you reconsider integrating the original picture's reverse taper?

I agrre with Ellis's observation re visual "clunkiness" by using 1 1/2" for the legs - 1 to 1 1/8" would give them a great-looking "lushness".

As for the top, I agree with Chico (how can you NOT) re the top's diameter.

But I'd be inclined to use the same thickness as the legs for the top too - that, 1 to 1 1/8".

My 2C.

Howard

Re: Design help: accent table

#8

And I rather like it as it is... ,

David Barnett - SW Florida

>seeing it as a slightly wide but lightly constructed display pedastal, which just goes to Ellis' point on taste. A lot would depend on intended placement and use, how it fits into the decor.

Re: Design help: accent table

#9

Re: My 2C

David Hay @ Denver

>In the original, as well as in my version, the legs have a slight taper from the top of the outer curve to the top of the leg...only 1/2 inch over that length.

David

Re: Design help: accent table

#10

Thanks!

David Hay @ Denver

>Thanks everyone! I have a lot of ideas to work with now. I'll try out a few and see what I think.

David