Re: sun test not recommended + other thoughts
Dave Mount
>Some of this is going to sound like I disagree with Bill. This is only partially true -- it would be more accurate to say that I think Bill's response is carrying some assumptions that may not necessarily apply to you.
First, I don't recommend the "sun test" Bill mentions. Virtually any air dried piece is likely to cup under this test, even if it's dried down to 10-12% (which, as Bill says, is as far as you're likely to get unless you live in pretty arid country). Weighing, oven drying, and reweighing, though it's a pain, is a better way to tell where you are. Alternatively, if you have a hardwood retailer around, they might be willing to stick the piece with a meter for you (buy something while you're there to pay back the favor; do not brag to them about your home-brew wood as they are not there to help you avoid having to buy wood from them).
Comments about whether air dried is dry enough for furniture depends on your assumptions. It is true that hardwood used for commercial furniture manufacture is brought down to lower MC than your wood likely is before being used. However, it would be incorrect to extend this to imply that the wood is too wet for you to use in building furniture. As long as you realize that in a conditioned environment the wood is likely to go lower after you build the piece, and build it to accommodate that kind of movement, you can build with that wood. IMHO, quality furniture should be built to easily withstand a range of say 4% to 15% moisture content.
I've built quite a bit if furniture over the last 15 years and almost all has been built with air-dried wood (my father has a small sawmill, but no kiln). I dry it on sticks to 12% (I have a meter), the store it dead-packed (without stickers) as Bill suggests in unheated but weatherproof outbuildings. I usually bring it into the shop for 3 weeks or so on stickers before I build; if it is winter, this will bring the MC down further, but not so in the summer. The important thing is that all the wood is at the same MC, whether that is 5% or 12%. After all, if I were to buy KD wood and keep it in my shop in the summer, it would soon be at 10-12% anyway.
In all the pieces I've built, only twice have I had problems with wood movement. Both can be traced to moisture issues that were secondarily related to me using air dried lumber, but the primary problem was my failure to build with that in mind. One example was when I didn't have any birch in the shop for drawer boxes for a case piece built of walnut that had been held in the shop in the winter. Without thinking it through, I got some birch from storage, milled it immediately and dovetailed the drawer together. Because the birch sides and walnut front were at different MC, the birch later shrank and the walnut didn't, which created a small lip at the bottom of the drawer front and also created some very small cracks at a couple of the dovetails. The failure was not catastrophic, but regardless, it would have been completely prevented had I acclimated the birch to the shop first.
The other failure related to some shop sawn veneer that I made from osage orange which, again, I got straight from the barn in the winter, sawed it into 1/10" thickness without acclimating and immediately veneered it onto a plywood substrate which had been in the (heated to 50 F) shop. The finished piece ended up developing a few very small checks in the veneer from shrinkage, which was caused by a combination of my impatience and using fairly thick veneer. Thinner veneer would probably have acclimated in an hour to the shop MC anyway, and would also have withstood any remaining shrinkage better.
There are some caveats here. The primary one relates to things like inset drawers. If you want "piston fit" drawers, you will face some challenge building with wood at 12% as piston fit at 12% will be less than that at typical inside-the-house MC. However, I don't find this is a problem, as piston fit drawers are an invitation to sticking drawers unless the environment of the finished piece is very tightly controlled. I live in northeast MN, and we don't have/need AC. As a result, with windows wide open on a summer night, the humidity in our house can get pretty high. On the flip side, when it's -20 F and the air to air exchanger running, the humidity in house in the winter is exceptionally low. Furniture exposed to these swings are not going to have piston fit drawers year around. I build with the idea that the drawer will be tight at about 12% MC will have some gap below that.
There have been past discussions here about whether a moisture meter is a necessity if you're drying your own wood. My position, and I think that of many others, is that no, it's not a necessity. However, it does make life easier, particularly if you don't always plan ahead adequately (like me) and want to know if you can "marry" wood with different acclimation history.
My somewhat more that $0.02,
Dave