Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

Posts

Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#1

Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

Gareth

>Hi:

I am looking to buy a new bandsaw for a precision cutting project. (wood puzzles where I need to make very straight and very reproducible cuts at difficult angles on small triangles of wood).

Thus, I was drawn to the Sears 12" bandsaw because it has two T grooves which I thought might be helpful guiding a jig I'll make for the cuts. But, a kind woodworker suggested that a Sears tool was not ideal for precision work. And that 1 groove on a Delta was better than two on a Sears.

Question: Would I be better off with a $350 Delta or the Sears $350 12" model? What model Delta? Any other advice would be much appreciated. I am new to bandsaws.

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#2

Wood puzzles there is an expert

Dustmaker Mike

>around here on that subject.

As for the Bandsaw. The trick is to get one that the blade tarcks straight. I have not seen either one (Sears or Deltas), but from the smallers ones I have seen I would stay away from a three wheeler. Also check around you may be able to find a Good Used 14 inch Jet or Delta that will out do the 12 inch by a long shot.

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#3

Re: Scrollsaw?

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>My take on bandsaws is that those tabletop models are not really serious machines and I wouldn't call any bandsaw "accurate". But if you're reproducing bunches of 1/4" thick puzzle parts, a good 14-incher will allow you to stack and cut quite a few pieces of wood so that each would be the same.

Don't most puzzle makers use a scrollsaw?

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#4

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

john lucas

>I agree. The cheap two wheel 14" bandsaws are far better than the table top bandsaws. Been there done that. The 14" jet or Delta are much better machines than the cheap taiwanese (even though they may be made in the same country)

I would consider the Dewalt scroll saw. With some practice you can cut extremely accurate cuts and who knows you may want to cut curve puzzle pieces. The scroll saw is much better at this.

If all you want to make are straight sided pieces I would consider a disc sander. If your making duplicates of the same piece all the time you can rough cut them on any bandsaw, table saw or miter saw and then fine tune them on the disc sander. Get Malcolm Tibbets book on segmented turning and it shows you how.

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#5

Re: Scrollsaw?

Gareth

>The puzzle I'm working on is not a traditional jigsaw puzzle type. I actually did try to use a scrollsaw to make the straight cuts I need but it didn't do a good job.

I need to cut a very thin slot (paper thin) into the corners of triangular blocks. Then just go about 3/4 of an inch. It is for a sheet metal piece to slip into. It turns out to be difficult to get the cut to start in on a sharp corner without shifting to one side or the other.

I tried it on a bandsaw at work (big metal cutting machine) and it did a nice job, though it was a heavy blade and was a bit too thick.

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#6

While I'm loyal to . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>Craftsman, the small band saw ( 9 ", 2 wheel ) ain't a box of Cheerios for precision. Considering what I paid it does everything I ask of it wich is rough-out work. I know, I know, there is a raft of after market do-dads to improve performance but I never have the time or patience to spend tinkering with it. On all the shows that use band saws the more accurate seem to be the big floor models with bigger blades. As of yet I just can't justify the cost of one. Wich does'nt mean I don't drool on them !

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#7

Re: Scrollsaw?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>Two idea come to mind

1. Can you cut the slot first and then make the triangle edges meet there?

2. With completed triangles, can you sandwich them between a piece of plexiglass (transparent) and a thin piece of hardboard, and then cut the sandwich. The blade will have less tendency to wander in the sandwich. I know plexiglass has a tendency to reform/heat up on a scroll saw, so you'd have to keep things moving.

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#8

Re: Wood puzzles there is an expert

Falberg saw Co

>Once again the conventional wisdom is completely off track in regards to two wheel/three wheel design comparison. Industrial applications favor the multiple-wheeled approach because it's basically more efficient. Industrial three and four wheelers generally use better components: bearings, wheels, frames, etc. throughout and they are far superior to any two-wheeled consumer bandsaw in terms of power requirements and blade life. The biggest difference between two and three wheel designs is cost. Three wheelers require bigger and stronger frames, more efficient wheels and bearings, more sophisticated tensioning systems, and more complex alignments.

Three wheelers of the consumer/hobby variety have generally been made to compete throat-wise with the cheaper two-wheel models and historically they do this by using the cheapest parts obtainable; such as *plastic* wheels and even *plastic* wheel bearings, if you can believe that. Nonetheless, you CAN get a lot of good use from even a dirt-cheap three-wheeler if you correctly understand the basics of cutting with a thin strip of steel.

The ancients used treadle-powered strands of diamond-saturated silk to cut jade which was extremely crude compared to the slick sophistication of my first plastic-bearinged three wheeled cheapo bandsaw. In either case, it's the blade, not the machine, that makes the cut. The machine is only there to move the blade. What makes a machine efficient is the elimination of vibration, friction, and heat build-up on the moving parts; regardless how many wheels are used.

If cost is your main consideration, get the cheapest used bandsaw you can find. They're all the same.

While there are virtually no differences in quality between the umpteen brands of two-wheeled bandsaws, there is a world of difference between the brands of blade you can put into those machines. ALL of them are good; for something. FEW of them will cut more than 4" deep without drifting. Unfortunately, two-wheeled consumer bandsaws are so inefficient, machine-wise, that their throats are constricted to an average 10" cut depth and you need a 1HP motor to even start those big cast iron wheels turning. There just isn't enough reserve power to cut big workpieces so the blade manufacturers don't bother supplying blades for deeper cuts. There's no market; and thin kerf blades are so much more profitable to make and sell. *FLAT* cuts are not even mentioned in their ads.

Cheapo saw + quality (set) blade > Expensive saw + cheapo (unset)blade. ;<)

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#9

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I am sure that many will disagree with me, but a band saw is not a precision cutting tool. You can tune it up all you want, get it to track true and use the best blades but in the end it still will not produce a cut that does not require further finish work. Nor will it produce acurate repeatable diminsional cuts suaitable for joinery with out fitting with a chisel or plane.

On the question of size, noumber of wheels, and benchtop vs floor; it is somewhat an issue of finding the machine that is easiest for you to use and keep it tuned up. I have two friends who own Inca bandsaws which are three wheel bench top machines. they have a very loyal fan base who swear by their acuracy.

For you application you may wish to also consider something like what I did recently. I made a fixture to hold the hand piece for my Fordom gringer and installed a small slitting saw. it is basically a miniature table saw and makes a kerf for 28g sheet metal. I used it to make dados for drawer bottoms for a jewlrey box, but you may be able to adapt it for your application.

Robin Corell


img

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#10

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

Gareth

>Robin:

How wide is the slit that you get. I'm not sure how thick 28gram sheet metal is. But, that sounds like a good idea!

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#11

This Sounds like

Dustmaker Mike

>the ones I have seen.

"Three wheelers of the consumer/hobby variety have generally been made to compete throat-wise with the cheaper two-wheel models and historically they do this by using the cheapest parts obtainable; such as *plastic* wheels and even *plastic* wheel bearings, if you can believe that."

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#12

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

Jerry Samsen

>Have you considered on of those small table top table saws? I forget the brand but it has maybe a 4" blade or smaller. I don't think the price scales with the size so still not cheap. You could probably do a high percentage of your cuts with that and use a japanese pull saw to the what you can't get to with the small saw.

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#13

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw? *LINK*

knotscott

>I can't comment on the Delta, but I've had the 12" Rikon made Craftsman since September and it's a pretty nice machine with some nice features and good capacity.

I added a set of Timberwolf blades and some ABEC 5 roller blade bearings, and am good to go.


Sears 22400 BS

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#14

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

Dennis Yoder

>You can get a wide range of saw widths from Enco.

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#15

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

R. L. Tracy

>You could look at a Jet 12" A GOOD machine at a very decent price, most of the features of a 14' but in a slightly smaller package.

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#16

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

Gareth

>Thanks very much.

I will take your advice and replace the roller bearings. Is ABEC 5 the full part number I need to order? Is the company ABEC?

Thanks again.

Gareth

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

#17

Re: Delta or Sears for a small bandsaw?

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>ABEC 5 is the bearing grade, not the part number. Take the old bearing to a bearing supply house. they will measure it and find the replacement.

Al