Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Box joint fit/ glue up question

Posts

Box joint fit/ glue up question

#1

Box joint fit/ glue up question

Pat Evans

>I built a 10" high box from Lowe's cheapest pine. (Trust me... that's the sorriest wood on the market, but I thought it would suffice for a strictly utilitarian box.) After 7 tries, I got the box joint jig adjusted to what I thought was a good fit. I could push the joints together with just hand pressure and there were no obvious gaps. However, after applying TiteBond III, the joints were almost too tight to get together. I applied glue to one end and fit it up, then did the other end and applied cauls and clamps. The first end apparently set up enough that it never did pull up as tightly as I hoped.

What did I do wrong?

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

#2

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

David Yoho

>I've had that experience with box joints before. You didn't say what size box joints you used but even at 3/8 - 1/2 inches, that's a lot over a ten-inch span. Even though they fit together with only hand pressure when dry, I think the glue either caused a little swelling of the wood around the joints or it started sticking sooner than you clamped it. Maybe this would've worked better with liquid hide glue - at least it has for me.

David

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

#3

1/2" joints; outdoor box

Pat Evans

>Thanks David. The joints were 1/2" and yes, there were a lot of them. Since the box will be used outdoors, I thought the TiteBond would be better than hide glue.

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

#4

Re: 1/2" joints; outdoor box

John in New Mexico

>you could try poly glue, its slippery. I've had the same thing happen, but I'm usually using baltic birch plywood, so I just use lots of clamping pressure.

One question though, if you're using the cheapest of pine outdoors, how long do you expect it to last? If you keep it well painted to protect the wood, that ought to protect the glue as well, so you could use hide glue.

John

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

#5

Re: 1/2" joints; outdoor box

Pat Evans

>Thanks John. I don't expect this box to last indefinitely, and I will repaint it annually. I just assumed that the inherent moisture from outdoor humidity would weaken hide glue regardless of paint protection.

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

#6

Yeah, I wouldn't...

David Yoho

>I wouldn't use hide glue for your intended purpose. The point of using it was it would give you a longer open time, which would allow you to close the joint easier. Still, there are other glue choices with longer open time that would work for outdoors.

David

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

#7

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

Jim Dillon

>Pat,

This is one of those woodworking experiences that you learn from and next time try to make the box-joint just a tad looser. I had the same experience after making a fancy box-joint jig for my table saw. Well, of coarse, I wanted to try it out. Got that perfect snug dry fit on an 8 inch plywood drawer and then applied glue. Long story short, I ended up beating the heck out of the joint to get it to seat. So don't be discouraged. If you prime (2-coats) and paint (2-3 coats) that pine box, it should hold up reasonably well outdoors. Oh, it might help to glue the drawer box two sides at a time (keeping everything very square) rather than trying to do all four sides at once. Then combine them.

Jim

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

#8

A minor variation...

Jim Dillon

>... on the glue-up procedure. As mentioned before, apply glue to two opposite corners and assemble them. Then, without applying glue to the two remaining corners, assembly the entire box and check for square etc. Allow the glue to dry, disassemble, apply glue to the remaining two corners and reassemble (don't forget the drawer bottom 8-)). You might also try using masking tape on the interior next to the joint to help with glue squeeze-out. And because box-joints are so darn strong with so much glue surface-area, maybe using less glue would help; I had a REAL mess the first time I glued a drawer up. Thank goodness it was just a shop drawer.

Jim

Re: Box joint fit/ glue up question

#9

Pine+box joint+water-based glue

Rob Sandow

>Your glue swelled the wood. That joint is particularly susceptible to swelling if you wet it because of all the surface area, and white pine will suck up a lot of water. Your Titebond III PVA glue is water-based. So basically what you did was a combination of 3 things, any 2 of which would have been fine. For example:

Box joint, pine, polyurethane glue

Pine, splined miter, PVA glue

Box joint, cherry, PVA glue

Rob