Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT: Welding

Posts

OT: Welding

#1

OT: Welding

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>I'm getting the opportunity to learn some welding on a Lincoln arc welding from Lowe's, from a 89 year old gentleman that likes me to come over and practice. Another 89 year old fellow that I work for would like to buy me some welding equipment if I'd like to really learn.

So, what do I need? I'd like to be able to weld around the farm - a busted piece on a bush hog, fix a plow, etc. - and I'd like to be able to make a few things for my shop - maybe some tracking to install a winch in the ceiling to pick up large bowl blanks for my VB, make some tool rests and tools. I'm using an arc welder, and I've heard of stick welder, MIG and TIG? Any advice guys?

Thanks!

David

Re: OT: Welding

#2

Re: OT: Welding

Bill McDonald

>I have a cheap mig and a nice tig....I love my tig hands down....

Re: OT: Welding

#3

For your situation

Ed Snow

>A nice arc welder would be perfect. The tig and the mig at a reasonable price will not have the power to do some of the maintenance tasks that you would like to. An arc welder on the other hand will. Easy to use, reasonable consumables, ability to work on larger objects.

Re: OT: Welding

#4

Re: OT: Welding - long reply

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Asking what do I need to weld is kind of like asking what saw do I need to cut some boards to make furniture, decks - cabinets etc. You will get about as many answers to your welding question.

First a basic primer on the types of welders available and their typical uses.

1)Arc welder: These can be a simple AC (alternating current) "buzz box" or a AC/DC (AC + selectable direct current) , or an AC variable frequency welders (some may also have DC capability). All of these welders are also called �stick welders� as they use a stick (welding rod with a flux coating). The �buzz box� is the cheapest welder available � it is also the hardest to learn to weld with IMHO. Normally these type welders are typical used to weld 1/8� to � � mild steel / iron (180 amp versions). Arc welders normally require 220 volt input and are available with outputs from 120 to 300 Amp. (I have a 295 Amp buzz-box). Slightly thinner steel can be welded with some training � down to about 1/16�. With higher amperage units thicker metal can be welded. With the variable frequency control, very thin materials can be welded and the arc is very easy to strike and maintain. The DC capable units have better control of the weld penetration, can weld thicker material (IMHO) better and it is easier to strike and maintain an arc with the DC.

2)MIG welders: These are Metal Inert Gas welders. These use a wire which is automatically fed from the end of the electrode, the wire takes the place of the �welding rod�. These originally were equipped with a tank of compressed gas � usually Argon or Argon / CO2 mixture. This gas is automatically fed through the electrode, bathing the welding area in an inert gas � this prevents oxidation of the welded material. There is also a cheaper version which used �Flux core wire� � The flux core emits a gas during the welding which also prevents oxidation. The Flux core is only available for mild steels. The Gas fed version of these welders are capable of welding steel, Stainless steel, aluminum etc., when used with the proper shielding gas and wire. Most MIGS are more expensive than the comparable Arc welders. Typical uses of these welders are thin material 1/32� to max. �� � with the normal units sold for home use. These are very easy to learn and use. These are available as 120 Volt and 220 Volt input units. Amperage varies from 85 to 250 Amp. (I have a 115 Amp MIG).

3)TIG welders: These are Tungsten Inert Gas welders. These have an electrode with a replaceable tungsten point; the arc is struck between the tungsten electrode and the work-piece. Inert gas is automatically fed around the arc during the welding process. The welding material (bare wire type rod) is fed into the arc with your other hand, somewhat like soldering. These are capable of welding very thin to thick material and will weld Aluminum, steel and other materials. These are fairly easy to learn and very versatile � also a good unit is quite expensive. I have welded with a TIG a couple of times, but do not own one.

4)One thing I would recommend is a decent �auto-darkening� helmet. These have a (almost) clear lens that allows you to see the welding area until the arc is struck. Then they immediately darken to prevent eye damage. These cost $50 for a cheap one to 2 or 3 hundred for the best. They can be used with all types of welders.

My suggestion to you is that you continue to learn the welding process. After you have became proficient in welding with the arc / stick welder, you can decide if you need any other type. A decent buzz box can be purchased for a couple hundred or so. A MIG will run $300 and up + gas tank. In my opinion I don�t see you justifying a TIG � A decent unit will run a couple thousand or more + tank.

Re: OT: Welding

#5

Re: OT: Welding

Paul Waddle

>I've welded some,but just get by. I'm wondering,can one silver solder steel with a tig??? Looks like it would get the metal hot very quickly. pw

Re: OT: Welding

#6

Re: OT: Welding

john lucas

>I've done a fair amount of silver soldering and I think you need a torch. I use a Mapp gas torch at home and an LP and oxygen torch when I can go to the Craft Center to work.

Re: OT: Welding

#7

Re: OT: Welding - long reply

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Larry,

I've got a lot going on right now, and I really appreciate you taken the time to write such a concise, helpful explanation of what has had me very confused. I know this question, like many others, gets asked a million times on boards like this one, but there's no place quite like WC. I'll be looking through the archives for any more tidbits of info, which I should have done before asking I suppose, but I do thank you for your time and expertise.

At the moment I'm going to look into the arc welders, and see what it would take to get to the AC-DC stuff.

Thanks!

David

Re: OT: Welding

#8

Re: OT: Welding

Bill McDonald

>would not want to waste a tig unit on silver solder....but.....I have seen them used to solder all kinds of metals. Copper, gold, brass......

Re: OT: Welding

#9

Rick L

Re: OT: An arc welder is...

Rick L

>stick welder. In my opionion and experience as a Metalsmith, the best thing to start with a an oxy-acetylene torch. A bit of a learning curve but you can cut, bend, braze, weld. Definitely the basics to move onto Tig. Arc is crude and takes quite a bit of practice but the nice thing is they are pretty cheap and common and can easily be converted to a basic scratch start tig. Mig is the weasiest to learn. Gas type mig is cleaner than flux wire. All in all the torch would be my recommendation to start with as it's the most versatile and even with an arc or mig or tig, I'd never get rid of my torch. Cordless too!

Re: OT: Welding

#10

From the tasks you list....

John in New Mexico

>I'd say find a Lincoln arc welder, they're all over the place, and usually pretty reasonable used. Once you get the hang of it, you can do most tasks with one, and the weld is nice and strong.

John

Re: OT: Welding

#11

Re: OT: Welding

Pete LaBelle

>A stick AC buzz box will get you most places, though there is a technique learning curve. Takes a lot of practice to weld thin metal.

If you are planning on welding a lot of thinner (less than 1/4") CLEAN metal, a wire welder is pretty cool. If your work involves a lot of heavier (1/4"+ old iron (dirt, rust, paint, etc), a stick welder with the right rod will be better for you.

As mentioned, learn to weld first. Just because you own a welder doesn't make you a welder. Scares me those guys who proclaim,"damn thing........welded it 5 times now and it broke again ! "

Re: OT: Welding

#12

Check out local high school adult-ed

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Years ago, I enrolled in an adult education shop class at the local high school for peanuts. I was taught how to gas weld and braze, stick weld and mig weld. We were able to concentrate on any area we wanted. I personally saw no use for the exotic (to me) TIG welder.

bottom line, I came away with a good enough understanding of welding to know what I'd buy if ever needed my own machine. Nice thing about the class was that you got to bring in any project you wanted. I made a ski-rack and roll cage for my Jeep. Used stick welder on the ski-rack and mig welded all the tubing together for the roll cage.

You may want to look into this as an inexpensive way to learn about all the different techniques. Worked for me.

Re: OT: Welding

#13

Re: OT: Welding

jmohnike

>I have an old Linc. buzz box stick welder. It has served me well over the years and has done everything I needed to do with it.

I would suggest you start with a stick welder. I have a wirefeed which I never use. I also have a oxy/act which I use from time to time.

The big advantage I find with a stick welder is that I can get welding rod almost anywhere and for almost any kind of job.

You will also need a good angle grinder.

Learn from the old timers and get a good book not a welding for dummies but a real book.

Hit the junk dealers for scrap metal and pratice, pratice, pratice.

Have fun and good luck.

Joe

Re: OT: Welding

#14

Re: OT: Welding

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Yeah Pete, I have seen some "welds" that I wouldn't trust as far as an epoxied joint. I learned to weld in High School shop. I went to a small school in a rural community so we had a LOT of farm equipment brought in to repair. I was pretty good with a stick then - (50 years ago!). I did a lot of cutting with torch when I was a lad. I have welded intermittently since then, mostly stick and Mig - though I used a good friends TIG - we welded all the seams and rivets in my aluminum Jon boat. I still can get two pieces stuck together - but taint near as prutty as it was then. I really like the MIG I have for light work. And in reality 99% of items I weld now are light. I still have my buzz box for the heavy stuff. Usually let my boy weld with it as he is a lot steadier than I now (and can get down on the floor and back up).

Re: OT: Welding

#15

Thanks guys!

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>You all have helped a lot. Doc bought me a welding handbook, and it's great. I'm a few chapters in and learning from a fire hydrant of information in a world of stuff that I know so little about.

I did get an ancient buzz box today though - it's a 50-60 year Sears stick welder, with some heavy duty, extra long leads on it. It's working right now, but it's a little jury rigged with the wiring and it's cord. So I'm going to clean it up a bit, and hopefully have something to learn on.

The list is endless though! An oxyacetylene torch for cutting and some welding, a table, vise, c-clamps and vise-grips and on and on and on! Thanks for all the help though.

David

Re: OT: Welding

#16

Re: Thanks guys!

Bill Howatt

>Yes, you can embark on another round of tool and supply purchases.

When I started fooling with welding I bought a metal cutting bandsaw which I have found to be very useful for cutting up long stock and also for metal cutting unrelated to welding (like the too long after-market tool-post for my lathe). Others have found chop saws to be handy.

I did buy an autodarkening helmet which I like and I think are great for hobbyists. I always lived in fear of an accidental arc flash.

You can do very crude cutting with an buzz-box by cranking the amps up full (around 200) and blasting the metal with a 6011 rod. Naturally, this only works with thinner metal, it isn't going to blow through 3/8" thick steel.

Bill