Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

Posts

What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

#1

What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

Dan Manturi

>Redoing my stepson's kitchen - another in a series of questions and you folks have always given me good advice. The doors are flush doors make with 50 year old solid core Mahogany veneer plywood - nicely grained, not the luan garbage. Veneer is quite thick, and this plywood is in amazing condition. I plan on lightly getting the dirt off with a scotchbrite and maybe a little TSP, letting it dry well, and then running through a Performax with a little 220 grit to freshen up the doors. However, instead of just putting some wipe on poly and remounting them, I was toying with the idea of making a frame around them (say a 2" frame) to change the look. Not sure what solid wood goes well with mahogany (except maybe some more mahogany). Do not want a light frame around the darker mahogany. Also not looking to break the bank on exotic stuff.

Suggestions welcome.

Dan M.

Re: What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

#2

Re: What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

Steve Schoene

>Satinwood, berhaps with beeswing mottling.

By the way, while the veneer may be a lot thicker than on modern doors I'd be doubtful that it is thick enough to withstand the Performax sanding.

Re: What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

#3

Ellis Walentine

Couple things....

Ellis Walentine

>What does the rest of the kitchen look like? What is the color scheme of the walls, floors, counters? What's the flavor of the house itself? (modern, colonial, victorian, etc. -- sorry, I can't recall your earlier posts on this)

Personally, I like doors that are the same species for the frames and panels, but that is a personal choice. If you really want a contrasting wood, cherry isn't a bad choice, but I think there is a nest of snakes in this exercise, because cherry or even new mahogany is going to be a lot lighter than aged mahogany veneer, so you will have to go through a bunch of other hoops to selectively stain the frames without staining the panels. If you sand the mahogany face veneers on the existing doors (which I wouldn't attempt unless they are at least a 1/16" thickness, and maybe not even then), it will probably not lighten them to the point of matching new wood. Old veneer ages through and through.

Another point, not to be the wet blanket here, is that you are dealing with existing panels that are (presumably) the same nominal thickness as the frames you propose to make, or else you plan to make thicker frames to inset the panels. You don't have the option of fielding the panels, since they are veneered and not solid; so your design must take into account a flush relationship of the panels to the frames. I like to leave a gap between the frame and panel to accentuate this relationship. Since you are dealing with plywood, you can rabbet the existing doors so they fit almost exactly into the frames and glue them in the final assembly to create very substantial doors.

Before you commit to any of this, I think you might want to see what the scraped/sanded veneers actually look like. If there is a backside of a door that you can use for experimentation, I'd recommend trying it. And, consider staining everything after you make the new doors, since that will be your best shot at a uniform appearance. If you want the contrast, skip the stain step.

Two longwinded cents.

Ellis

Re: What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

#4

Re: What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

Kelby

>Ebony and mahogany is a great combination.

While you probably wouldn't want to use actual ebony, you could ebonize (i.e., dye black) a less expensive hardwood and frame the panels with that. Rather than a traditional frame-and-panel cabinet door with a 2" frame like you mentioned, you could try a very thin border (maybe 1/4" or 3/8") out of an ebonized hardwood. I think it would look great.

Re: What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

#5

The house (long).

Dan Manturi

>Thanks for the suggestions. This veneer is actually about 1/16th thick. Understand that I'd be looking at frame material on the order of 7/8th thick for a slight difference in the field and frame. Like two suggestions and one is the gap between a frame and field. The other interesting thought, and less work, is a very thin border. Had not considered that. I do have some material to play with - when I installed the dishwasher, I had to remove an existing cabinet and a half (there was no dishwasher originally), so this will tell me how the existing material stands up to sanding even a light pass.

Ellis, the existing counter tops are 1950's canary yellow Formica. While my perverse sense likes it, and it is in good shape, we will, for now, replace it with laminate, and if he decides a few years in the future to get a totally new kitchen, then he can decide on the new material for the counter. Cannot beat laminate, dollar for dollar. Th entire kitchen is mahogany, with the walls covered with a nicely figured 1/4" plywood. Even the soffits are mahogany. Too much mahogany. These walls are getting replaces with sheetrock. The home itself is an all brick split and the LR and DR have 3/4" mahogany T&G walls on 3 sides that I redid nicely and one stone wall with fireplace, oak hardwood floors (that turned out OK - thanks to info from this site). Sort of a Frank Lloyd Wright look. He must have had a mahogany merchant in the family.

All floor joists are 3x12 stock that was harvested from a church that was being torn down. I remember when the home inspector went through and saw the size of the beams, he said "Holy xxxx!" and I remarked, Yes, they came from a church. Walls are real plasterboard and a plaster top. I'll tell you, a thrill watching your kid fix up his first home and helping where you can...

Anyway, I got a couple of good ideas here. Either Mahogany or an ebondized border would create a different, refreshed look.

Thanks again!!

Dan M

Re: What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

#6

How about walnut?

Charles Sharp

>

Re: What wood goes well with Mahogany (cabinet)

#7

Re: How about walnut?

Dan Manturi

>Got to think about that but good suggestion.