Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

Posts

After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#1

After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

Peter Gregory

>I have a ROS, but not Festool, and nothing else. What sanding device do you have, that I need? An edge sander looks very handy. The big belt sanders seem pretty expensive. I'm not into curves right now, so I don't think I want a Norm-esk spindle sander.

Thanks for any advice.

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#2

depends on how much there is to do

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I rough sand with an air driven ROS and always finish sand furniture by hand. Nothing equals the control of hand sanding. Of course if you are finishing house trim or run a cabinet shop hand sanding might be less practical.

I almost never use a belt sander any more. In spite of years of practice it still sometimes badly screws up surfaces in my hands.

Editorial: The more experienced I became the less I was inclined to think some power tool was the answer to all woodworking tasks, especially so in a "hobby shop". Just file this thought away and later on think about it when tempted to buy some specialized power tool.

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#3

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>You did not mention a standard size belt sander. If you don't have one then add it to the list. I have the PC 352 VS and it works very well.

Tom

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#4

Belt, ROS and then hand

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#5

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have a belt sander, 1/4 sheet pad sander, and ROS. The ROS gets the most use by far, followed by the pad sander. The pad sander is really useful if you reserve it for when you need less aggressive stock removal. It's a finish sander, whereas the ROS can be used for stock removal and finishing, but it can be pretty aggressive in either mode if you aren't careful.

The belt sander gets used only for rough stuff. I never use it for finishing applications, just can screw things up faster than you can whistle "Dixie".

For the most part, I'm in total agreement with what Bill said.

Bruce

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#6

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

Jesse in New Mexico

>Well, the short answer is Festool. ;^)

But, you might also consider one of the combo disc and stationary belt sanders. Delta makes a good one for about $200.

If you have to sand in tight spots, a detail sander is the bee's knees.

I've been woodworking for years, but just learned about sanding sticks. Glue some sandpaper to a piece of scrap an inch wide and a foot long (easy to make a bunch of these at once). Works great for getting into small places and keeps things flat. Great for fine tuning joinery. And almost no cost!!

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#7

My " go-to " all 'round . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>do, pretty much anything is the 4 x 36 belt / 6 " disc bench sander on the stand / legs. Not to big, not to small. Plastic, metal, wood. For rough acuracy remove the dust chute and you can run a whole 2x4 lengthwise. I'm partial to Craftsman but any cast iron bottom will hold up for a lifetime. Get a couple extra drive belts at the get go and stow them. Next year they'll be harder to find when they change model styles but they can be had from NJ. After having one for awgile you'll find its got, about, a million uses.

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#8

Mr Sandman, Bring Me A Dream

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Peter,

I've accumulated most of the commonly used machines. My next purchase after a ROS would be another ROS. (I currently have 3 of them) I also have several orbital sanders, and the sweetest is the P+C #330 Speed Bloc. Its a hummer. I have a 1/3 sheet Skil which I use on panels, and would love to have the big P+C 1/2 sheet sander, but the price is too high. A large format keeps the surface "undivited". Detail sanders are useful sometimes. The one useless device is the P+C profile sander which was a gift from my kids, so I keep it around. I hand sand more and more.

George

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#9

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

David Hay @ Denver

>I haver both a ROS and a 1/4 sheet palm sander. Mostly I use the ROS, but every now and again the palm sander comes in useful. The latest thing I used it for was to help with rubbing out the finish on some cabinets I was building. It was going to take forever to do by hand and the ROS would have been too agressive...the palm sander worked just right.

David

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#10

Re: Thanks, bigger than hand tools?

Peter Gregory

>I have a hand held belt sander that I never use, it just screws things up and I have time. Now that I have read all the good ideas, how do you keep a flat edge flat while sanding? I'm all ROS or hand sanding, and really hand sanding generally is where I spend a majority of my time on a project.

I was thinking an edge sander like http://www.grizzly.com/products/G0563 would be a superior addition to the shop. Anyone have something like this? Or maybe a disk sander like http://www.grizzly.com/products/G1276 would be better?

Thanks for all the help - Peter

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#11

Re: Thanks, bigger than hand tools?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Peter,

what I would do is first start to work on projects. Figure out what you can't do with the tools you already have and then add the sander thingie that will fill that need.

In addition to the sanders I mentioned above: belt, ROS and pad, I also have a 1X42 strip sander I made about 20 years ago. It works extremely well for a bunch of needs that don't fit well into other categories, like sharpening lawn mower blades, grinding the bevel on hunting knives, etc. It's good for making patterns, sanding to a line, but it's no good at all for finish sanding. At some point I'm going to have a disk sander, but at least a 12", maybe 16" with a big motor, just because I do things that it would work on.

I have a friend who is about 5 years from retirement and decided he wanted to do woodworking. In the last few years he has acquired a table saw, band saw, chop saw, radial arm saw, jointer, planer, drill press, and a router. Most of those tools are still covered with cosmolene and are in the boxes they came in. The only one he uses is the band saw, but then he got a good scroll saw that works well so he doesn't use the band saw much at all. He found out he was good at woodcarving and spends ALL his time doing that.

First figure out what you're going to do. Spending $1200 - $1500 on a tool that you think you might need just seems like a bit unnecessary to me until you actually have identified the need for it.

bruce

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#12

Re: Thanks, bigger than hand tools?

Tom Stockton

>It all depends on what type of edges you want to sand if it is cabinet doors and things like that the grizzly combo belt/disk sander isn't the best tool for that. What you should be looking at is the larger ones that grizzly makes like the g1531 it is designed to do edges and is easier to use for things like that and is about the same cost.

As for not owning a festool ros don't feel bad. While they are very well built and engineered there are other ros out there that will give them a run for their money at a third of the price. FWW liked one of the bosch models that is about $70. I have the festool 150/3 and it's a great tool but if I were on a tight budget I would have no hesitation in getting a bosch. The one sander that has no competition is the rotex haven't used one but people really like them.

Tom

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#13

Them things are ok...

John in New Mexico

>I actually like something like that best for large convex curves and shaping really not flat stuff like chair arms. Last shop I worked for had one of those - I just use a hand belt sander in a MDF jig to do the same. If you're really looking to keep an edge flat, use a sharp handplane followed (maybe) by one of those little square sanders.

John

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#14

Re: Profile sander

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>George, I have been using my profile sander quite a lot lately. I really like it to sand the profile on raised panels. I had a roll of adhesive discs -320 grit - that I never used. I found they will adhere well to the 5/8 radius (convex) that just fits my raised panel cutter profile. The 320 really smooths the end grain on the raised panels fast. Helps when staining - I have 11 white oak panels I am finishing for my current blanket chest project. The profile sander leaves a nice sharp edge on the panels.

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#15

Re: Profile sander

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Larry,

I never thought of that. My best friend and I will be making a Grandmother Clock this coming fall/winter, and he wants to employ raised panels as I did in the one built for my wife's Christmas present a couple years ago. We haven't gotten as far as choosing profiles yet. (May have to acquire still another router bit set! :<)) I'll keep your idea in mind, Larry.

George

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#16

Re: You have given my way to much credit!

Peter Gregory

>I don't sit around and figure out what I might need, I have found I often would like to sand an edge and keep it at a 90 degree angle. An ROS has a tendency to round it off.

Thanks for all the help.

Re: After ROS, what sanding device to get next?

#17

Re: You have given my way to much credit!

Larry Marker in Alabama

>I sometimes clamp a straight piece of wood to each side of the thing I want to edge sand and use the ROS. Any roundover is to the two sacrificial pieces. Use the same kind of wood so that everything sands at the same rate.

Larry