Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Dishwashing detergent usage

Posts

Dishwashing detergent usage

#1

Dishwashing detergent usage

Paul Butz

>I have turned many bowls using the detergent soaking method and have had only two bowls that warped only slightly, not enough that it mattered . I have read everything I could about the process and have not found out what happens to the wood when it is soaked in the detergent. I usually soak mine overnight after turning to one tenth thickness of it's diameter, then soak it, then finishing to size , then drying it in the microwave until dry .My question is what is the chemical change that happens while soaking that keeps the wood from cracking and warping??? I am very satisfied with the results.

Thank you for your input.

Paul

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#2

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

Jim Dillon

>Paul,

Here is a guess. Detergent molecules generally consist of a long carbon chain hooked to a small ionic chemical group (although modern detergents are quite complex mixtures). The long chain is the hydrophobic (hates water, loves dirt) portion, while the ionic end is hygroscopic (loves water, hates dirt). Detergent works by the hydrophobic end attaching to the dirt and the surrounding water carries off the ionic end, thus lifting the dirt away. What has this to do with wood? I suspect the detergent molecule is penetrating the wood cellular structure and relaxing the wood fibers (sort of acting like a plastic plasticizer) enough to minimize any surface cracks from starting and leading to bigger cracks. There might even be direct interaction with the cell wall leading to a somewhat more permanent fix. Anyway, food for thought.

Jim

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#3

Speculation continued...

Jim Dillon

>... now that I have had my second cup of coffee, at least both eyes are open. Sorta. You mentioned that treatment with a detergent minimizes warping. This indicates to me that interaction between the detergent is deeper (in a chemical sense). I suspect that the detergent is acting as a hydrogen-bond disruptor between the polysaccharide (cellulose) cell walls. The ionic end (i.e. more polar end) of the detergent molecule may be preferentially attracted to the cell wall thus displacing adjacent cell walls. This would weaken the normal hydrogen-bond interaction between cell walls and allow slippage of the cell walls past one another further minimizing (or averaging out) stress in the work piece, hence warping. As an aside, hydrogen-bonding can exert a large influence on the strength and flexibility of both synthetic and natural materials. A living tree, filled with water, can be very strong and resist wind forces by bending. But a dead tree, with no water within and between the cells, is weak and brittle because of the absence of hydrogen-bonding.

I hope the fellow WoodCentral poster from the U.S. Forest Service lab will chime in and give us the real story.

Jim

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#4

I'll try to find out but I'm skeptical

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I know a cellulose chemist and I will ask him when I have the opportunity. The hydrogen bonding hypothesis has merit but frankly I am skeptical of the whole affair. The rate of penetration of a detergent molecule into the wood would be very slow, I think. As a test of this thought, someone put some water soluble dye in the the detergent and then see how far it penetrates. Report back to WC.

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#5

Dirt is brittle

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Dirt is very brittle. Ever made a sand castle? Ever take your rake out of the shed and accidentally hit a mud wasp's nest on the ceiling? Dirt is very brittle.

And rust, which is chemically related to dirt, is also brittle. Just look at that old hunk of rusting pickup truck in the backyard. Bumpers break off much more easily when they're rusty.

So when you use detergent on your wood, it's removing the dirt, thus it becomes less brittle.... and more stronger.

Less dirt, means less brittle.

;) ;) ;)

No, no, no, you don't have to thank me!

;) ;) ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#6

Re: Dirt is brittle

Marv

>I've seen dirt ON wood but have never see dirt IN wood. I understand the rust theory because rust reduces the thickness of the metal. Dirty wood? Nawwww.

Marv

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#7

Re: I'll try to find out but I'm skeptical

Jim Dillon

>Bill,

Hope you can get an answer from your friend. Since Paul is a turner, I assumed that what he is turning is relatively thin stuff. Hence permeation of a thin cross-section wouldn't take long, especially with the detergent breaking down surface-tension etc.

Jim

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#8

Re: Dirt is brittle

Jim Dillon

>Mark,

I was using the term "dirt" loosely to point out how detergents work on normal "dirt" - that one gets on their clothes - by surrounding the "dirt", forming a micelle, and floating off, hopefully leaving behind a clean shirt etc. Using this analogy, I could easily envision these types of detergents reducing the surface-tension at the surface of the wood and penetrating the wood. The wood does NOT have to have any dirt on it at all, but that would not stop the detergent molecule from trying to do its chemical thing.

I have to say that it has been quite awhile since I've built a sand castle, but I sure have knocked down a few hornets nests. 8-)

Jim

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#9

Logically!

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Well, then logically.....

If you use detergent effectively, to reduce the wood's brittallity,

And detergent removes dirt completely,

then logically and therefore subsequently,

The wood is, or should I say: was, to begin with, categorically dirty.

That is to say was filled with dirt.

And since we build bridges out of wood, and wood floats, she's a witch..... and we can burn her!




Of course, this would all be much more believable if I could a mimic a MonthyPython-esque British accent through typing!

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#10

JL

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

JL

>Many of the modern detergents used in dishwashing detergent are non-ionic surfactants (such as polyoxyethylene sorbitan mono-oleate). Many of the dishwashing detergents also contain a little bit of ethyl alcohol (1-6%).

The detergents still have a hydrophobic chain (mono-oleate or similar fatty acid chains and a hygroscopic end (with lots of -OH groups).

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#11

I Use Detergent On My Pick-up Truck

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>and its lasted 14 years! It 99 and 44 one hundreths percent non-brittle.

George

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#12

Re: I Use Detergent On My Pick-up Truck

Dan Donaldson

>If I used it on mine, it would fall apart. The dirt is the only thing holding it together ;-)

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#13

you are on to something

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>Turners soak things in PEG. It displaces water and doesn't come back out so the wood does not shrink upon "drying". Maybe the nonionics are doing the same. Test....see if Ivory Flakes works, it is supposedly only soap, or Shampoo which is definitley only soap and usually a strange smell like apples or some such.

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#14

Re: you are on to something

Jim Dillon

>Bill,

Maybe the whole thing is just one of those urban/internet myths?? Wouldn't be the first time I've speculated on some phenomena that didn't exist 8-) 8-). And probably won't be the last. FWIW, PEG works by a different mechanism. Hey, is that the same stuff they embalm people with? If it is good enough for wood, should be could enough for people, right.

PS. Keep up the good work on your articles. Man-oh-man, a 100 HP motor on by bandsaw would make it sing!!

Jim

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#15

Ellis Walentine

Whew! What a thread!

Ellis Walentine

>It's been forty years since I took organic chemistry. This thread took me right back to the lab. We sure have an amazing bunch of experts here.

Ellis

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#16

Re: Organic Chem

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I got a great lesson when I tried the soap-soak routine.

Had a 20gal can with 50/50 Costco/water mix in which I soaked my roughs. Being the lawyer /sculptor, and knowing zip about organic chem, long-chain protein molucules, extractives, etc., I was totally mystified when 15gals of detergent soak solution turned into slightly runny Jello. Then I found out that one of the projects in Org. Chem. lab is to isolate proteins by way of an ionic/surfactant solution. That's indeed what happens in the soak barrel, and the more you soak, the thicker it gets. So, be prepared to deal with disposing of the organic mass you will have created.

My 15gals. of goop caused quite a reaction when I trucked it down to the county hazardous waste cleanup day where homeowners get to take their old paint and used thinner and motor oil.

No. I don't soak bowls any more. The detergent wrecks the clarity and color of the grain (IMHO).

mm

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#17

Please don't move this to the Turning Forum

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>This is one of those subjects that turners go over, and over, and over. Then there is the soaking in Denatured Alcohol. Over and Over and Over.

You guys keep in over here in the messages forum. ;)

It is enough for a guy to turn using kiln dried wood......Oh, that is what I do. ;>}}}

Mark

Co-moderator for the turning forum

www.markkauder.com

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#18

Re: Why Would We Do That?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>It fits so well with Kauder's Roofing Saga!

[Did you EVER get that done?]

mm

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#19

LOL Ellis!

Jim Dillon

>Ellis,

Holy smoke, I didn't think you were expecting the RIGHT answer here at WoodCentral. Shoot, that takes all the fun out of providing a response to a question 8-) 8-). And it also eliminates 99% of my posts! As I am a real turning novice, I had not heard of this soaking methodology before. Now I'm puzzeling over the change in the freshly lathe-cut surface at the molecular level and whether that enhances interaction with surfactants. Very interesting indeed.

Jim

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#20

Don't keep us in the dark...

Jim Dillon

>... Mark K. What is the answer! Even us flat-wood folk like to learn something now and then 8-).

Jim (who is more scared of operating his lathe, than tablesaw)

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#21

Organic was the only distress signal on my ME deg.

Art Silva

>

Re: Dishwashing detergent usage

#22

Re: I thought

Wayne

>Heck I thought it just made bubbles and was slipery!!