Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Have you read the FWW review on Glue

Posts

Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#1

Bart Goldberg

Have you read the FWW review on Glue

Bart Goldberg

>I have to admit, I was really surprised by the results. My long held notion of what's best for different applications has been seriously altered. I may think twice about using Poly glue for much other than gluing pen tubes in the future. And my long held belief that nothing was strong then epoxy has been shattered.

Bart

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#2

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

Dan Donaldson

>I thought that it was interesting, but you do need to be careful how you interpret the results as to the "best" glue. There are other characteristics besides pure strength that may also influence your choice. The test did not mention anything about resistance to heat, moisture, creep, or solvents, as well as ease of use, open time etc. Sometimes one of these may be more important than pure strength. Also, one may be stronger than another, but what is "strong enough"? One may be stronger, but cost twice as much. If the "weaker" one is completely adequate for my application, why pay more?

Not knocking the review, but just pointing out that it is important to look at what is critical to you in making assessments based on the results of the review.

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#3

What I learned

john jesseph

>The article reinforced my thought that all the glues I use are strong enough, and that I should choose adhesives based on other characteristics. For me that means lots of hot hide glue and shop-made liquid hide glue.

FWIW the hide glue they used is not the strongest, and not very high quality...

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#4

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

MikeW

>I agree, Dan.

While the article/test does add to the body of tests done in the past (and rest assured, there will be more magazine glue "tests"), that is all it does.

And it also only really applies to singular bridal joints tested in a mode of failure which has no real-world bearing on cabinet making. Even at that, it demonstrates leveraged rotational force--not a common force applied to most furniture with the exception of some chair leg and table support designs.

As well, I have never made a bridal joint where I have not clamped the cheeks of the joint. I suspect this would have altered the results, especially on the "snug" and "loose" fitting joints on at least the Oak.

I do think that in so far as the test parameters dictate, it does reinforce the idea these glues are all more than adequate in so far as strength. That leaves the other considerations you mention in your post.

Take care, Mike

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#5

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

Howard Acheson

>Now that I have had a chance to read the article in FWW, I think the test is basically flawed. Unless I'm missing something, no clamping pressure was applied to the joints. With the exception of epoxy and hot hide glue, all of the tested adhesives require clamping pressure to ensure full adhesive strength. How can they evaluate adhesive strength if they don't clamp the joint?

While I am not a fan of Poly Glue, it does require strong and long clamping to develope full strength. As I recall, the instructions call for 200 psi of clamping pressure for 12 hours. The reason that clamping pressure is important with Poly Glue is that large pressures forcing the joint apart result from the expansion characteristic of the curing adhesive. If tight clamping is not used, the surfaces will be forced apart and the joint will be filled with a foam rather than the adhesive. The foam has very little strength and may explain the poor adhesion results for that product.

There are a number of standard tests for adhesive strengths. I wonder if the writer researched any of those sources. Also, I wonder if he solicited any comments from the manufacturers.

I am sending a letter off the the publisher of FWW and may raise the issue on their website.

When it's all said and done, their results may be relevent but the fact that all had at least some wood failure shows that all had strength greater than the strength of the wood itself. But, I would not put too much credence in the specific results of their "test".

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#6

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

Orion/.Denton, TX

>The important factor is, is the strength of the bond stronger than the wood itself. I don't know of any common woodworking glue that is weaker than the wood itself. It is really a moot point as to how strong a glue is as long as it won't fail before the wood/woods it is bonding fails.

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#7

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I totally agree Dan. I use a lot of Titebond 3. Since I do have a few applications that require water resistance, it is really more cost effective to have 1 gallon of it - I end up throwing away as much as I use due to age. I also use LV cabinet glue & a lot of hide glue. The results of the hot VS liquid hide glue did surprise me somewhat, I think I will use the hot hide glue less often. Kind of disappointed that they didn't test the Titebond liquid hide glue. However I would expect it to perform similar to the "Old Brown Glue".

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#8

Statistically speaking....

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>...it wasn't exactly a clinical trial.

They had three species (maple, oak, and ipe), and three joint fits (tight, snug, loose).

What makes this not-so-great science is the fact that they only did one sample for each type of joint and species combination (unless I read the article wrong). In order to really get statistical significance, they would have to perform the test on the same combination of wood and species many times and get an acceptable range and mean.

I wasn't so disappointed in the lack of clamping the joint. As long as the subjects were all treated identically, then it's valid in that regard.

And here's the big thing for me...on the bottom of the last page, they said that with the stronger of the glues, the failure was almost 100% wood failure, and not glue failure.

This being the case, then they are just proving the variability of wood from joint to joint, and proving nothing about what differs between the strong glues. This truly invalidates their data. If the wood is failing, then what information can possibly be extracted in regard to the glue strength and how each type of glue differs from the other? They were not measuring glue failure! What glue comparison can be made??? The only thing proven here is how a joint can differ in strength based on the qualities of the wood...NOT GLUE.

Now I'm not saying that the information isn't somewhat valuable, and I don't expect Fine Woodworking to become a clinical lab striving for statistically significant p-values, but I take the information with a grain of salt.

Oh well...not to overly criticize, it was still a good read.

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#9

Re: Statistically speaking....

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>They did 3 samples of each joint and each wood for a total of 162 samples.

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#10

Re: Statistically speaking....

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>OK...I did read it wrong.

That's a bit better.

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#11

Not much...

John in New Mexico

>If they want to be scientific about it they need way more samples per glue and per wood, like at least 25 each instead of three. But then, I don't think anyone really expects them to be scientific when the point is to sell magazines rather than contribute to the grand glue knowledge base of the world. I haven't seen the article, but I gather that the wood tended to fail before the glue, so it sounds like more of a test of the woods' strengths than the glues'.

John

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#12

Re: Not much...

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Actually 5 pcs. do constitute a statistical sample, and is the normal sample size taken in manufacturing SPC. (Statistical Process Control). Larger samples - usually a minimum of 25 Pcs. (of each mold cavity etc.) are used to define a process. - The FWW data is somewhat revealing in its context as measuring the adhesion of the various glues against each other. However as was mentioned by Howard, they did not "clamp" the joints so I would consider some of the results suspect - especially the Poly Glue. As I don't normally use that glue for furniture construction I didn't care. As far as glue starvation, normally considered as caused by excess clamping pressure, the test was flawed as the clamping was non-existent.

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#13

Well, thats more or less my point....

John in New Mexico

>the article appears to be attempting to define a model for behavior of materials under certain stresses, and thus the larger sample size is called for. A smaller sample could be used to confirm that the model was behaving as expected, which is why SPC uses smaller samples. I'd speculate that the lack of clamping was an attempt to introduce a variety of results in an area where there really is no lack of acceptable performance of any of the comercial products -- but then again, I'm pretty cynical that way.

John

Re: Have you read the FWW review on Glue

#14

Ironic their #1 pick has full page cover ad?

Marym

>When I read this article, I was also surprised at the results, and immediately thought about their main advertisers. I flipped through the magazine, and sure enough there was Titebond on the back cover, full page. Thats why I dont believe reviews from magazines, I much prefer to here from unbiased users. Dont get me wrong, I like Titebond as much as the next woodworker, I just am not sure how much to believe about these results.

In my shop, I find that epoxy and poly are stronger than pva, and yes I do clamp these joints for at least twelve hours.

If all the glues are stronger than the wood itself. then it doesnt matter much if the results showed a stronger breaking point for pva than poly, does it?

I use poly for certain applications, such as countertops and dining tables, for solid wood glue ups. I find I dont have glue creep in these applications like I sometimes get with pva.