Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

Posts

Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#1

Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

Dan Manturi

>I did searches on this web site and found little. Figured I'd open a topic. I was looking at Festool jigsaw for $280, but reviews show the Bosch is as good in many ways. Need one in a hurry as my old porter cable gave up on me, and I need one for this weekend. Can find lots of the Bosch 1590VSK top handle around (can even score one for $145 on aspecial). The barrel grip models - 1591VSK - supposedly offer better control, but are not available in a lot of stores and I'd have to drive quite a way and pay about $190. I am leaning toward just getting the top handle model for $145. Am I giving up a lot of accuracy and control by going top handle? I never used a barrell grip model, always considered a jigsaw to be a sort of imprecise tool anyway, but heard REALLY good ones like the Bosch and Festool are very accurate. I also figure accuracy is more a factor of the user than the placement of the handle.

Comments welcome.

Thanks.

Dan

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#2

Barrel for me...

John in New Mexico

>I don't really find the grip design to improve accuracy per se, just more comfortable for me to use, which might effect the accuracy, but not as much as some of the tools' other features. I've used both Festool and Bosch jig saws, both are excellent. If Bosch has added any kind of dust control (and if you want that) they'd be roughly equivalent -- the Boschs I've used were a good ten years ago though, so I may not be up on all their features. I don't think you'd be disappointed with either brand.

John

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#3

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

Tony - Memphis

>I'm like you in that I've never considered the jig saw to be very accurate. I rarely use mine. I have a DeWalt handle type. I have small hands, so the handle fits me better. Been a good saw for what I've used it for. I mostly use it for rought cutting large pieces down.

Tony

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#4

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

Dan Manturi

>I have fairly small hands as well, as opposed to "hands like hams", as the joke goes.....

Dan

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#5

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

Dave's Not Here

>I think it's more of a whatever feels the most comfortable in your hand than a matter of which is more accurate. An unscientific guess at best but with the availability of barrel grip models being what it is I'd say that more people prefer the top handle style than the barrel grip style.

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#6

Definitely barrel grip for me!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I had an old cheap B&D jig saw that I used for years. It finally gave up and I purchased a Bosch Barrel grip. In making the top handle versus barrel grip decision, I recalled that when I used the B&D, most of the time, I gripped it around the motor and not up on the handle for better control. I bought the barrel grip model.

You won't regret the Bosch. It is a fine tool and does an excellent job. The B&D I had was a toy compared to the power and preceision of the Bosch. Some of their progressor type blades will give an almost chip free cut in oak and a cut edge on straight cuts that rivals smoothness to a table saw cut. Best of all no tools are needed for blade changes.

Lee

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#7

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>While the barrel-grip (which I own - a Milwaukee) is better for flat, horizontal work, it doesn't work as well when used overhead or vertically on ceilings or walls. The handled version is probably a better overall choice unless your're only going to use it for woodworking.

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#8

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

Bri in Mtl

>Same reason I bought the top handle. Best bet though is if you can try the feel at the store b4 buying. The top handle felt better right away.

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#9

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

Curly Smith

>I've got a Bosch 1590VSK top handle and really like it. I think the barrel vs. top handle decision is really how you want to control the saw -- by your hand/wrist (the barrel model) or by your arm/body (the top handle model). If you do more straight lines then the top handle may be better, if you do more curves then the barrel model may be better. I think the barrel model probably gives you more finesse but the top model probably gives you more control.

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#10

I Prefer Barrel Grip

Howard In Toronto

>I've got small hands too.

The top handle's handle would suit my hands better I get better control by holding onto the barrel.

But the real question is - how does each one feel?

If it's not comfortable, you won't use it.

My 2C.

Howard

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#11

Re: I Prefer Barrel Grip

Orion/.Denton, TX

>I own the bosch with the barrel style. I do like the control compared to top handle models but if you let your hand ride forward onto the cast metal portion it can get quite warm if your doing any amount of cutting. I never remember that and the heat always reminds me if I'm using it for more than a relatively small (quick) job.

Re: Jigsaw - top handle or barrel?

#12

Got the top handle after all

Dan Manturi

>Snagged it for $145 with a $25 pack of Bosch blades. Used it today. The top handle I think works out better for me as i do not have large hands, and that saw runs great. Bosch blades are also first class.

Bottom line is no one anywhere near here sells the barrel grip, but the deal was a good one and teh saw is actually the same machine. I am happy with it. Thanks for the comments.

Dan