Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT Good news/ Car insurance

Posts

OT Good news/ Car insurance

#1

OT Good news/ Car insurance

Barry Irby

>We all have those horror stories about car insurance, I want to share some good news.

My son, the recent college graduate (can you say boomerang kid) decided it was time to buy a pickup truck. I said, you have a real job now, go for it, just don't expect me to do it for you.

He goes to a local reputable dealer and buys a 2003 pickup with about 12K miles on it. Salesman tells me to call insurance company and let them know the dealer will be calling them with the details to add it to the policy. I call them. Dealer Issues state tags and attests my son has insurance. Dealer gets Toyota Finance to give him an excellent rate and assures them he has insurance with Finance company indicated. I drive my son back to pick up the truck and ask about the insurance again. They tell me, "this might be his first truck, but it's not the first one we have sold. We were in this business before he was born and we will not let your son drive away without insurance. Don't worry."

About two months later, he had an accident. Improper left turn. May have totaled his truck and thousands of dollars worth of damage on the other car. File the claim. The insurance company comes back and says "we have no evidence he was insured," and "we did not log the call you made" and "we never heard from the dealer". The next day the request for proof of insurance came from DMV.

Dealer accepts no responsibility. "Yes we did SAY we would take care of it, but we slipped a little note in the financial papers indicating it was his responsibility to maintain the insurance." (My son thought they got it for him and he maintained it.)

Needless to say we have been in turmoil. Now for the good news. The insurance company stepped up and wrote him a policy and back dated it to cover the accident. This might be what they do or are supposed to do, but it looks great to me. The company is Progressive. They matched the policy he had on my car that he was driving, right down to the rental car. I don't think they could have done better. So kudos to Progressive.

Will not be buying anything else from that dealer and will be double checking behind these things better.

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#2

Re: Didn't You Think It Odd

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>When the salesman kept pointing out how "round the wheels are"? Count yourself and your son VERY LUCKY indeed!

mm

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#3

Re: Didn't You Think It Odd

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Round wheels? That's a funny one...they're only round if they're on their side...

Jason

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#4

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Wow. I've always figured it was my own responsibility to take care of that. Usually it's just a phone call for me to add or swap vehicles on my policy (American Family). Although, there was one time when I sold one and bought another, and they dropped the wrong vehicle, so a vehicle I no longer had was insured, but one I did have wasn't. I didn't notice for about 6 or 9 months, either! Fortunately, nothing happened in the interim. But that was just a miscommunication between my agent and I. I think he just misunderstood me.

Jason

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#5

Re: Wheels

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Not Tires |;-}}}

Around here they won't let the vehicle off the lot unless there's a Certificate of Insurance in the file and in the glovebox. They get faxed to the dealership by the agent or "da cah don go nowheres"

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#6

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Barry, you really got Lucky with this one that's for sure!

I also hope that you have learned the old adage that how to tell a car salesperson is lying is that their lips are moving is in fact True, and not a myth.

IMO there is nothing and I mean NOTHING lower than a car salesperson on this earth. They are so low down that they make lawyers look like Saints. you can well imagine it's not a pretty sight when I go onto a car lot. Just the sight of a salesperson rankles me, and it's all downhill from there.

T.O.

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#7

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Phil Thien

>I don't get it. I live in Wisconsin and use American Family insurance. We make our own arrangements (add/drop cars). But even in states where the dealer makes the arrangements, at some point you have to start writing a check for insurance to the insurance company. Was your son writing a check to Progressive?

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#8

Re: Wheels

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Ahh...semantics. To me, rims + tires = wheels.

Jason

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#9

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

tabs

>You are absolutely right. I am a lawyer, and I have made a lot of money suing car dealerships over shenanigans like this. Most states have an unfair trade practices law that not only prohibits this kind of thing, but also provides that a plaintiff is entitled to recover their full attorney fees if they win. I have had dealerships fight tooth and nail for years over relatively minor amounts of money, only to lose and owe a whopping atttorney fees bill in addition.

Anyway, I will never, never buy a car from a dealership. Find a decent used one on Craigslist, or the classified, have a mechanic you trust check it out, and drive away happy.

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#10

Re: Wheels

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That's part of the salesman's art; playing on your assumptions to get you to think he actually said what you wanted to hear. When you go back and complain about the flat spots on the bottom of the tires, he correctly points out that he never mentioned those because they were there in plain sight for everyone to see, so he didn't "need" to point them out to a savy guy like you. Since you didn't ask about them, he figured you were OK with them as is. That's also why he may show you the lot's real clunker first to see how observant you actually are.

|;-}}

mm

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#11

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Barry Irby

>You are right Phil. I was trying to let my son deal with this and as someone said "man up". At 22 he as failed to grow up and start doing things for himself. His mother and I are divorced and between us we have smoothed the road for him and made life easy. I had just paid my annual car insurance bill when buying the truck came up. My insurance covered him as well. The salesman told me to call the insurance company and tell them they would be calling and adding the truck. I did that and discussed with them that my son would probably have to have his own policy, but that they would work it out. I had told my son that this was his deal, his first truck and he would have to take care of the details. I was gritting my teeth trying to let him handle it, but clearly I waited too long and should have gotten after him. I had not thought this through well. I guess I thought DMV would bust his chops, and they did. The letter demanding proof of insurance came one day after the wreck.

Everything went wrong. I did not drag him to the insurance company. Dealer assured DMV and Finance company that he had insurance. Turns out that would have been true for ME, but not my son. The insurance company would have automatically insured the new vehicle if I (the insured) had traded in a vehicle, but that does not happen if a "covered driver" just buys a vehicle. So the salesman's lips were moving, but a "sorta" truth. And if DMV had followed up in thirty days as they were supposed to he would have at least been on notice. No one sparkles in this, but maybe he learned something.

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#12

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Ernie Miller

>Come on Todd what about us Vinyl siding salesmen? I like to hit the new home for up grade replacement windows. Or the added insulation that will almost pay for the siding over time. Add value and jack the price. (Not really a siding salesman but know several)

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#13

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Don't feel bad Barry, my 21 year old daughter isn't maturing into a fully responsible person as well as I had hoped for, nor as I know she can. I thought that once she got out of Army bootcamp she'd be a completely different person, but that was an illusion. I call the kids in her age group thge "Nintendo Generation" and for the most part feel that 98% they aren't worth a hoot in Hades.

Still, car salespersons are the lowest form of Human Being I have ever encountered.

T.O.

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#14

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>There must be someone upstairs watching out for you. I would have to say this is the first time I have ever heard of a dealer claiming they set up insurance for a vehicle. But of course Michigan is in a whole different world when it comes to insurance. Would have to say insurance companies are a pet peeve; better not get started on that subject. But it really sounds like you got taken care of by a decent person.

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#15

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Kevin Rabenaldt

>I don't get it. Did you think is was odd never to be billed for the insurance? Were you not interested in the amount of coverage, what the cost would be? Your son is college grad? He should know better not to follow up.

If I was Progressive, I would not have paid.

Kevin

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#16

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Barry Irby

>I agree, I should have followed up. I was trying to let my son deal with it and I expected DMV to bust him for not having insurance and they did, but not until the day after the accident. I should have been after him, but I convinced myself that if I followed up, he would never learn.

I also agree about Progressive. I am amazed they stepped up. I doubt I woudl have. OTOH, they are exactly where they would have been if they had followed up on my call aobut he insurance and the dealer anyway.

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

#17

Re: OT Good news/ Car insurance

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>There are good agents and people in many companies. My father was an agent for over 35 years, and tells stories today, retired fifteen years or more.

It's a relationship business, based on human comfort and care as much as finance and rate of return, at least in some corners of the world. And it's fairly highly regulated. A company can often make more friends, keep more clients, and pay fewer attorneys' fees by making a judgement that, since they will likely pay anyway, they pay now, and come out looking like the good guy.

Not always. Not every where. But sometimes. I'm guessing that Dad is known and seen in the community, and, telling this story, makes selling insurance a little easier.