Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

Posts

Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

#1

Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

R. Lance in G.R., Michigan

>Help. I've built a blanket chest and I'm about to apply finish. My reading and research in various chatrooms has shown not to apply any type of oil finish to the inside of a chest because of the smell that will build up and permeate the cloth goods inside the chest. So, I planned to use shellac on the inside and coat the inside of the chest a few times with shellac to offset the finish on the outside of the chest for more uniform moisture absorption/loss. Now I've read an article in Wood magazine that if you line the chest with cedar (which I want to do), then do not finish any part of the inside of the chest at all (underside of the lid, tray, etc.) because cedar gives off a turpintine type chemical that would react with the finish and keep the finish soft and sticky. YIKES!!!! The article specifically names oil and water-based finishes as being vulnerable. But what about shellac?? - an alchol based product?? Help please. Any insight - experience - much appreciated - before I turn to alcohol myself.

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

Dale Lenz

>I've used shellac many times over ERC, aka aromatic cedar. Works great and the shellac will not soften to my experience. Also, clear shellac, keeps the cedar close to the bare wood look.

Most folks, myself included, will not finish cedar inside a chest, as they, we want the 'cedar smell' inside the chest...Dale

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

#3

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The point of lining a chest with aromatic red cedar is to inhibit insect infestation, which would be compromised by applying any finish. Forget about finishing the inside; moisture "balance" is a non-issue.

Clint

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

#4

more on incompatibility

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I agree with what the others said and will add some irrelevant, to this discussion, information. Yes, softwood sap will soften oil based finishes. But, if the lumber has been kiln dried to hardwood specifications the heat will "set" the sap, which means the volatile parts are driven off and only a hard resin remains. The set sap is not much of a problem. The problem of course is knowing whether your softwood has had its sap set unless you dried it yourself.

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

#5

what you can and can't use, and why

Michael Dresdner

>As was said, the point of using aromatic cedar lining is that it gives off a chemical that acts somewhat like napthalene (moth balls) in that it prevents moth infestation in the clothes within. Also, it smells nice, imparting a nice aroma to clothes, and finishing would block both those characteristics.

For the record, though, the problem with finish over aromatic cedar is that it contains an anti-oxidant that will prevent the cure of finishes that cure by oxygen polymerization. That means it can impede the cure of oil based finishes, but waterbased finishes and other solvent based finishes, including shellac and lacquer, will cure just fine.

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: For the record.

Dale Lenz

>Back 27 or so years ago, our silviculture instructor assigned us each a tree species to write a x pages report on. One of the girls in the class, Barbara A. helped me find reference for my tree species. Barbara had Eastern Red Cedar, as her tree species to report on. She informed me that there was no "hard scientific evidence" that ERC repelled insects, I was somewhat shocked. I'll look it up from time to time and can't find anything, from a good reference, that says ERC repels bugs, doesn't say that it goes either way for that matter-in-fact. But, the world's perception is: that it does repel/kills insects.

Once I sold a ERC flag case on Ebay, and I think I said something to the effect, Reportedly Repels Insects, : ' >. I tell my boys: never lye but it's okay to play it up, : ' >.

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

#7

clarification

R. Lance in GR, Michigan

>It is not my intent to place any finish on the cedar. The shellac is for the exposed areas of the interior of the chest and possibly for the sides of the chest upon which the raw aromatic cedar will be attached. However my concern comes from the warning in WOOD - March 2007 - page 41 - which states that the resins in cedar are similar to those in turpentine - so the oil vapors will soften oil and water-based stains, paints, and finishes (including lacquer) causing clothes and the lid to stick. I appreciate your responses - especially from Michael - thanks - to be safe, maybe I'll do a little experimenting.

Re: Finishing ? - shellac and aromatic cedar

#8

Hard data on the topic

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I make canoe paddles and have made them from Eastern Red Cedar. I finish them with spar varnish and I have never had a problem with the finish drying. The cedar I use has been dried and the resin "set" as I described in my post above.


img