Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Posts

On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#1

On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Over the last month or so, I have been upgrading my DC system from a Grizzly 1.5hp cartridge system to a new 1800 cfm ClearVue Cyclone system. Though the ducting is still only 4" and I am slowly going to convert to 6" ducting all the way to the machine, the results are nothing short of spectacular. I put a HEPA filter over the intake of my window Air Conditioning unit. Before the ClearVue, that filter work get very dirty in a matter of hours, now it takes 4 days to get as dirty. Seriously.

Here is my question for the assembled experts here. My Cyclone is in a storage room with nothing but a solid wall between - no air return. (By the way, the storage room is staying very clean do the great filtration provided by the Wynn Environmental filters, and the great dust seperation provided by the Cyclone.) I want to setup air return so that I do not lose cool or warm air to the outdoors, without returning noise. My plan it to put a floor register/vent in the storage room, and another in the opposite end of the shop, 24' away. The exact question is - how big should that passive air return vent and ductiong be?

Thank you all

Mark

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#2

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>You want to keep the face velocity across the register as low as possible in order to minimize the pressure losses (doubling face velocity will quadruple the pressure loss). A low face velocity will also keep the (air movement) noise down and will limit the "throw" of the air re-entering the room (the throw is the distance at which when you held your hand you'd feel air moving).

Face velocity is calculated by dividing your volume of air (1800 cfm in your case) by the surface area of the register.

A face velocity range of 100 fpm (feet per minute)to 500 fpm would be suggested. At 500 fpm (the pressure loss would be low, but the throw would be about 3 feet (assumes about 6" static which is WAY high), so I'd say that's a max.

So - at 500 fpm, your total register area needs to be:

1800cfm/500fpm = 3.6 sq ft. or 518.4 sq in.

a single register of 21.5"x24" or two registers each 11'x24" would get you there.

at 100 fpm your total register area needs to be:

1800cfm/100fpm = 18 sq ft. or 2592 sq in.

a single register 30"x86.5" or two registers each 30"x44" would get you there..

You get the idea.

If it was me, I'd size the registers for the largest disposable furnace filter you can find in your local hardware store and use as many registers as you need to get the face velocity below 500 fpm. this will keep the noise level down, keep the pressure drop down, keep the "throw" down which will not stir the dust as bad and the extra filtering can only help.

good luck!

Rob

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#3

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Barry Irby

>Unlike Rob, I don't have any numbers for you. Just thinking about this. First, glad to hear its working as well as it is.

A number of things come to mind. It seems that the duct will have to sized according to the air flow and the size of the registers. The registers and the filters will ahve a dramatic effect on the air flow. For example, a register may have only fifty percent of the opening or equivalent opening that the hole it covers would have. The point is that a register may reduce the air flow through the hole significantly. Therefore, the hole and regisrer probably should be twice or triple the size fo the duct.

The "old school" way of keeping noise transmission down in ducts was to line them with fiber insualtion. The ducts would have to be an inch or two oversized each way and then the liner took up the space. Today, I would think the duct would be a section of flex duct and I doubt that has the sound absorbing ability of the old metal stuff or even the fiberglass ductboard stuff.

Another thought is that you are providing a "relief port" but the air flow through it is indirect in that it is not connected to the machine. The air flow will take the path of least resistance. If the shop and closet were perfectly sealed nearly 100% of the air would return. In your case, some air will be sucked back into the shop through every avaiable leak and some will escape the closet. The more resistance in your relief tube, the less air will find its way back.

Does your Clear Vue system have an external filter? Could you install that filter inside the return duct with a direct connection so that the air would be forced to return? Obviously, you would have to arange that so the filter could be changed easily, but that would all but elimanate the "free air" problem. This would have the effect of installing the filter in the shop, hopefully leaving the noise behind.

Another thought, the effects of sound proofing on ducts is lost or hits the point of diminished return at about fifteen feet (IIRC), so running 24 feet may not be necessary unless it is convenient.

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#4

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Steve King Plano, TX

>I have the same setup that you do with my Bill Pentz design cyclone in a storage room. I built a box around the filter, cut a hole in the wall to vent the return back into the shop and installed a 12x24 hvac filter.

Steve


img

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#5

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Rob,

I, ah.....think I understand.

No really, I understand only because of your examples.

Thanks so much.

Mark

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#6

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Barry,

Thanks for the good ideas as always. The box around the filter is a great idea, now I just have to think through the possibility.

Mark

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#7

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Thanks Steve. Especially with the Picture.

How about the sound transmission?

Mark

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#8

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Steve King Plano, TX

>There is no sound because the filter is boxed in, you can't here the return air.

Steve


img

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

#9

Re: On Topic: Air Return Ducting Question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Yeah. Yeah! Fantastic. Again, I would have to re-adjust my current arrangement, but it could work.

Thanks again for the picture.

Mark