Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Insulating a shop

Posts

Insulating a shop

#1

Insulating a shop

Josh in VA

>Well first off...sorry for not doing a weekly update on the building of the shop...been doing some traveling for work and haven't had the time to size down pics and post.

The roof will be done tomorrow...siding hopefully very soon after that. Garage doors will be ordered by the end of the week and the electrician will be in sometime next week.

Builder says about 3 weeks and he will be done.

So I am starting to think about what all I have to do before I "move in". I will be doing all of the insulation and finish work inside. So I am looking for opinions/advice on the insulation.

The shop is 32' x 28' with a 2' knee wall (poured and 4" slab) and 8' - 2" x 6" walls (10' ceilings). Lots of windows (low E). I have a 13' x 32' room in the "upstairs" to be finished later. The shop was also wrapped in Tyvek.

My HVAC system is TBD at this point as we need to recoop some money...maybe a next year tax return job.

With that...any opinions/advice on the insulation to use and what values? I have been doing a lot of reading up on insulation and everyone seems to have an answer. Obviously the higher the R-value...the better it will restrict airflow. But from what I have read...there does reach a point when the cost starts to outweigh the benefits.

My better half is starting to complain that the shop is only a shop and does not to be as insulated as I am planning.

However my POV is...it is something that as I get older I will spend more and more time in so the climate will become a huge factor to my comfort/productivity/quality of work.

So what do you think?

Thanks

Josh

Re: Insulating a shop

#2

Re: Insulating a shop

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>get one chance to do it right. It is almost impossible to add or replace the insulation once the building is complete. That said, when I built my shop about 3 - 4 years ago, I installed all the best insulation I could find and afford. I house wrapped the outside. I built using 2 X 6" walls so I could use the thicker insulation. I then stapled heavy poly on the inside walls and installed 5/8 (fire code) sheetrock. I had trusses designed so I have a 10' wide X 30' long room upstairs. I installed roll insulation on the roof trusses in the room area, then 2" thick foam board and covered the foam with luan. From the eaves to the upstairs room I nailed 3/4 to 1" thick strips against the trusses against the underside of the roof sheeting. I then fastened 3/4 foam on the strips - this let the air flow from the eaves to the peak of the roof. I sealed the foam at the eave area with the expanding foam insulation. We sided the upstairs walls with OSB, but left one small section out. We then blew the entire cavity along both sides of the room full of the cellulose insulation ( some places it is 5 foot deep). I knew I was retiring in a year or so (then) and like you wanted to be comfortable in the shop - winter and summer. I installed all thermopane windows and insulated doors. I also installed a high efficiency gas furnace and central air. I don't think you can really judge what is cost effective. What may not be justifiable today may be paid back in a few months due to fuel cost raises in a few years. As I stated you only get one chance to do it right. I sure don't regret anything I did or spent now - and wished I could have done more.

Re: Insulating a shop

#3

Re: Insulating a shop

Ray Newman

>Agree w/ what Larry Clinton wrote.

Put in the max. am�t of insulation possible & install good windows & doors.

Been there & done that & I don�t regret the extra money I spent to do it right. My Modine Hot Dawg keeps the shop warm in the winter.

Energy isn�t going to get cheaper.

Your POV is �dead-nuts on�.

Re: Insulating a shop

#4

Re: Insulating a shop -additional info

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Josh, before you finish your ceiling, you may want to do your ducting for your heating system. Your shop is similar to mine in construction. I installed the furnace in the upstairs room. I purchased the furnace and air conditioning compressor, "A coil" box (for the A-coil, and refrigeration tubing from a local discount house for under $2M, I then installed a Trunk line (8"X 20") between the trusses toward the roof eaves. I tied that to a 8" X 16" trunk at each end of the large trunk & ran the smaller trunk parallel to the eave's of the shop. (joined the 8X16 to the top of the 8X20 at 90 degrees). I then attached the 6" runs to the smaller trunk & installed registers in the ceiling. The furnace is located at the end of the shop upstairs with the return air in the shop ceiling. This perimeter system works great and is not in the way at all. If you don't want to spend the money on the furnace at this time I would at least install the ducting if this is the way you plan to go. My furnace is a direct vent so no combustion air is drawn from the shop. Both inlet and exhaust are through the end wall of the shop in 2" PVC. I have a large older house (1880's) - which is well insulated and has new windows and doors. My heating bill for the shop is less than $75 a month (close as I can estimate) for the coldest months & cooling is less than $50 for the hottest. I have a filter grill in the ceiling and change filters every 3 - 4 weeks. Shop is very comfortable - no hot or cold spots.

Re: Insulating a shop

#5

Paul Kramer

Re: Insulating a shop

Paul Kramer

>Josh,

Absolutely, without any doubt at all, whatsoever -- INSULATE. Larry is dead on. I did exactly what he described with the foam insulation spaced from the roof sheathing to allow an air passage from the continuous eave vent to the continuous ridge vent. It really helps in the summer. The underside of the roof sheetrock is as cool as the room. I put an additional layer of fiberglass insulation between the foam and the sheetrock. The walls are insulated with fiberglass with an added poly vapor barrier. I lined my walls with half inch plywood. It's tougher and you can hang things nearly anywhere. The heavy stuff (lumber rack, cabinets, etc.) needs to be anchored to studs though. My shop is small but I appreciate the insulation and the HVAC (with the automatic thermostat) every time I go out there.

HTH,

Paul

Re: Insulating a shop

#6

Re: Insulating a shop

Bart Castleberry

>yes insulate as much as the studs or rafter will hold. Compressed insulation bats do not offer any additional insualtion. IE; it does not help to stuff a 10" thick bat in a 6" deep cavity.

Second, look for an insulation contractor, in my area (Southwest VA) I can get insualtion installed for less than what I pay at a big box store with a contractor's discount. I recenly had a 14' foot ceiling insulted from the floor below for less than a buck a square foot to R38.

Third, on the HVAC, get a sealed combustion furnace, they are actually cheaper than the ceiling mounted sealed combustion gas garage heaters, by about 50%. Go figure. If it's realtively mild there, just get a heat pump if you are going all out. otherwise a window unit works fine in most cases. I have a couple 25k window units and they do fine with a 3000 square foot shop, takes about 20 min and it's not bad in the summer. Keep your eyes open and they find thier way to you for free.