Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

Posts

Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#1

Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

Jay Fischer

>I am planning to finish a bubinga dining table for my family with Tung oil. As I read the directions on different mannufacturer's labels and check out postings on the subject on the internet, I find conflicting ideas on how to apply the oil. Some say to thin to 1:2, then wipe on (like wax) a thin layer and let dry (3+ coats). Others say to put it on, then wipe it right back off within a few minutes (multiple coats).

Another, calling it hand rubbed finish, says to do 2 thin layers of thin shellac (or Krenov polish??) and then put a tung oil vernish or poly over that consisting of many thin layers that you rub in, then immediately rub off. This one sounds very interesting to me but I hate to experiment on this wood. (Posted on "Artisans of the Valley" site)

I know Lee Grindinger is very knowledgable about bubinga and sent him a few emails but his inbox is full and I need some expert advice. The last thing I want to do is spend the money and time on this great wood and have it not look beautiful! Who knows about Tung oil and, hopefully, bubinga in particular? Also, any advice on how to prepare the edges before gluing up the top, type of glue I should use, etc., would be very much appreciated.

Thanks!

Jay

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#2

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

Bob Reeve

>I use a product that is called Velvit Oil. It is an Oil and Varnish mix. The procedure I floow is to flood the piece with oil and while keeping it wet, I wet sand with the next higher grade of paper than I used dry. This creates a slight slurry and help fills the pores of the wood. Keep the wood wet with oil for 15 minutes and then wipe the excess off. You will need to return several times and rewipe as the wood will continue to bleed off excess oil for awhile. Let dry till cured at least 24 hours. You can then topcote with a wipe on poly if desired or just add a coat of wax.

Bob

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#3

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>Reading the directions on verious containers of tung oil can be very confuning because they are sometimes not even close to being the same product. sometimes they are labled as pure tung oil or polimerized tung oil, which is usually what it states. then there is "tung oil finish" which can be just about any concoction containing tung oil, and usually contains some amount of varnish resins as well as driers. I have even seen pure tung oil finish which I think is most likely polimerized tung oil or possibly tung oil with the addition of a dryer but I'm not really sure and reading the label is often no help.

You can often get a clue as to what type of tung oil/tung oil blend you are dealinmg with by reading the directions, in particular the drying time. the longer the drying times the most likely it is either pure tung oil or polimerized tung oil. Polimerized usually means it has been heated to initiate long chain formation so it accelerates the drying process dramaticaly.

In the case of tung oil it is often best to buy small quantities of several products and try them on several scraps of diferent woods to find a brand you like. I am partial to Jasco brand. the container calls it pure tung oil, but I strongly suspect it to be heavily modified due to the high sheen it will produce with enough coats as well as its relativly quick drying time. Jasco is on the deep end of the spectrum color wise. it adds a rather dramatic amount of deep amber color. On the oposite end of the specrum color wise is something like Formby's which is a pale sraw color and darkens about the same as a high quallity linseed oil.

For a dining room table I would consider a single coat of an oil finish to pop the grain, followed by a seal coat of shellac and then several coats of one of the new generation of waterbased finishes. I have recently switched to Generals high performance polyurethane top coat which is a waterbased polyurethane finish that drys and sands like nitrocellulose but is much tougher and has a uv inhibiter, something tung oil finishes all lack.

Good luck,

Robin Corell

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#4

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

Jay Fischer

>Thank you very much for the response. Your last paragraph listed a method that I have not heard before and it sounds interesting. I'm pretty clear on the differences in pure tung oil, tung oil varnish and tung oil poly. It's really how to apply the oil that has me confused. I have the Fromby's as well as pure tung oil. I tried the two finishes on a piece of bubinga and found the Formby's too glossy for what I want. I like a more natural finish but I also want it to "shine". I like Krenov polish a lot but it has no water resistant qualities. I also tried a varnish and a Watco Poly and wasn't crazy about either look.

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#5

Depends on the look you want...

John in New Mexico

>I use tung oil from Woodcraft, which I believe is pure un-polymerized oil (though I wouldn't swear to it). Sometimes I mix it with turpentine, sometimes not. It will build faster un-thinned, but is a lot harder on the fingers when rubbing out a big surface. It generally doesn't give you a high gloss, hard finish, but is very easy to apply and repair. It needs no other finish, but you can always put some on, shellac, poly or whatever. Personally I don't see the point - why not just skip the oil? For a shiny oil finish, or even a satin/shiny one, I prefer Waterlox to tung oil.

John

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#6

Re: Not sure of your application...

Grant Smith

>Jay,

I am wondering how much you have thought through the use of Tung oil for a dining table. Will this be a table that sees daily use by a family with kids? Will it see any alcohol? Will it have glass over top of it? Tung oil, while a beautiful and renewable finish, might not be up to protecting the wood from regular spills and abrasion at a table.

Personally, I would consider another finish such as a film finish (partial to General Finishes Seal Coat and Top coat) for a table that may see daily use. You might consider finishing the apron and legs with Tung oil, and putting on a coat or two of a tung oil finish to the top before adding a durable coating when it cures a while. In the end it is your call. If you are Okay with the prospect of regular maintenance with Tung oil, and aren't worried about a spill that may damage that finish, then proceed.

I should say that I have limited experience with Tung oil, but I understand it to provide minimal protection from moisture and certain chemicals such as alcohol. A great looking "in the wood" finish for more occasional use projects, but may not provide the prtection you may want for a Dining table. Someone correct me if I am wrong about this.

Also curious... does anyone think Bubinga may be too oily to allow proper drying of Tung oil? Not sure myself, but something I wonder about in this case.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#7

Re: Not sure of your application...

Jay Fischer

>I have read (on the internet) that if the last 2 layers of finish are a tung oil poly or varnish mixture, and you put them on somewhat thickly, that it is almost completely impervious to water. If that's false, I will need to rethink my choice of finish.

Jay

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#8

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>Sorry I didn't really finish my previous post and tie all the diferent types of tung oil into how to apply them. The straight pure oils have an increadibly long and forgiving workable time. you can most likely apply to the entire table top in one go and all the legs in another go befor stoping to wipe off the excess, the polimerized stuff can be harder to guage as to how much can be applied before wiping off but it should be close to the pure stuff if it is not thinned with turp. if you thin tung oil with turp it will penetrate a bit better but turp is a drier and will shorten your working time a bit. the tung oil fiishes are more like wipe on poly finishes in their application. all of them are very forgiving in that if they get too tacky you can go over them with fresh finish and wipe off the excess. of course this has its limits on the modified finishes.

The method of laying down a coat of oil and following with shellac and lacquer is perfect for high traffic items(catalized lacquer or the poly acrylic lacquers, not notrocellulose). the oil pops the figure and deepens the grain. after the oil is compleatly dry beyond all question, several days to a week for a coat of oil where all the excess was compleately wiped off. then seal with a coat or two of dewaxed blond shellac. the shellac will adhere to the oil and the waterbourne lacquer or solvent based lacquer will adhere to the shellac. this method will not five you a natural look, it will give you a lacquer finish with the depth of an oil finish. The method you mentioned about finishing with a couple of coats of thick modified tung ol will also not give you a natural finish, it will look very similar to spar varnish. I have this kind of finish of a workbench. it is very tough and durable and uimpervious to water and all maner of abusive things but it looks like heavy thick spar varnish.

I also forgot to mention that I use a brush to apply the General High Performance finish. You can spray it but I don't have a suitable area so I tend to brush all my finishes.

Good luck and post some pics.

Robin Corell

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#9

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

Howard Acheson

>Let me give you a simple rule. If the can does not say "pure" or "100%" you are not looking at real tung oil. If it's called a "Tung Oil Finish" it probable contains no real tung oil. Products like Minwax Tung Oil Finish and Formby's Tung Oil Finish are totally different products and neither contain any real tung oil. Minwax is a varnish/linseed oil product and Formby's is a thinned wiping varnish.

Here's some info that may clear this up somewhat.

There are two "true" oils used in finishing. One is linseed oil which comes from flax seeds. The second is tung oil Which comes from a nut tree that originally grew in China. Both are called drying oils although neither really fully dries and becomes hard. The primary use of both is in manufacturing oil based finishes.

A product that is a true tung oil will have a label that says either "pure" or "100%". If it doesn't say that on the label, IT ISN'T TRUE TUNG OIL. Forget about all the other baloney and look for one of those two words if you want to use a true tung oil. If the label contains any other chemicals, except a thinner, you are not getting a true tung oil. Real tung oil has acquired a cachet in the past twenty years that seems to elevate it to some type of magic potion. In fact, as a finish, it does not offer anything much different than linseed oil. In spite of the hype, is not significantly more water resistant than linseed oil--both are lousy--nor is it any more durable. Used alone both are fairly inferior "finishes". About the only difference is that tung oil is slightly less amber than linseed oil but it also is slightly less effective at "popping" the grain. By most measures, it is not significantly different from linseed oil.

"Tung Oil Finish" is a marketing expression for products that the manufacturer thinks will give you a finish like the finish you get from a true tung oil. These "Tung Oil Finishes" may or may not contain some true tung oil, but most do not contain any true tung oil. Their only claim to the use of the word "tung" is that it claims to give you the appearence of finish that results from true tung oil. You're buying a "faux tung oil finish".

There are two types of "tung oil finishes". One is mixture of varnish, boiled linseed oil and mineral spirits (called an oil/varnish). The exact mixtures are proprietary but 1/3, 1/3, and 1/3 will get you real close. Some manufacturers add a dollop of drier to speed up the drying. This same mixture is frequently also called "Danish Oil" because it gives a finish that resembles the finish used on much of the "danish style" teak furniture imported in the 50's and 60's. It closely mimics a true oil finish but the addition of the varnish resins gives it more durability and protection. These finishes do not need to be overcoated with a film finish. When you do so, you are destroying the look and feel of the finish.

Here are some oil/varnish mixtures:(*)

Deft Danish Oil

General Finishes' Seal a Cell

Behlen Danish Oil

Maloof Finish (contains pure tung oil and linseed oil)

Behr Scandinavian Tung Oil Finish

Minwax Tung Oil Finish

Minwax Antique Oil Finish

Velvit Oil

Watco Danish Oil

Liberon Finishing Oil ((contains pure tung oil and linseed oil)

McCloskey Tung Oil Finish (contains pure tung oil, no linseed oil)

The second "tung oil finish" is one made from varnish and mineral spirits. The approximate ratio is 1:1. This is really just a thinned varnish just like the stuff sold as "wiping varnish". When one two or three coats are applied, it also mimics the finish produced by a true oil but it is harder than the oil/varnish above because it does not have as much oil. It is slightly more protective than the oil/varnish type or tung oil finish. For all intents and purposes it is a varnish finish.

Here are some thinned varnishes:(*)

Minway Wiping Varnish

Watco Wiping Varnish

Formby's Tung Oil Finish

Zar Wipe-on Tung Oil

Val-Oil

Hope's Tung Oil Varnish

Gillespie Tung Oil

Waterlox Original Sealer/Finish

General Finishes' Arm R Seal

Jasco Tung Oil

(*) Courtesy Bob Flexner and some personal information.

One way to tell whether the product is an oil/varnish or a wiping varnish is to read the application instuctions. Oil/varnishes are applied, then given some time to set, then wiped dry. Wiping varnish products are wiped on an left to dry (no wiping off).

Finally, I'm not disparaging any of these products. In fact, they are a more protective and durable finish than any pure oil finish. They are what they are and can give you a very nice close-to-the-wood finish when properly applied and not overcoated with a film finish.

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#10

Waterlox Sealer/Finish (red top can) has ........

Art Silva

>enough tung oil in it to make figured Bubinga pop like a cheap balloon. I am sending you a picture of my new workbench which will soon be a Shop Shot. It has four coats of Waterlox, two brushed on, and two ragged on. Try it, you'll love it. Art

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#11

Re: Waterlox Sealer/Finish (red top can) has .....

Steve Schoene

>The Waterlox doesn't have tung oil in it, it is a varnish manufactured using tung oil and phenolic resin as ingrediants. A chemical reaction has created a new product--varnish, that is then thinned to be a good wiping varnish. It, like any varnish with an amber color will pop the figure. As a varnish, it is dramatically more protective than tung oil, or tung oil mixed physically with varnish.

You can let it build a film on the surface if you want. It's one of my favorites--partly because it comes in three flavors, Satin, Original/Sealer and Gloss, depending on the look you want. (The Gloss is nearly a "full strength" varnish, but it is easy to thin if you want to wipe it on too. The original sealer has a VERY NICE mellow gloss--shinier than satin or eggshell if those terms have any meaning, but definately not high gloss. Calling it a sealer doesn't make it any less effective, or protective as a final top coat, either.

Everyone be sure to read Howard's lists. There is lots of pretty cynical marketing going on associated with the tung oil buzz word. No wonder lots of people don't like finishing.

With a pure oil (either linseed or tung) or with oil/varnish mixes, you cannot allow the finish to build a film on the surface. If you do it will be soft--practically gummy. You NEED to apply and then vigorously wipe off all excess that has not penetrated into the wood.

And, I definately recommend against using pure (or 100%) tung oil. The drying time is MUCH longer than linseed oil. (You should wait several days (overnight is not good and three days is better than two) between coats, and it will take 4-5 coats to get an even satin sheen.) If you move too quickly, the tung oil finish can develop a frosty look that is hard to deal with. It doesn't always happen, I think it has to do with how you hold your mouth.

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#12

Wait a minute, s'll vous plait *LINK*

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Steve, you need to read the Waterlox website. It clearly states that Tung oil IS an ingredient of Waterlox.

I totally agree that there are many products on the market that report to have tung oil, but indeed do not. They probably just wave a Tung nut over the varnish pot. :-)

Happy saw dust,

Ken


Waterlox Tung Oil

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#13

Re: Wait a minute, s'll vous plait

Jay Fischer

>I had the same reaction when I was told that Formbey's Tung Oil Finish had no TO because I saw it listed on the label. The explanation is that they used TO and linseed oil to MAKE the varnish in the mixture and it is no longer TO; i.e. it is changed chemically.

Jay

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#14

A few minor errors, Howard

Michael Dresdner

>The vast bulk of what Howard wrote is both quite correct and very helpful, but there are a few technical errors that should be cleared up in the interest of accuracy.

First, Watco does not make anything called "Watco Wiping Varnish." They do make a Wipe On Poly, a Danish Oil, and a Teak Oil, all of which are wipe on oil based varnish mixtures, just as Howard described. Only the name was wrong.

There is also an error in saying "There are two "true" oils used in finishing." Actually, there are quite a few, though until recently tung and linseed were far and away the most popular. Soya oil is moving up fast and is being used extensively these days. In addition to the so called drying oils are a wealth of semi-drying oils, such as tall, tabacco, oticica, and others which can be converted to drying oils. Those are also used in finishing formulation.

Finally, the statement "Both are called drying oils although neither really fully dries and becomes hard." is also untrue. Both will dry to a solid film. Granted, the film is a rather flexible one, but it is fully dry and solid. If by 'hard' Howard means brittle, he is right. They do not form brittle films, but then neither do many other finishes that are very durable. For example, the paint used over flexible shock absorbing auto bumpers is designed to be tough, but flexible. That does not diminish its durability, so it is important not to confuse hardness (brittleness) with durability.

Re: Bubinga & Tung Oil - Which Method is Correct ?

#15

After mineral spirits, Tung Oil is 2nd. ingredient

Art Silva

>