Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT---Strange e-bay activity

Posts

OT---Strange e-bay activity

#1

OT---Strange e-bay activity

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

I'm currently watching an auction on e-bay that I intend to get in on tomorrow. The strange thing is that there have been 19 bids, but 17 were by the same person, one who has no e-bay history. Is somebody just trying to jack up the bid, or is this someone who doesn't have a clue? He raised his own bid from $1.00 to $55 before someone else came in with a bid.

Gary

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#2

Steven Antonucci

Probably some kind of proxy bid

steve antonucci

>You can't raise your own bid. It's "impossible" without someone else bidding first. You might have an open bid of $1, and a max of $55 with another bidder notching it up a few bucks at a time.

This keeps the second bidder from consuming his "best offer" in one chance- I do it all of the time to sense where someone else's max might be if I don't want to start an early bidding war.

Steve

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#3

Re: Probably some kind of proxy bid

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I thought about that, Steve, but I couldn't understand why it didn't show the other bids. It only showed the opening bid, this person's 17 bids and then the bid which was high the last time I looked.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Gary...

Dale Lenz

>is there a reserve on the listing?

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#5

Re: Gary...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>No, no reserve.

Gary

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#6

Re: Probably some kind of proxy bid

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>If I understand the way it works it only shows the high bid. If someone made multipul bids below his max it would only show the increases in his.

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#7

Steven Antonucci

I think that's right...

steve antonucci

>

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#8

eBay programming bugs

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>eBay may be a billion dollar enterprise and should be able to afford good programmers, but I think there are a few glitches in their system.

I once bid on an item (think it was about $25) and I was the high bidder. There was a couple of hours left and I was leaving the house and thought that I'd be willing to pay a little more. So I went and increased my max bid to $30 (IIRC). It instantly increased my bid from $25.00 to $25.50 (again IIRC). I was already the high bidder at $25 and was just increaing my Max Bid a little bit, and it increased my bid to the next increment, which was 50 cents I think.

I thought it was odd, since no once else bid on the item. I won it, sent a letter to eBay but just paid the extra 50 cents to the seller..... it wasn't worth my time to straighten it out.

But as far as I was concerned, it was a programming bug.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#9

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

Ernie Miller

>look at the times on the bids Person 1 made a bid person 2 placed a bid higher $55 then person one made several small bids to get back on top nickeled and dimed his way to be back in charge. I'm betting a good snipe will win the auction cause bidder 1 is just barely holding on to the auction

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#10

Sounds perfectly normal....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Many ebay newbies don't understand the proxy bid on ebay. Let's say I want the thing in the auction. I'm willing to pay $50 so I bid that amount up front. The way ebay works is, my bid only increments by the minimum amount needed to become the high bidder. And this can happen many times and it still only records me as one bid since I only entered the single $50 bid.

Now lets say the novice doesn't understand how the system works. My bid is sitting there at say $5. He bids $7. He's instantly outbid since my original $50 bid rachets up just enough to outbid him by the minimum amount. So he bids again, and again, and again until my bid reaches the maximum $50 I originally entered. Then he's the high bidder. My bid shows only once, the original $50. But since he place multiple individual bids trying to outbid me, his bids show up as just that - multiple individual bids. That's why it looks like he's incrementing his own bids against himself. It doesn't show the leapfrogging of my bids over his as a result of the proxy system.

Hope this makes sense. I see this all the time on ebay.

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#11

Re: eBay programming bugs

Tom

>That happened to me several times. As a matter of fact (or fact as I recall, which may not be), ebay lost a lawsuit regarding this issue of bidders bidding against themselves. I have a vague memory of that from a while back.

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#12

and Perfectly Common

Tom MacGregor

>It's usually people with very low feedback and no clue. What's really fun is watching two of them duke it out. I once saw an item go for $36.50 with 32 bids between two single digit feedback bidders.

Re: OT---Strange e-bay activity

#13

Yes, yuo're right!

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I forgot about that. THere was a class action lawsuit about this. In theory you weren't supposed to be able to bid against yourself, but due to a problem bids were improperly increased under this situation. I think eBay was going to pay each of it's members that was affect $1 or something like that. I can't remember if I applied for it or go it. I seem to remember seeing a small payment from eBay. Perhaps that was it.

Happy Woodworking!