Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OT - Chance of lightning damage?

Posts

OT - Chance of lightning damage?

#1

OT - Chance of lightning damage?

Herb Yost

>Here's the situation: my shop is in an all-steel Butler building, built 1950's. Also in the building are several rooms for artists, including a metal-worker, and a sizeable video production room. On one side of the building are tall trees; on the other side is open field.

Now, our metal-working artist has lately been building some steel totem poles....at least that's what I call them. Not like any totem pole you've ever seen, but I zip my lips on that!!

He has put them out in the open field. They're anywhere from 30-50 feet high, resting directly on the ground. Seems to me they are marvelous lightning rods!!! One of them is about 50' from the corner of the building, and Steve's video room is right at that corner...huge amount of computer and video stuff. One of the pole's feet rests about 2' from a concrete sidewalk which has steel matting in it, and which runs right into the building's foyer.

I got to wondering if that one pole is too close to the building. If lightning were to strike it, would it do damage? I think lightning can radiate underground from the strike point for quite a ways....would hate to see all our stuff get destroyed or fried.

Should we get the artist to move the pole, or am I being nervous about nothing?

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

#2

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage? *LINK*

Bill Howatt

>I'm no expert on this and it seems to me that while you can maybe say what probably might happen it doesn't necessarily unfold that way when dealing with lightning.

Have a look at this link to see how lightening works and how protection systems work. My "guess" is that the poles are not really increasing your chances of a strike and if they were well grounded might be useful.

Based on my limited experience the tall trees beside your building are every bit as much of a risk. Where I live, trees seem to be where the strikes often hit.

Bill


How Lightening Protection Works

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

#3

Perhaps and perhaps not . . .

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Color me unconvinced about lightning rods. Many years ago we had a house supposedly protected by such rods. However, in a major storm the house was hit. The lightning blew a hole in the roof, blew up a telephone, took out 2 electrical circuits, and blew out an electric fencer. It also travelled underground for about a quarter mile to a neighbor's milking barn where it, luckily, only knocked out two cows. This was during milking.

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

#4

Re: Perhaps and perhaps not . . .

Bill Howatt

>I think if you are going to get zapped by a big strike nothing is going to do much to save you, certainly not a cable that you are trying to drive a zillion amps down. Could be they protect against the "lesser" charge build ups. I honestly don't know.

It would be interesting to know, IMO, how many new places put in lightning rods. The ones I see tend to look like older installations.

Bill

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

#5

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

Phileas

>Provided these totem poles are well grounded, I suspect you're OK.

When I worked on an Air Force test range, we attached grounded "bottle brushes" - metel doofers about two feet long with whiskers about three inches long radiating out from the axis - to every metal structure out in the desert. We put a bottle brush on every corner of a single-wide trailer, and on opposite corners of a 50' antenna tower. The theory was that these bottle brushes prevented any charge from accumulating on the object to which they were attached. Instead, the charge was routed to the ground.

In four years, we experienced not one lightning strike. And my towers were the tallest objects for miles around. The key I think was the whiskers; they prevented even a small charge from accumulating, which obviously precluded a large charge.

Oh, yeah. "Grounded" means 1/2" copper wire attached to a copper stake about 3' long driven directly into the earth. The stake was relatively close to the structure - maybe a foot separation, but not a whole lot more than that.

Cheers,

Phileas

P.S. "Doofer" is a technical term used by lightning protection experts world-wide.

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

#6

Re: Perhaps and perhaps not . . .

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I think you are probably right, Bill. I seem to remember a class back in the late '40s or '50s where we were told that lightning rods would not work unless they were at least 3/4" diameter and were grounded 10' deep. Ours certainly did little good - unless w/o them the house might have been gone! Do you by any chance remember the large caliber storm fuses people used to have? My wife's folks in Madison, WI, had two of them. From what I gathered they were supposed to work in a similar manner to rods. I do know they did blow at least once and MG&E had to come and replace them.

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

#7

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

Terry in Edmonton

>I work in the cellular industry and it is our experience that if you are in a grounded metal building the problem isn't from the lightnig directly. The biggest killer of electronic equipment in a stike is the electomagnetic pulse (EMP) that comes with it. Consider the amount of current and how high the voltage in a lightning stike is and you will realize how high the magnetic field generated can be. We have found that the best protection in a STEEL building is to ground the building at the 4 corners to ground rods sunk at leat 10 feet into the ground. We have found nothing that works reliably for nonferrous buildings.

That said, we have approx 500 towers in Alberta, most 350 feet high, and we only have 1 or 2 problem strikes a year. About 1/3 of these sites are in the highest lightning areas of Canada. You probably have little to worry about. Use good surge suppressors on the AC power because that is route most EMP surges take, and make sure the gound to your electrical panel and telephone lines are good.

Re: OT - Chance of lightning damage?

#8

Real-life story

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Lightning hit the ground outside a single story brick office building. It hit the ground (leavign a burn mark) and the power (in whatever form) found it's way into an underground phone line bundle. That phone line bundle was UNUSED and disconnected, but it did come into the building and was attached to the wall on an UNUSED 66-block (for those in the telcom industry you know whtat hat it).

This cable and 66-block was very old and had not been used in years (perhaps 10). There was nothing connected between the old 66-block and the new equipment, but the electricity managed to arc about 10-12 inches from that unused block to a used block.

It melted alot of the metal connectors and fired every single piece of electronic equipment. Because it got it got in between the surge protectors and the equipment, everything: faxes, phones, and even computers.... (just the NIC's) got friend.

Freaky, yes! Alot of people didn't believe me, but we had BellSouth and then the inurance adjust come out and inspect the damage and they were as shocked (pun intended) as I was.

Happy Woodworking!