Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

Posts

Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#1

Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

Dan Manturi

>Ongoing saga of my stepson's new (50 year old) home purchase...

He had seen some hardwood floor refinishing at a friends home and thought it looked great - probably did. He hired these two guys who did refinishing on the side. Saw another example and also thought it looked great. Bottom line - they have refinished the floors (home still vacant) and there are ripples in the sanding of the main floor plus you can see where they used the edge sander, as it is uneven. Varathane was used as finish. FIrst time it was "done", it was "fuzzy". They came back in and apparently loaded the place up with varathane again, in my opinion unsing way too much finish, and now there are puddles in places and also bubbles in areas. Cannot see the gaps between boards - looks like a basketball court. Wood itself is fine, and when the furniture is in place, I am sure folks will come in and be impressed, but the job was botched. Varathane all over baseboards that had just been painted as well. These guys are not a company, no formal business, so there is no legal recourse.

While I am not suggesting we try to remove the uneven sanding (would mean total resanding), is there anything that I can do to make the surface correct? Steel wool buffing and reapply finish? They even missed spots, which is easier to deal with. Last finish applied on 5/30, and I think that anything to be done would need to be done after finish hardens a bit, but I am not sure. He had the floors done in a low lustre.

It is a good thing I am not a younger man. People who do careless work like this should be held accountable, but caveat emptor, I guess...

Suggestions welcome. Thanks for reading this log note.

Dan M.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#2

Tough one, Dan

Ellis Walentine, Host

>That second heavy coat of urethane is the killer. It isn't unusual to have the first coat fuzz up, but it needs to get sanded lightly before adding another coat. At this point, I suspect you will have to either strip the finish with a heavy duty stripper or sand it back to bare wood if you want to remedy the situation. If you do, remember when recoating that you want to use gloss varnish for all but the final coat, so as not to cloud up the transparency of the finish.

I have heard differing reports about sanding sealer, but my floor finishers always put one coat of it on the bare wood to prevent fuzzing and to make sanding easier. It gives a really nice job.

Sorry about the debacle.

Ellis

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#3

Re: Tough one, Dan

Dan Manturi

>I think these guys did use a sealer first. I am not up to stripping the floors and he does not have the time.

I was thinking of renting a buffer and using a steel wool pad to even out the finish then going over it with a coat of gloss. I know he wants low lustre, but I think that the floor does look a little cloudy.

It may be best for them to just live with what they have. I cannot tell you how angry I am. But that is a waste of time..

Thanks.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#4

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

Curly Smith

>I'd just fix the "missed" areas

Absent sanding and refinishing there's not really anything you can do about the "fuzzy" finish. Putting a coat of clear gloss over two coats of a low luster finish will be just as cloudy so your work really won't accomplish anything.

I'd arrange the furniture to show off the best areas of the floor while hiding the problems. Maybe that means buying a few rugs (now you know what house-warming present to buy!) but unless you're prepared to redo the job then you're pretty well stuck with the floor the way it is. Tell the stepson to hire a licensed and bonded contractor the next time.

Question: is your daughter-in-law happy with the floor? If she is, tell her it's fine because her opinion is the only one that really matters.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#5

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

Dan Manturi

>She is OK with almost anything. Sort of surprised it turned out as it did as the other places looked good.

I guess it is what it is.

Thanks.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#6

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

Ted Wong

>I know it's hard to look at shoddy workmanship. But If your stepson is old enough to purchase a house, find labor to do the work and write a check to pay for it then he's probably old enough to deal with the folks who did the work if hes not happy with the job they did.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#7

Re: Tough one, Dan

Howard Acheson

>Dan, hereis what I would do first. Let the floor completely dry for at least four weeks. This will give even the thicker film areas time to fully cure. Once cured, get a pole sander and some 220 screens and sand the whole floor. If the sanding doesn't produce dust--but instead seems to sort of "ball" up, let it dry a couple of more weeks. Dust and then recoat using an applicator pad on the pole. Work carefully and stroke slowly to minimize bubbles.

BTW, was the finish an oil based or a waterbased? Varathane makes both.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#8

hardwood floor owners beware

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I have heard this story repeated countless times. I am convinced that there are more people out there that can't do an acceptable job that there are that can.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#9

Lee Gordon

Re: hardwood floor owners beware

Lee Gordon

>That is true in any field, not just floor refinishing.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#10

Re: hardwood floor refinishing

Chuck Lenz

>I refinished floors for a year when I was younger. It is not a easy thing to do. Floor sanders and edge sanders are tricky and so is laying a finish, it takes time and alot of patience and even then mistakes happen. Whoever hired the weekend warriors that do it on the side should only be mad at themselves. You tried to save a buck and thats what you got, less than professional results. I've known a guy personally in town that has refinished floors for a liveing for atleast 25 years, last year he gave it up, doesn't want any part of it anymore. He has moved on to other things. I can't say that I blame him.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#11

Re: hardwood floor owners beware

Dan Manturi

>Yes, understand that going in he was taking a gamble but having seen results in two homes and having recommendations of 2 friends of his, as well as the financial list of things to do when buying your first home and hoping he could get a decent job at a good price, he felt, based on what he saw and heard, he would get a serviceable result. I am not going to berate him on that, as I am sure he already is based on his mood right now.

With respect to him dealing with them, I know he would do a better job of that than I would. Right now, I wish I was the 39 year old Dan and not the 59 year old Dan. Old age puts you in touch with your limitations. I am probably more angry about it than he is. I am the "fixer of broken things". Do not know if there is any road I can take on this.

Dan

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#12

Re: Tough one, Dan

Dan Manturi

>Howard,

Thanks - this is info I can use. Oil base is what they used and your idea sounds like something we can do.

Thanks much.

Dan

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#13

Re: hardwood floor owners beware

BilWil

>First, I agree with Howard that screening is your best alternative, given the limitations you have described. You'll need to come up with a method to get into the corners and the last inch or so next to the wall. Depending on the machine you use for the screening and whether or no you remove shoe and baseboard, you may have as much as 2 and 1/2 inches next to all the walls.

I did a similar, not the same, fix on my daughter's home. I rented a heavy floor buffer and a thick flet pad. I put the buffer with the pad on screens of 150, then 180, then 220, she wanted the final finish to be gloss. Using the buffer made the work go very quickly, even though the finish appeared as thought it had been poured on in spots. Since we weren't taking the finish to bare wood we were careful to never let the buffer remain in one spot.

In her case the finish was over 1 year old so I knew it was fully cured. I took off the shoe mold and the baseboard, I ended up with about 1 and 1/4 inch next to the walls I couldn't reach and, of course the corners. I used my 6 inch random orbit sander and Mirka Abranet 180 and 220 to get those areas. Then for the corners I used my 1/4 sheet vibrating sander and cut the Abranet to fit.

I had to be careful blending in the different areas done with different equipment, and although it wasn't perfect it is still very good. Both my daughter ans my wife were happy.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#14

Re: hardwood floor owners beware

Dan Manturi

>This too is information that is very valuable to me. I am leaning toward telling my stepson to forget these clowns and just do it ourselves, starting in a spare bedroom to refine technique and finishing in living and dining rooms.

I really think too that glossy is the way to go, as more semi gloss over semi gloss will just exacerbate the cloudiness which is not terrible right now, but could be.

Much appreciated.

Dan

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#15

Re: hardwood floor owners beware

Andy Halterman: We need more rain

>Dan,

Whatever you do, be patient. The advice given to you about waiting for the finish to cure longer is good stuff. The only way you can get it off right now is to scrape it. That would be fine if you wish to undertake that route but you'll burn up lots of sandpaper trying to sand that stuff off.

Also, in the future, do some checking around and hire someone who does that gig full time. Floor finishing is about as much an art as a science. It takes time to learn the trade and a deft touch to get good results. Been at it almost 20 years and I still learn more all the time.

Good luck with your "problem".

Andy Halterman

Enjoying a blast from the past watching Fast Times at Ridgemont High in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#16

Re: hardwood floor owners beware

Chuck Lenz

>Gloss is also a harder finish, thats why gym floors are gloss. We allways used gloss.

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#17

finish hardness

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>The delustering agent is silica which is 5 orders of magnitude (this is an estimate) harder than the finish. However, I have heard reasonable explanations for how the delustering agent could contribute to somewhat decreased stability of the finish when exposed to the elements. .

Re: Long - botched floor refinishing - what to do?

#18

Re: finish hardness

Chuck Lenz

>Bill, thats the same thing I heard. The silica makes the finish less durable.