Re: OTish - Welders
ScottS
>Lots of good advice already. I learned to weld last year and have probably been doing more welding than woodworking in recent months. So, from a "newbie" perspective here's what I have to say:
MIG welding is very easy to learn. Unlike Forrest Addy, I've never had any problems with weld bead contamination when using gas-shielded MIG welds. I have, however, seen lots of really ugly looking stick welds. When welding mild steel, I used ER70S-6 wire, C-25 shielding gas, and do only minimal cleaning. I haven't had a weld fail yet, but that's not really saying anything... If you want to start MIG welding, buy a 220V machine. I bought the Millermatic 175 and wish I'd gone with the equivalent Lincoln. The Miller has a feature called "Wire Speed Tracking", which is supposed to help beginners but invariably seems to make it more difficult to get the machine settings dialed-in properly. At least for me. For MIG welders, I would only consider Miller, Lincoln, or Hobart welders is buying new.
If you're a perfectionist TIG welding is the way to go. It's far more difficult to learn and much slower than MIG, but you have incredibly precise control over the weld bead. It's also more "clean" in that it doesn't generate the fumes or showers of sparks the MIG or stick welding do. In addition, TIG gives you much geater flexibility in terms of the types of metal you can work with. And the equipment is a minimum of 3X more expensive than MIG. I was lucky enough to find a used AC/DC TIG machine for $1500, which was twice what I paid for the Millermatic. New, the machine would have been $2200. If you decide to purchase a TIG welder, I'd suggest buying an "inverter" based machine. Inverters are small (40lbs), use less power (~30A @ 220V), and often have more advanced features for controlling the weld. The alternative is a transformer-based machine. These are large, heavy (think cabinet saw weight) and current-hungry (often 50-70+ amps @ 220V). If you don't think you'll need to weld aluminum, you can get by with a DC-only machine and save some money.
FWIW, I don't think I've plugged the MIG welder in since I learned how to TIG...
Buying a welder is just the start of the game, unfortunately. Just like a table saw, there are lots of accessories to "add on" before you become productive. As someone else suggested, an auto-darkening hood is a great purchase; now that I have one, I'm not sure how I ever managed to weld without it. The cheap ($50) ones from Harbor Freight actually aren't too bad, though they don't seem to work well with my inverter-based TIG welder for some reason. I bought a HF to start with, then eventually upgraded to a Miller "Big Window" Elite (~$300) that has all of the bells and whistles.
Finally, I'd suggest getting some instruction from someone. If you're not sure where to find instruction, call your local welding supply shop. They can probably point you to local classes or refer you to a local welder. The guys at my local independently-owned shop were more than happy to set a machine up for me to test and give me pointers on welding. That said, I did take a weekend class to learn MIG welding and an 8-evening class to learn TIG. You might mention your goals when asking people about classes. In my area, many of the classes are targeted at professional welders who want to get certified in a particular kind of welding. If you just want to stick some pieces of steel together as part of a furniture building project, you might not need the same level of detail/instruction as someone building a bridge or skyscraper...
If you want more advice, feel free to e-mail me. As I said, I recently got started and would be more than happy to share the research I did when deciding what types of classes to take, what to buy, etc.