Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OTish - Welders

Posts

OTish - Welders

#1

OTish - Welders

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>My BIL stored his big MIG welder in my garage for a few years, but I never took advantage of that opportunity, to learn and use the machine, as there was no immediate need. Now that the welder is gone (of course) I find myself in need of a welder for various jobs in and out of the shop. I just don't know what to get.

I did use a little bit the old standby stick welder at my father's place, but it's a little far to go there for a welding job (400+ miles). So I'm thinking that maybe I should get myself a small welder. I don't plan to weld anything thicker than 1/4".

Father's day sales have begun sprouting around, so there are a number of small MIG welders available on sale. Stuff like the Lincoln Pro Pak 10, and other brands, that work on 110V. I just don't know if these things are toys or whether I can do decent work with those units.

I have 220V available in the garage, so I could go with a stick welder if that's the better solution. Whatever solution is chosen will have to be easy on the budget...

Never mind for the moment that I still have to learn to weld...

Ideally I'd like to be able to weld aluminium too, but from what I've heard, machines that can do that cost an arm and a leg, in which case I'm willing to forego that capability.

Endless appreciation to anyone willing to provide me guidance...

DC

Re: OTish - Welders

#2

Lincoln......

Basil

>....cracker box, sometimes called a buzz box. It's the little 225 amp. AC machine they've made and sold for years and years. Runs on 220 volts and will burn DC rods (LH 7018 etc.)if you warm them up a bit before welding with them. I just stick the DC rods to whatever I'm welding for a couple of seconds and then break'em loose and start welding. .....to lazy to rig a rod box with a light in it. Old fridge does just fine.

I can remember when you could buy them for $80 bucks. I'm lowballing a guess of about $275 now maybe.

Re: OTish - Welders

#3

Re: OTish - Welders

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>Stick welders are significantly cheaper. The right stick can let you weld thinner materials too, which is where the cheaper (but generally more expensive than sticks) 110-volt Mig excell.

You might look into gas welding for aluminum or thinner metals (Google Henrob), and get the stick for starters on up to 1/4" stuff.

Re: OTish - Welders

#4

Re: OTish - Welders

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>For ocasional use by inexperianced users it is hard to beat the 110v mig units, especially if you consider their extreme versatility. I am not up on model #'s and makers but there are a couple diferent levels of quality or capability. As with all tools it is often nice to get one that will support more options down the road. Some 110v migs will only let you use flux core wire and some will allow you to add a sheilding gas. With the use of a sheilding gas it is possible to weld aluminium with a mig welder, a tig will produce a stronger and prettier weld on Al if you are willing to spend the aditional 2K, but a mig will still stick two pices of aluminium together.

Robin Corell

Re: OTish - Welders

#5

Concur with Basil

Forrest Addy

>Concur with Basil.

I bought a Lincoln 225 in 1962. Between then and 1982 I made far more money with it than the rest of all my equipment put together. The machine is bonehead simple, butt ugly, and utterly reliable. I did some real sophisticated welding with it too. A used garage sale Lincoln 225 that doesn't smell scorched is as good as a brand new one. This is an AC only machine with 8 heats and a limited duty cycle yet it's up to the requirements of the home and farm workshop for projects to a surprizinly large scale.

Nowadays people like MIG and the small better MIG welders are slick and sweet. The problem that few people care to acknowledge is that without fluxing action of a stick rod, a MIG weld can easily be contaminated by surface dirt and be weakened or embrittled. A fluxed rod will bring most of this to the surface and include it in the slag. The MIG deposit will contain whatever has been caught up in the puddle. Therefore reliable MIG welds require the metal surface to be clean to some distance from the heat affected zone including mill scale. Another point is thicknesses to be preheated if the wire is small and the available electrical input to the arc limited.

So long at these limitations are understoof and provided for a MIG machine is a valuable metalworking asset.

If you have 230 in your shop the 170 Amp MIG machines and a cylinder of Agron or Argon mix will serve you quite well and give you some capability with aluminum. I wouldn't reccommend the 115 Volt MIG machines unless you need the portability and will never weld thicker than 1/8".

I recently bought a Miller 210 with the spool gun option and a cylinder of argon. This is a very handy package although I wish I had got the argon mix for steel.

There are a lot of things to consider when purchasing a welder. Spend a little time and don;t get talked into any particular process until your worklond settled in a particular direction.

I have two welders (stick/TIG and Mig) and oxy/acetyelene. I have it all covered. For a first welder I'm tempted to suggest a good stick machine as being the most capable of covering a lot of options; a 230 Volt 170 Amp MIG would be my second choice.

Re: OTish - Welders

#6

Re: OTish - Welders

Larry Marker in Alabama

>I have a Hobart "Handler 125" and am quite satisfied with it. It comes setup for flux core wire only, but you can buy a gas conversion kit for it.

If you are a novice welder, I'd recommend you find a trade school where you can take an adult ed class in welding. That's what I did and had a chance to try several kinds of welders before I settled on a small mig.

Larry

Re: OTish - Welders

#7

Re: OTish - Welders

Bruce Wrenn

>In our shop, we have a Miller Bobcat( gasoline engine driven), Miller 230V, stick welder, and a Hobart 140 Mig unit. Bobcat is used in the field for machinery repairs and stuctual welding. Stick welder is used for the same at shop. Mig unit is the most handy, as it can be carried into a building, plugged into 110 outlet, and WELD! Just be sure that smoke/ infa red heat detectors are turned off. Trouble with gas shielded is that even the smallest breeze will blow your gas away. Each has it's place. I would avoid those $100- $200 imported mig units though. Stick with a name brand (Miller, Hobart, Lincoln, and Century.) Century's biggest business is building battery chargers, which is basically what a welder actually is. Check out local Craigslist for used units, especially where someone has bought a bigger/ fancier unit.

Re: OTish - Welders

#8

Re: OTish - Welders

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>As a home shop unit, the little mig's are hard to beat. I have a AC buzz box 295 amp max. I also have a Century (labeled with Tractor Supply brand) 125 amp 115V flux core / argon mig. For thin (they say 1/4 I would not use it on over 3/16) material, it is hard to beat. I currently have CO2/Argon mix - good for mild steel. I also have flux core wire which doesn't require shielding gas. I purchased mine at the Tractor Supply store. They sell the tanks - and you just return and pay for the refill when needed. If your going to weld aluminum, you need to use pure Argon shielding gas and - on at least my machine - a couple of changes to the wire feed system - required to not contaminate the aluminum wire. I don't believe any flux core welding wire exists for aluminum. The Mig is extremely easy to use. I took a stick welding class many years ago and used to do a bit now and then - really hard for me now. I would also recommend you buy an Auto dark welding helmet - for any welder you purchase. These sure help me now. I don't think I could weld today without one.

Re: OTish - Welders

#9

Thanks, keep'em coming... Deca welders?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Thanks for all the responses so far...

Looking at the latest flyer from Princess Auto (a Canadian chain), they have a Deca wire fed welder that might be the ticket, if they are of decent quality. a 130 amp model goes on sale soon for $222, whereas a Lincoln Mig Pak 10 (100 amp) is currently on sale somewhere else for $500.

Anyone knows the Deca brand? I like the fact that they don't come from China, in this case Italy (actually San Marino).

Thanks again,

DC

Re: OTish - Welders

#10

Re: Only Forrest mentioned

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Denis,

Forrest is the only responder who mentioned "duty cycle". Duty cycle is the percent of time that the machine will do work. In other words, a 20% duty cycle welder can be used for 12 minutes out of 60 minutes. After 12 minutes (or thereabout) the machine will shut down to protect itself from overheating. It's my observation of MIG welders that price increases faster than duty cycle. That is, to buy a machine with a duty twice that of the baseline machine, one will pay much more than double the price.

Al

Re: OTish - Welders

#11

Re: Only Forrest mentioned

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Al, your right about the cost/duty cycle relationship. However for a home shop I haven't ever found it to be a problem. I suppose if you were welding up a large tank or using it for production purposes with long welds it would be. I think my little mig has a 15 or 20% duty cycle. In reality I probably couldn't sustain an arc 15% of the time. The welder is resting/coolint while aligning the parts to be welded, repositioning for welds etc. I'm sure the rating is also figuring high ambient temperatures etc. I've never kicked out either of my welders. In any event - even if it did kick out due to the thermal load, it would cool down in 5 - 10 minutes.

Re: OTish - Welders

#12

Re: Duty cycle

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Larry,

I agree with you. Not knowing exactly what Denis will be welding, my intent was to make him aware of one of the main reasons for price differences of units that he may look at. Often, two welders with similar features carry wildly different price tags. The main difference is, often, duty cycle. As with most items, brand name, reputation, quality, and service also enter the price picture.

Al

Re: OTish - Welders

#13

Re: OTish - Welders

ScottS

>Lots of good advice already. I learned to weld last year and have probably been doing more welding than woodworking in recent months. So, from a "newbie" perspective here's what I have to say:

MIG welding is very easy to learn. Unlike Forrest Addy, I've never had any problems with weld bead contamination when using gas-shielded MIG welds. I have, however, seen lots of really ugly looking stick welds. When welding mild steel, I used ER70S-6 wire, C-25 shielding gas, and do only minimal cleaning. I haven't had a weld fail yet, but that's not really saying anything... If you want to start MIG welding, buy a 220V machine. I bought the Millermatic 175 and wish I'd gone with the equivalent Lincoln. The Miller has a feature called "Wire Speed Tracking", which is supposed to help beginners but invariably seems to make it more difficult to get the machine settings dialed-in properly. At least for me. For MIG welders, I would only consider Miller, Lincoln, or Hobart welders is buying new.

If you're a perfectionist TIG welding is the way to go. It's far more difficult to learn and much slower than MIG, but you have incredibly precise control over the weld bead. It's also more "clean" in that it doesn't generate the fumes or showers of sparks the MIG or stick welding do. In addition, TIG gives you much geater flexibility in terms of the types of metal you can work with. And the equipment is a minimum of 3X more expensive than MIG. I was lucky enough to find a used AC/DC TIG machine for $1500, which was twice what I paid for the Millermatic. New, the machine would have been $2200. If you decide to purchase a TIG welder, I'd suggest buying an "inverter" based machine. Inverters are small (40lbs), use less power (~30A @ 220V), and often have more advanced features for controlling the weld. The alternative is a transformer-based machine. These are large, heavy (think cabinet saw weight) and current-hungry (often 50-70+ amps @ 220V). If you don't think you'll need to weld aluminum, you can get by with a DC-only machine and save some money.

FWIW, I don't think I've plugged the MIG welder in since I learned how to TIG...

Buying a welder is just the start of the game, unfortunately. Just like a table saw, there are lots of accessories to "add on" before you become productive. As someone else suggested, an auto-darkening hood is a great purchase; now that I have one, I'm not sure how I ever managed to weld without it. The cheap ($50) ones from Harbor Freight actually aren't too bad, though they don't seem to work well with my inverter-based TIG welder for some reason. I bought a HF to start with, then eventually upgraded to a Miller "Big Window" Elite (~$300) that has all of the bells and whistles.

Finally, I'd suggest getting some instruction from someone. If you're not sure where to find instruction, call your local welding supply shop. They can probably point you to local classes or refer you to a local welder. The guys at my local independently-owned shop were more than happy to set a machine up for me to test and give me pointers on welding. That said, I did take a weekend class to learn MIG welding and an 8-evening class to learn TIG. You might mention your goals when asking people about classes. In my area, many of the classes are targeted at professional welders who want to get certified in a particular kind of welding. If you just want to stick some pieces of steel together as part of a furniture building project, you might not need the same level of detail/instruction as someone building a bridge or skyscraper...

If you want more advice, feel free to e-mail me. As I said, I recently got started and would be more than happy to share the research I did when deciding what types of classes to take, what to buy, etc.

Re: OTish - Welders

#14

look at clarke welders too

Ed Snow

>good quality machines. great prices.

and like everyone else has said don't get a 110v machine if you don't have to. just too wimpy.

Re: OTish - Welders

#15

Re: OTish - Welders

Ronald

>I bought a Henrob and i can weld anything but titinum and it cuts like a plaz cutter. I have welded aluminum. but what amazed me most was the time i cut, like a plaz cutter, 1 inch thick steel plate. Go for the henrob you won't regret it.

Re: OTish - Welders

#16

Lincoln WeldPak 240V

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I have Lincoln WeldPak 155, which is the larger brother of the WeldPak 100 which was avialable at HomeDepot and Lowes a few years back.

It's a 240V MIG welder (I got it without the gas tank, so I just use it as a wirefeed welder). Very nice, and not too expensive. I looked some of the better Lincoln and Miller ones that are about this size, and decided for the amount of use (once or twice a year) I don't need to spend twice as much to get one that other people would use weekly or daily.

Nice thing about getting a Lincoln or Miller, even their entry level models, is parts availability.

I had a more powerful and less expensive Lincoln stick welder, but the wirefeed is SOOO much easier to use.

Happy Woodworking!