Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

Posts

The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#1

The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>If you don't know what I am talking about go to leevalley.com, click on item search and type in "CMC". Canadian woodworkers will be especially interested.

To cut to the chase, I'm in love again (with a piece of furniture). I am going to build this desk which is going to involve figuring out construction details (eg how are the drawers guided) and scaling it to make plans. If anyone else is contemplating building it I would like to share the efforts figuring out how.

Editorial: While I like looking at the fine pieces of Goddard, et. al., these high toned pieces are not compatible with my life style, or home. The clocks and secretaries wouldn't fit in my home! Unfortunately for me, and maybe someone else, it is these kinds of pieces that get reproduced, described, drawn, published, etc. It is less common to see the less formal but still refined "country furniture" described in a way that would enable it to be reliably reproduced by amateurs. I wish more of this country furniture would be described and drawings made of it and published. This desk would be good place to start.

As an example, take the Chester Co chest I recently built. There must be a great deal of interest in it because I have seen pictures of it in every compilation of Chester Co furniture or other furniture of that region. This Doan desk is a similar Canadian example. Look at the interest the Spice Box book kindled. If that many people are interested in looking at a picture of pieces such as these, I would presume there might be a significant number of woodworkers wanting to make a stab at reproducing them, which leads to a market opportunity for the museums and publishers

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#2

Nice looking piece

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I agree that there is a market for plans for vernacular pieces like this, Bill. Maybe WoodCentral should solicit measured drawings of selected pieces and edit them together with parts lists and step-by-step instructions. Grass roots plans, in a sense. If they turn out to be as popular as you think, it could be a nice little revenue generator. :-)

Let us know what you figure out...

Ellis

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#3

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

Hank Knight from SC

>Bill, I absolutely agree with everything you said. The desk on the LV catalog cover caught my eye, too, and for the same reasons it caught yours. Not only is it a beautiful piece, but the scale is very appealing.

My wife and I fell in love with early Kentucky furniture when we lived there years ago. The elegant simplicity and the comfortable scale of these pieces fit our lifestyle and tastes. I have looked in vain for good drawings of these pieces. Unfortunately, they don't appear to be available. High-style classical designers like Goddard, Townsend and Thomas Elfe (Charleston) are well documented as are the Shaker designs, but there is a disappointing dearth of drawings for high quality Early American/Canadian pieces. There are plenty of books with sketches or line drawings and basic dimensions for Early American furniture out there, but good technical drawings are not readily available.

I'm not well accomplished at design rendering, but I gladly offer whatever help I can be to address the problem.

Hank

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#4

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

cse

>Check out the pieces done by Glen Huey at woodworkersedge.com. He has some exquisite pieces and I think that there is a piece in there that matches the desk. He has plans available along with many others.

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#5

A contrary opinion

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The Doan desk is great, and certainly worthy of reproducing. However, anyone with the experience and skill to make such a piece probably can create a working plan with alterations to individualize it. Even if those folks used a commercial plan, it's a small market. Further, aside from the considerable investment in time to make it, the amount and quality of wood going into it adds up to a significant dollar expense, Those who can successfully address the project are probably too few to support developing marketable plans at a profit.

Clint

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#6

Another

Bob McGovern

>One of the joys of vernacular or provincial furniture is that it was generally made by artisans working away from the centers of high culture (& the rule-bound traditions that go with it), using the tools and materials available to them. Sometimes an approximation of a style they had seen and liked. Sometimes completely reinventing the whole approach to, say, a hall clock.

So in keeping with the tradition, I'd say eyeball this desk you like, make some reasoned guesses about dimensions and construction, & have at it. Probably what the original maker did.

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#7

some other factors to consider

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>There are pieces that have become famous for representing a period or style of construction. One of the factors that make them special is that they are perfectly proportioned. It is very difficult to get exact dimension from a picture and I am not going to make more than one of these to get it right by trial and error. I just went through an episode of this kind with a famous Chester Co chest so I have recent experience with this issue. I missed a drawer height by 3/8" and the piece would be better looking if I had got it right. Hence, a dimensioned drawing is essential to reproduce the piece, and the effort to create a dimensioned drawing is not great. Many museums do it anyway for their files.

Second, there is no clue from the photograph how the maker chose to guide the drawer. The case side construction is not typical for a slant desk so my experience is no guide. The desk has lasted 150 years, so what ever was done, the maker got it right. A person reproducing the piece would benefit from knowing how the maker got it right.

Finally, I know several people that do period reproduction work and all would pay for a drawing rather than try to estimate dimensions from a picture.

You are right on one issue. We don't need details for installing the door hinge, the sort of fluff that fills books on this topic.

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#8

I guess the bottom line is....

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>how much would you pay for a set of drawings/plans that include the drawer guide detail, and maybe even the hinge placement instructions? $10? $50? $100?

Clint

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#9

$50

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>And at that price I won' t make minimum wage if I figure it all out for myself.

Re: The desk in the May Lee Valley catalog

#10

Re: $50

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>But if you made up a set of measured plans/drawings and materials list, you could make your own wersion then sell copies at $50 each, enabling you to quit your day job and retire.

Clint