Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Posts

Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#1

Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

wilbur

>(I wasn't sure if it was better to post this here or the hand tools forum, so I flipped a coin.)

I don't know why I was thinking about this, but it occurred to me that when I read reviews of jointers, a common criticism is that the jointer bed is "too short", theoretically limiting the length of the board that can be flattened.

If this really is a limiting factor, how is it that you able to flatten a long board using hand planes? Even a #7 or #8 jointer plane is much shorter than the shortest jointer that I know of, but flattening a long board with hand planes is possible, even if it takes some effort.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#2

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Sgian Dubh

>The problem with powered surface planers (jointers) is not that they won't flatten long boards because the tables are too short. The difficulty is more to do with balancing the board on the tables at the beginning and end of each cut--- laws of physics, mechanical advantage and moments about a point and all that sort of stuff.

In pracice, but with help of one sort or another, 20' planks can be flattened on a short bedded machine. The help required usually comes in the form of a nimble footed but knowledgable helper to balance the board at the beginning and end of each cut. An alternative is precisely set up rollers either end of the machine to support the wood at the beginning and end of the cut thus effectively increasing the length of the tables.

Hand planes are the opposite, small and light and easily balanced on the fixed piece of wood. It sounds like you already know how to get large planks flat with these, so there's no need for me to go over the details. Slainte.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#3

jointing long stuff

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>My record on a 6" jointer was straightening a 16' x 8" piece of 8/4 red oak for a hand rail for a store. It took two people- one to push and one to hold the out feed end up.It was a lot faster than doing it with a hand plane. It is not uncommon to have to mow 1/2" off portions of an edge to get a long piece straight. It can be done with a hand plane, slowly, but I don't see a hand plane replacing my jointer.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#4

Jointer bed length

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Bill points out a critical factor in straightness, and it has nothing to do with the width of the jointer, except that wider jointers are usually longer as well. (That hasn't always been true. David Lamb, in New Hampshire, has a jointer that is 24" wide and shorter than any 6" jointer I've seen. The old timers knew that you could rig up an outfeed table to a short-bed jointer and extend its usefulness in straightening long boards.

For my part, I had a 10" Inca jointer/planer in my shop BF (before the fire) and I built a 4' outfeed table for it. I was able to routinely joint 14' boards and timbers on this odd setup and get near perfectly straight surfaces.

Ellis

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#5

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Wilbur,

A few thoughts.

I have had the experience of working with figured wood on a jointer and having terrible tear out.

At Sheridan College here in Oakville, Rob Diemert showed me how you could shear joint a face on a wide jointer (12-16") and simulate using shearing plane cuts by hand.

You have already heard the comments on bed lentgh and how that is a prime feature for a machine jointer in my books, but I have a 22" hand jointer plane and I use it often to clean up a machine edge if I am looking for a fine fit on a panel glue up.

Now, having said all of that I recently replaced the head in my 8" General jointer with a Byrd Shelix helical head.....the cut on that is unreal!

So I will say that you need to know your wood and how it responds to both a machine jointer and hand jointing, and in some cases using them together can give you a superiour result, but it takes time understanding how to use what you have.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#6

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Kinda of my (in a way) bad or incomplete information - I posted in a reply to a person wanting to set up a shop, presuming they were a "newbe". With the 6' bed on my 8" Grizzly jointer, I (alone) can fairly easily straighten an 8" X 10' board without any additional stands.- My son & I together have straightened 14' oak boards together. I also said it made sense to buy a wider ( 8" ) jointer so you could face plane wide(r) boards. Again, I know there are "workarounds" that allow you to face about 12" boards on a 6" jointer, but it certainly isn't easy for an inexperienced person. There are many woodworkers who replaced a perfectly good 6" jointer with an 8", including me, for the ease of working larger lumber easier. I know there are ways to straighten long boards with a short planer (did some when I had my 6" with about a 3' bed) but really wasn't easy to me (and I did waste a few pieces of lumber). I felt a novice would be much better off using a wider / longer bed jointer for long wide boards. I know it sure wasn't easy for me when I started. I guess it is all in what you expect your machine to do. (and what your capable of doing). When I built my first home in 1964, I had a retired pattern maker help me. He didn't install my new kitchen cabinets with a plane. He scribed the walls and used a small, very sharp hatchet. He did about 24' of cabinets in less than 15 minutes. The finish from his hatchet was as good as most experienced people could get from a plane and the fit was within 1/64". However I would not recommend that I or 99.9% of the woodworkers I know attempt to do this.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#7

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Edge and Face jointing

Jim in Burlington On

>I have used alot of different jointers hand and powered. It's certainly possible to get a flat product from both given some skills. Where power jointer bed length make a difference for me is face jointing wide heavy boards.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#8

Re: infeed and outfeed tables

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>One of the local hardwood suppliers has tables built onto their jointer that extend a good 6' in front and in back. Doesn't all need to be cast iron...

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#9

Back when I had muscles I was pretty good

Forrest Addy

>Back when I had muscles I was pretty good with a hand plane. I could take crooked cupped lumber and straighten it out using not much more than a string, a level, and maybe winding sticks. Once I got one side flattened I could go around with a marking gage and make a nice parallel plank. However it was hard sweaty work and it took time.

A jointer will accomplish more in the line of straightening and stock removal in a half hour than a powerful 30 year old with hand tools could do in day. The machine knife ripple you can never quite eliminate comes right up with a hand or cabinet scraper. (Which reminds me I had a Stanley #10 cabinet scraper for many years until I dropped it and it broke in about 6 places. Maybe I can silver braze it back together now that I know some new tricks.)

In recent years, I've seldom done any major lumber prep using a hand plane. I use a plane mostly as an adjunct with my woodworking machines. My usual reason for hand planing after I got a jointer and a planer was that it showed me where the locked-in strains lay and any funny grain that was present before I put the machines to it.

In my opinion hand tool users are the salt of the earth but they're missing a good productivity bet by not using planers and jointers for lumber prep. OTH, maybe that's why they avoid power tools. It gives them more time to work with the wood.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#10

Re: Back when I had muscles I was pretty good

NickB

>Yeah, there is something very satisfying about using a hand plane to face and edge joint a board true, but man does it take forever. Before I got my General 480, I spent a lot of time and sweat hand jointing boards (I did an entire kitchen-worth of rail and stile stock for new cabinet doors-at least they used plywood for the flat panels), which gave a great sense of accomplishment, but now that I have three young kids (6, 4, and 2), it's power tools all the way for stock prep. The few minutes I get in the shop just don't allow anything but the speediest methods.

Nick

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#11

I'd say Richard really summed it up well...

John in New Mexico

>The only thing I'd add, is that though slower, a handplane has the advantage of being able to take off just enough if you're trying to conserve thickness or width. Power jointers use much larger increments, so you can end up being a 16th less than what you're shooting for. A minor point I admit, but one guy I worked for was pretty particular about keeping table tops at 13/16th's.

John

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#12

Somewhat contrarian opinion

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I think that the speed advantage of the tailed jointer is somewhat exaggerated.

If the boards are mildly warped, one pass or two on the jointer will put a straight face and edge. However, if a board is severely out of flat, the advantage diminishes substantially. One needs to take many many passes (or take deep cuts, which brings its own load of problems) before getting a flat face. In these circumstances one could use the standard planes (scrub, jack and jointer) and get there nearly as fast.

And don't forget that with the hand planes the surface is finished and can be used as is, whereas with a jointer one will need to plane, scrape or sand the surface to get rid of the machine marks, an extra operation that has to be taken in consideration when comparing the speed of both approaches.

Also, jointers are finicky beasts, easily get out of tune (unless you have a heavy-duty machine), enough so that I check my machine (General International 6") before each jointing session, having been burned oftentimes before.

When I got my jointer I felt like a new world of possibilities had opened to me. Years later, when I got serious about hand planes, my enthusiasm for the tailed beast had waned substantially. I still own mine, but it sees less and less use. The planer though, that machine will pried away from my cold dead fingers :-)

Now, back to the original question, in theory one can joint any length of stock on any jointer, one needs to think of the jointer as an upside down plane and take off the high parts of the board. Easier said than done when handling a twisted 8/4, 8" wide by 8' long piece of maple...

DC

Oh, the cordless planes also generate a lot less noise and dust, and use no electrons...

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#13

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

wilbur

>I probably should have picked a better title. I wasn't looking to start a powered jointers are better/worse than jointing with a hand plane discussion, but I was interested in seeing why jointer bed length is a recurring theme in powered jointer reviews, when one can, with some effort, get excellent results using a hand plane that is much shorter than the bed of a powered jointer. A typical statement in a jointer review goes along the lines of, "The Woodplaner J-600 had jointer tables that were 7 cubits long, making it the longest in its class," which usually results in a higher rating ("9.5 out of 10 -- Grand Poobah's choice!").

Like Ellis, I've got a 10" combination jointer/planer machine, although it's a Rikon, not an Inca. I've had good luck jointing boards as long as 6 feet on it, even though the jointer bed is only 40" long.

I've seen articles on building outfeed and extension tables for every machine EXCEPT a jointer, which seems odd to me.

I guess my takeaway message from the experiences posted here is that jointer bed length is somewhat of an oversold feature. If jointer bed length was really that critical, hand planes would do a crappy job of flattening a board. Granted, longer is better, but it doesn't seem that it should be a critical factor in determining what jointer to buy.

Jointer width, on the other hand, is a much more critical feature. I've been very glad I've got 10" of width capacity on my jointer, but so far I haven't found that length capacity has been a limiting factor.

In other words, my bet is that for most people a wider jointer with shorter beds would be more useful than a narrower jointer with longer beds.

Besides, outside of floor to ceiling cabinets and, as Bill mentioned, railings, I can't think of many projects that would require very long boards. And if I ever hit that limit, I'll take Ellis' advice and build an outfeed table.

P.S. I agree that a hand plane often will get me a finer surface than my powered jointer will, although this may just be a reflection of my crappy technique on my powered jointer.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#14

Denis, I disagree that jointers are finiky. Once

Don henthorn

>my old 6" Rockwell was set up I never had to touch it again until the blades needed sharpening. I am curious as to why you call them finicky.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#15

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Wilbur, as for projects requiring longer boards, my youngest son and I are trimming his entire house - baseboard, windows, doors, and ceiling molding. We are making it all from rough sawn White oak. I don't disagree with your assessment that you can hand plane any length. But you don't just start by laying a plane that weighs 40 to 60 lb on the end of the board and plane away, (similar to jointing on a powered jointer.) The advantage to a powered jointer is that it will quickly and with little labor flatten a long board. At 66, I don't relish the amount of hand labor required to plane a dozen, 1 to 1 1/4" thick 8" wide, 10 - 12 foot long, white oak boards down to 3/4 and make them flat. The longer jointer bed allows for much easier manipulation of bowed boards and has more out-feed table length to keep the board stable. I had a short bed - now have a long bed and would never go back. I suppose I could make or purchase stands for outboard supports but it would be very difficult to make them near as accurate as my cast iron beds. - Same reason I have cast extension tables on my Unisaw. (I do own a Stanley #7 and about 15 other planes - and do use them some.)

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#16

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Dan Donaldson

>I wonder if the difference is that with a handplane, you can pick the areas that you want to hit and specifically concentrate on those. With an electron eater, it starts cutting and just goes. The only thing determining what and how much it cuts (not counting the blade setting) is the alignment that the tables give to the board.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#17

Bingo

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#18

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Sgian Dubh

>Dan, you can pick and choose which parts of a board you hit with a surface planer (aka jointer) too. It's the technique of dropping on and lifting off the board. This can be done at the beginning of the cut, the middle of the cut, or the end of the plank, or even at two or three drop-on and lift-off points if required.

There's nothing at all says you have to start the cut at one end and keep ploughing on until you get to the other. I admit that I can't ever recall seeing this technique described in books and articles, but it's commonly used, or it certainly is in all the workshops I've been involved in.

Surface planer bed length is not a significant factor in straightening boards, on either their face or edge, with the rider that there are aids about that help the process when dealing with very long boards-- we're back to that mechanical advantage, moments about a point thing I mentioned in my first point. Slainte.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#19

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Dan Donaldson

>Thanks. I have done that myself. I was mainly talking about why you can get by with a handplane that is much shorter than a jointer table and still get a board flat, not necessarily about any advantages/disadvantages for either one. I probably didn't say it too well ;-)

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#20

Re: Richard, at my age mechanical

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>advantage is a really good thing :~). The real advantages to me with the long bed are, first is the mechanical advantage you refer too and second, it makes it much easier to locate the "high spots", and orientate the board so you can feed it through the planer and remove them. After you have flattened the crown of a bow, the long bed allows you to seat on that flat spot and continue to flatten the board. I often "surface plane" long boards just until I have enough flat area to allow my thickness planer to finish the other side. then I flip the board over and finish on the surface planer. Seems to work well for me.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#21

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>you can pick and choose which parts of a board you hit with a surface planer (aka jointer) too. It's the technique of dropping on and lifting off the board. This can be done at the beginning of the cut, the middle of the cut, or the end of the plank, or even at two or three drop-on and lift-off points if required.

There's nothing at all says you have to start the cut at one end and keep ploughing on until you get to the other. I admit that I can't ever recall seeing this technique described in books and articles

With a heavy board it's not easy to control it for doing selective removal. And I see this technique as being dangerous (especially with small boards), same as lowering a board over a tablesaw blade for non through cuts. Do it if you want, I won't.

Maybe the fact that you've never seen the technique described is because those who use it don't have fingers to type with anymore :-)

DC

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#22

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Sgian Dubh

>Denis, your points are well made, particularly regarding heavy boards, but I do it,............ and I still seem to have enough fingers with which to type this reply, ha, ha.

Perhaps I've just been doing such tricks for far too long and it's just a way of working. Slainte.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#23

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Sgian Dubh

>I did miss it Dan. Sorry that I misunderstood what you said. Slainte.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#24

Well...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Your Rockwell seems to be a good machine...

That GI model I have was rated best in class in some magazine when it came out about 10 years ago. Over time tables have sagged (requiring shims), the infeed table has twisted, and the machine in general doesn't seem to keep its adjustments, forcing me to check it before working. I've had tapered, concave and convex pieces from running that machine... Simply put, it can't be trusted. Maybe I have a lemon...

My opinion here is that a good part of the problem with jointers is the dovetailed ways concept. Unless very heavily built, this type of table attachment is prone to run out of spec. We're asking 6" or so ways to support a 30-40+ lb. board at the end of the table, 24"+ from the support. Lots of forces at work here...

If I ever buy another tailed jointer, it will have a parallelogram table support (much less stress in that design), or something like the General 780 system (inclined planes).

DC

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#25

I agree, I would feel as you do if my jointer had

Don henthorn

>been like that. Ever since Taiwan started exporting cheap tools years ago a guy has had to be careful what he bought. You can't tell by price anymore although many feel you can. You just have to go by track record and that means buying older machines for me.