Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes
wilbur
>I probably should have picked a better title. I wasn't looking to start a powered jointers are better/worse than jointing with a hand plane discussion, but I was interested in seeing why jointer bed length is a recurring theme in powered jointer reviews, when one can, with some effort, get excellent results using a hand plane that is much shorter than the bed of a powered jointer. A typical statement in a jointer review goes along the lines of, "The Woodplaner J-600 had jointer tables that were 7 cubits long, making it the longest in its class," which usually results in a higher rating ("9.5 out of 10 -- Grand Poobah's choice!").
Like Ellis, I've got a 10" combination jointer/planer machine, although it's a Rikon, not an Inca. I've had good luck jointing boards as long as 6 feet on it, even though the jointer bed is only 40" long.
I've seen articles on building outfeed and extension tables for every machine EXCEPT a jointer, which seems odd to me.
I guess my takeaway message from the experiences posted here is that jointer bed length is somewhat of an oversold feature. If jointer bed length was really that critical, hand planes would do a crappy job of flattening a board. Granted, longer is better, but it doesn't seem that it should be a critical factor in determining what jointer to buy.
Jointer width, on the other hand, is a much more critical feature. I've been very glad I've got 10" of width capacity on my jointer, but so far I haven't found that length capacity has been a limiting factor.
In other words, my bet is that for most people a wider jointer with shorter beds would be more useful than a narrower jointer with longer beds.
Besides, outside of floor to ceiling cabinets and, as Bill mentioned, railings, I can't think of many projects that would require very long boards. And if I ever hit that limit, I'll take Ellis' advice and build an outfeed table.
P.S. I agree that a hand plane often will get me a finer surface than my powered jointer will, although this may just be a reflection of my crappy technique on my powered jointer.