Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT - interesting eBay feedback

Posts

OT - interesting eBay feedback

#1

OT - interesting eBay feedback

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>We've discussed and debated the value of eBay feedback ratings in the past here, since many of us us ebay from time to time.

One of the things that I've criticized is that the feedback system is a little worse that "I'll scratch your back if you scratch mine", it's more like "I'll punch you back harder if you punch me".

Bottom line is that I've felt the eBay feedback system is inaccurately and overly positive, because people are too afraid to post negative feedback. Post one negative feedback to a seller who's had 1000 transactions and it's a small dent, but that seller can turn around and post negative feedback to you and ruin you small 10 transaction feedback score.

I've recently read that eBay is implmenting a new anonymous feature to the feedback system, where you can rank the seller in areas of item description accuracy and shipping timelyness and things like that. And it's supposed to be anonymous and setup in a way that protects you if you're leaving less that postive feedback.

I'm intersted in seeing how this works.

Just thought I'd let you know.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

#2

Mark, I agree...

dwr

>... with your assessment. I have over 100 transactions, buying and selling. I made the mistake of buying some electronic items from a seller listed as "EBay's #4 Seller"(since gone to #3... maybe even #2)

I got the "New" items and they were DOA. The seller would not do anything, so I left negative feedback. They immediately blasted me with a negative even though they got all the money!!!

So, my 100% was destroyed with the only negative I ever received... right there for the whole world to see... while the negative I left ended up 22 pages deep within less than 12 hours of leaving it... They have nearly 30,000 negative feedbacks... but EBay is only interested in the fees they generate and not the buyers they cheat.

So, I only leave feedback for sellers that do a good job and don't do anything for the others... and I could care less about sellers leaving any feedback anymore... I just want what I bought and get on with life...

I have used the new system one time, but unless EBay is willing to police their 900 Pound Gorilla Sellers, it is just one more step to no where...

EBayer after the honeymoon...;)

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

#3

I like to use subtle negative feedback

Chad Pearson

>Not wanting to get slammed myself, I once left a subtle clue that hopefully can tip off a future buyer. The seller gets a "positive" but if you read the description it sounds a bit fishy. I have only used this on an item that was very slow in coming. The verbiage was:

"As described when it came."

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

#4

Re: I like to use subtle negative feedback

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>"As described when it came."

I don't think that was as good of a subtle clue as you may think it was Chad. I think next time you should say ; As described when it finally came" Good idea on giving a Positive with fishy verbage tho.

I got my 100% destroyed by a seller whom after the auction was over was to notify me of the S&H, but after 11 days of not hearing from him I left him a Negative and PRESTO!!! the very next day I got one in return. I thought that was very unfair and there was nothing I could do about it. to bad too because I really wanted that item, it was a handcrank grinder with a vertical and horizonal wheel, Niagria(sp) #12. Never seen one before, nor since. :~(

T.O.

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

#5

Re: Mark, I agree...

Ernie Miller

>I think I am close to 800 or so all positive and one mutualy removed. I allways try and make my customers happy even if it means taking a loss on an item. I agree the system is flawed. I have all but quit listing items a couple months ago they raised here rates and now the post office is raising theres I'm sure pay will soon fallow. They no longer want us small sellers if you are not moving 1000's of items a week they just don't care about you.

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

#6

Re: I like to use subtle negative feedback

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>Sounds like they wanted more money for it.

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

#7

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

David Hay @ Denver

>I'll be interested to see how their new system works. I've always thought that the feedback system should have an escrow-like system...where each person can only see the feedback of the other once both parties have left feedback. That is, I could see that feedback has been left, but only read it once I had replied with feedback of my own.

David

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

#8

eBay feedback

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I've done a few ebay transactions and all but one have been very good. I left negative feedback after getting the run around for over a month on an item that I bought that the seller never had in his possession and apparently had trouble obtaining for the advertised price after the sale. The seller responded with very negative feedback on me calling me names (even mis-spelled some of them). They started arbitration which at best is a waste of time as the feedback really doesn' go away and nothing is resolved. I dropped out when I realized that it wasn't going to solve anything.

I don't fear the negative feedback, because when I buy something, the seller has no choice on who can place a bid on an item and who ends up being the winning bid. A buyer with ooor feedback can still bid on anything they want, wehn they want. Only after the sale does the seller have any control at all about getting his money before shipping the item.

On the other hand, negative feedback on a seller will show up at least for a while and may "cost" the seller a sale or two. If enought people leave bad feedback the seller may lose some business or even get suspended by ebay. I tend to think that doesn't happen often and ebay can't prevent a seller from starting out fresh with a new name and new contact information.

It is sort of like dealing with itrems for sale in the local paper....buyer be ware.

Lee

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

#9

Re: OT - interesting eBay feedback

Frank G

>I bought an item, paid for the item, recieved the item amd seller posted feed back that I didn't pay or respond to e-mails. I questioned the seller about this and never had a response. Seller has the last word. It should be the opposite.