Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Posts

OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#1

OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

I'm currently researching solar powered water pumps to use for watering our garden. We don't have a lot of head, maybe 20' and we need to go about 50' from the water source, in this case a deep hole in our creek. I also don't need much flow or pressure, just enough to keep a 250 gal tank topped up.

I've found several pumps that are overkill for our situation and a number of pond pumps that don't have enough lift at their rated flow. Is there a direct correlation between an increase in lift and a decrease in flow, or is it dependent upon the type of pump?

I also saw one reference to a floating centrifigul type pump, but I haven't found one for sale yet.

Any inputs on this issue would be appreciated,

Gary

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#2

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water? *LINK*

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Pumps push water better than they pull it so maybe give thought to a small submersible. I'd imagine a small water feature pump from a landscaping supply place (designed for a small waterfall) would work.

And yes - there will be a direct correlation between how far a given pump has to pump water up and it's resultant flow rate..

This is just an example and is probably overkill, but if you look at the spec sheet it will give you 2000 GPH (33 gpm or 1/2 gallon/second) @ 20' head for $250. You could tie this in with a float (level) switch in the tank to assure it didn't short cycle.

Rob


water feature pump

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#3

I've been pumping for several weeks

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I may be fighting the same drought as you are. It is not clear from your request whether you are looking for the most practical solution to keeping a garden alive or there is some other agenda complicating the decision. I don't see many farmers using solar power to do anything except power remote fence charges. It takes serious HP to move water under pressure.

Presuming you are looking for the practical solution begin with the requirements for water, something like 2 inches a week in hot weather. You may be astounded at how much water that is over an acre, about 50,000 gallons. You want the pump at the water source. HP goes up as some power function of delivery pressure, so a water spreading technique that operates at low pressure is better than one that requires high pressure. So for example I simply flood pasture where I can and sprinkle that which is too uneven to flood. The very cheap gas powered pumps available at the Farm Coop don't hold up to steady use. The small electric pumps with hose fittings are fine for a very small area. Other wise you are looking at a $500 gas pump.

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#4

Re: Water Ram *LINK*

Grant Smith

>Gary,

I saw an impressive demonstration of water ram tehnology one time at a home show. Basically the pump is placed in a creek that has some fall so water runs through the pump (which is essentially a diaphragm or two--pretty simple). You place the intake upstream and create a small dam so there is some fall to the water (maybe as little as a foot or two). Then the pump uses the kinetic energy of the water flowing through the pipe to push a smaller quantity of water up as high as twenty or so feet.

simple, elegant, and tried and true... here's a link to get you started, feel free to google up more info or other sources.


water rams

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#5

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Rob,

From the little useful info I've garnered over the last 2 or 3 days on the Web, it seems that the best set-up for our situation would be a submersible pump that floats in the creek pumping to a tank on a little rise above the garden. I need to measure the actual rise, but I'll bet it is substantially less than 20'. After I posted this, I found a website that has exactly that kind of package. It is a 12V pump, operating off a 75W PV panel. Unfortuantely, there was no pricing on their webpage, so no telling how expensive it is.

I appreciate the link, but I don't have 115V anywhere near the garden.

Gary

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#6

Re: I've been pumping for several weeks

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Bill,

I am thinking I can put together the solar system for less than the price of a good gas pump. I don't have to lift the water very far, and I don't need a lot of flow, so I can get by with a 12V or 24VDC pump, keeping a good sized tank full. I just haven't found the pump I'm looking for yet. Either they are way oversized for my project, or they aren't rated at all at the head that I am estimating.

It just occurred to me as I was typing this that I need to find my link for that surplus company whose name is escaping me. Surplus Supply?

Thanks for the suggestion, though, and I really appreciate the numbers on the amount of water needed. I may have to revise my plan somewhat. So far, I'm just trying to minimize the costs of the system, both initial and continuing. Plus, if I don't have to buy gas, I'd just as soon not. 8^]

Thanks again,

Gary

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#7

Re: Water Ram

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Grant,

I've taken a pretty close look at water rams. I even have plans to build one from common plumbing supplies. 2 issues seem to rule out a ram for this installation.

The first is the supply piping. I haven't checked on the cost of pipe yet, but the last time I bought black plastic pipe, it wasn't terribly inexpensive, though it does rate as a less expensive investment. Unfortunately, the creek from the house down past the garden doesn't have a tremendous amount of drop, so it could take a lot of pipe to get enough head to operate a ram. Plus, it is the most maintenance intensive type of piping you can use. We used to have a gravity-fed water supply that was a true pain in the neck. Consequently, I want to use as little pipe as possible.

Secondly is the noise issue. My understanding is that a decent sized ram pump makes considerable noise. I've seen this mentioned in more than one source. I've pretty much decided on a solar powered pump. I'm just trying to figure out exactly what I need for the most reasonable price.

Thanks for your input, though. When I refigure my system using Bill's numbers, I may find that I need more pump than I thought. Could change the whole picture.

Gary

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#8

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Is there any way you can run a pipe up the creek far enough to get the intake of the pipe at the same level as the water you want in the tank?

If so, you could run a second hose back out of the tank and back to the creek to keep the water in a constant state of flush.

BTW we did this at our place years ago except I had a valve on the (tank) end of the fill hose so that you could stop the flow if you wanted to. That way the water could be warmed before it went on the garden. If you're using pvc rolled pipe, you can buy inexpensive hand valves form HD that are designed for hot tubs etc.

Or - a water wheel maybe?

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#9

Re: I've been pumping for several weeks  *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>


surplus

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#10

Here's a *LINK*

JohnM in Mid Michigan

>I found this place when I was looking for something similar. Check out the Congo Inline Pump for $120. (Click on Submersible Pumps.) Draws 6 amps. How much photovoltaic panel are you planning? Got a good source? I haven't pulled the trigger on a setup yet, so am VERY interested in this thread.

John


Solar Pumping Stuff

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#11

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Ernie Miller

>I by no way want you problem but here we have to much rain it seems like an inch a day for weeks! even the tomatos on the hill are getting root rot from to much watter. The damn stuff comes down it torrants. it will be cloudy all day and then a cloud will drop it all in an hour or less. Have you checked Tractor supply? or an automative supply house?

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#12

Re: Think about a windmill and pump.

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#13

Re: Think about a windmill and pump.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Al,

Thanks for the suggestion, but we live in the bottom of a hollow. We don't get much wind. I do own the top of a ridge, but I've never investigated the cost of putting in a wind generator. Might be worth looking at.

I appreciate The input,

Gary

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#14

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>You and me both, Ernie.

There is certainly a thing called too much rain. We have a pond that almost overran its banks back several years ago. I wouldn't want to see that again.

Send some of your rain our way and then we'll both be happy.

Gary

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#15

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Curly Smith

>What you need, as you indicated, is a low volume, moderate head pump that runs on either 12 or 24v DC. A bilge pump from Walmart might work, they're less than $20 but might not have enough head (the one I have says 500 gph @ 0 ft, 350 gph at 3.3 ft --> if you're interested I can hook it up to a hose and see if it will generate enough lift). This pump, though, from Harbor Freight should provide enough lift 12V MARINE UTILITY PUMP

Solar panel costs have skyrocketed in the past couple of years. They used to run around $1.5/watt (used) and $3/watt (new). Typical costs are now: solar from Northern Tool + Equipment

A quick project cost check. Let's assume the Harbor Freight pump will work, it draws 65w and costs $40. To run the pump you'd need an 80w panel (get one here: Earth Solar Group ) for $450, then you'd need a battery (too much output from the panel on a bright sunny day will fry your pump) that you should be able to get for ~$30 from Batteries Plus (it's just a replacement cell for a UPS), you'd need a charger $50-$100, plus some other miscellaneous expenses for a total cost of around $650.

The above cost check assumes that you'd be running the pump off of the solar panels. It's not really any cheaper to run off batteries as you'd need a large battery bank to run a 65w device for any length of time. In addition, you'd still need to charge the batteries.

If you don't want to spend that much money, and I wouldn't, then you need to find a pump that requires less power. Maybe something like this:

12 VOLT ELECTRIC DIAPHRAGM PUMP WITH DEMAND SWITCH that's $44 for a 1 gpm 20-35 psi pump. However, the specs don't list the power requirement. You might check windshield washer pumps (I think they're around $60) or maybe fuel pumps (but fuel pumps typically don't like water). FWIW, the Walmart bilge pump I mentioned earlier is 12v @ 1.4 amps so a 25w panel would work (if the pump generates enough head).

One manual alternative that you might consider is:

Multipurpose Drill-Powered Pump � 650 GPH . If you don't want to use the drill then you could hook up a hand crank or bicycle with the coupling they also sell.

Another alternative, and the one I'd go with if at all possible, is running direct burial sprinkler system wire (or low-voltage lighting wire) from a 12v transformer at the house to the pond. Solar power is simply not cost effective when you're close to the grid.

One more thing, you might try reposting your question on the the Otherpower.com Discussion Board and reviewing the info on OTHERPOWER.COM . They're an alternative power site/board with a bunch of interesting info.

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#16

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks Curly,

I got the Otherpower info from another friend but I haven't had a chance to check it out yet.

The problem with supplying a pump in the creek with something other than solar is the fact that the garden is more than 500' from the house. That's a lot of wire to buy and bury. I was also amazed at the cost of PV panels. I thought I had remembered them being cheaper in the past.

I'm thinking now that I may just go with a graviy fed system. I still have a bunch of pieces of 1 1/4" black plastic laying around. If I don't have enough to do the whole job, I'll just reduce it down to a smaller size and buy enough to get to the garden.

Thanks for your suggestions. It would still be interesting to know what the flow is with 20' of head from your walmart pump if you are up for the experiment. We're wanting to do a little water feature about 1000' from the house, so solar may still be in the picture.

I'll still be checking out Otherpower.com. We're trying to get as far off the grid as we can.

Gary

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#17

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

Curly Smith

>According to this chart my pump, the V500 model, will only generate 9' of head. I should have looked up the info yesterday.

Attwood bilge pumps

Of course nothing says you couldn't use two pumps. The first pumps from the creek to an intermediate tank, the second from the intermediate to the final tank. Regardless of the specs, I'll hook up the pump this weekend generate a pump curve.

500' is a fair distance but 18 gauge wire is OK for up to 750'. You can get a 500' roll of 18-3 sprinkler wire for $75 (for example: Low Voltage Multi Strand Lawn Sprinkler and Irrigation Wire Over 750' you'd need to go with 16 gauge. Ideally, you'd want a roll of 18-2 or 16-2 since you don't need to spend money wires that you won't use. Two 500' spools of 16-1 would run about $80 ( 16 Gauge Direct Burial Wire ) but a single spool of 16-2 would be easier to deal with. Of course wire isn't something you'd probably want to order over the internet due to the likely high shipping costs.

Here are a couple of other possible pumps:

Pumptec M9 12 Volt Pump

12V Battery Operated Submersible or Inline Pump UP-1500-DC

Re: OT--Anyone know about pumping water?

#18

Bilge pump test results

Curly Smith

>I connected the bilge pump to a 12v power supply (Note: the power supply output was 11.4 VDC, the pump specs are for 13.6 VDC), added a 5' section of 5/8" ID hose and submerged the pump in about 16" of water. I measured a flow rate of 5 GPM (300 GPH) with 0' of elevation change.

I then added 50' of 5/8" hose and repeated the test. The flow rate decreased to 3 GPM (180 GPH). At an elevation of +/-4' above the surface of the water the flow ceased.

Friction loss at 3 GPM in 5/8" hose is about 2 psi which is roughly equal to 5 ft of water. The manufacturer says the pump is rated for 9' of lift and I had zero flow at 4' elevation + 5' friction = 9'. My results matched the pump lift capacity specification.

You'd obviously want to use bigger piping and probably a pump with a bit more head.