Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Posts

OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#1

OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Bill Howatt

>Hi,

Seems to be the time for OT A/C questions! My brother-in-law had a central A/C installed recently. The unit looks like it is a reasonable size for his 50-60 yr-old house. The problem is that in order to get any cooling in the bedrooms upstairs, the main floor has to be very cool and even then the upstairs results are not the greatest. The stairway is open but it is not a large opening, more like a typical hall/doorway.

Is there a typical fix for situations like this? I have seen register vents with fans in them and I think even fans in sections of heating ducts. Is this the way to go?

Any help is much appreciated.

Thanks,

Bill

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#2

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Heat rises so if there are no vents on the upper floor it will be difficult to cool it. Preferably the vents should be in the ceiling or at least high on the wall.

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#3

Thoughts

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The system needs return air ducting from the second floor and balanced forced air to push more conditioned air to the second floor. Try closing all the duct dampers to the first floor and opening all the duct dampers to the second floor to see if routing all the air to the second floor works. If it does, but gets too cool up there, selectively open the first floor dampers to balance things. If it doesn't work, sue the HVAC outfit and/or move.

Clint

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#4

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Barry Irby

>If the house has a separate trunk duct for the first and second floor, you may have dampers in the ducts that would allow for "zoning" or balancing the system. Are the ducts used for both heating and AC? If so, you need to put the heat in "low", mostly on the first floor and the AC in "high", mostly on the second floor. There should be returns on both levels. If you have the dampers in the trunk ducts, you would open the one for the second floor and close off the one for the first floor about 50% or AC. For heat, you would reverse that and open the one for the first floor and close the second floor one about 50%. If there are no large system dampers, you can do the same thing with the dampers in the registers. Choke down the lower ones for AC and open the ones upstairs. You probably don't want to close off either floor completely. If you must, you could close a few of them but it�s not smart to reduce the airflow too much. If this does not work, discuss the situation with the installer. The system should be designed and installed to allow for balancing in either season. Once you figure out the seasonal setting, it only takes about five minutes to switch them. (If you have internal duct dampers, they are flaps of metal lined up and parallel to the handle. If the handle is perpendicular to the duct, it is �closed�. They should be near where the ducts branch)

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#5

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Good suggestion here, I'll add a couple...

When we had our AC replaced last year, I made the same comment to the sales rep, namely that it was hard to get the top floor cool without freezing on the main floor with the old furnace/AC. He made the suggestion that the air returns on the top level be moved from the bottom to the top of the floor, what this does is catch the warm air at the ceiling and runs it back to the system.

Another item that seemed to help was to install roof vents. The house came with none, and when we had the shingles redone last year we had three installed on the roof. Since you're more likely to run the AC on hot sunny days, the sun beating on the shingles turns the roof into a furnace, and despite the insulation in the attic some of that heat radiates back in the top level rooms.

Finally, some kind of fan in the staircase to help the air migrate between the two levels will help too.

[rant]

But in the end, none of that fiddling would be needed if the HVAC manufacturers and installers gave a hoot about making and installing a practical and efficient system. It would cost a couple hundred dollars at most to install thermostats in each room, with automatic dampers to regulate the air flow. No adjustment needed between winter and summer. Differential temperatures for each room if desired.

But no, we're kept in the stone age...

[/rant]

DC

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#6

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

robert davis

>THERE ARE AUTOMATIC DAMPERS AVAILABLE. A FRIEND JUST HAD A NEW A/C SYSTEM WITH ATHERMOSTAT ON EACH LEVEL..A GREAT IMPROVEMENT FOR COMFORT UP AND DOWN.

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#7

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Great, where does one get these? I'm interested...

DC

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#8

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Denis - systems such as that which you describe are available. We put them in commercial buildings every day. But most residential installers won't bother as it's harder for them to make $$ on systems like that. There's also a lack of quality residential equipment to support those systems (dampers, actuators etc.). That's the bad news. The good news is that most commercial gear is extremely well priced now (it's come down over the last few years) and available through multiple sources. Interestingly enough, one of the better companies making really good "controlling" thermostats is out of Quebec - they're stuff is top notch and extremely well priced.

If you're considering a (zoning) system such as this you'll also need an air handler to support it. You'll need variable air flow and this usually means a variable speed fan that controls to the amount of air required by the various zones. Even this isn't that expensive anymore as VFD's have come WAY down in price too.

If anyone's considering such a system I can't encourage you enough to get a mechanical engineer involved. I know some residential HVAC guys have the "you don't need one of those guys, I can do it" attitude and maybe they can, but commercial systems deal with zoning every single day - it's the way things work so an engineer versed in those systems can pump out a residential design pretty quickly.

Rob

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#9

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Well, I do have a variable speed blower in my furnace (new Trane installed last year), so this looks promising...

Any ballpark prices for the dampers and thermostats? Just trying to get an idea here...

Thanks!

DC

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#10

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Thermostats will probably run anywhere from $100 - $250 per zone and the actuators for the dampers will be in the $50 - $100 each range. Dampers themselves are generally pretty inexpensive but obviously will need associated ductwork supplied and installed.

The system you'll be gearing up for will be pressure dependent so the variable speed fan on the air handler will throttle up and down based on the air pressure in the duct. You'll also need to make sure that the fan can "listen" to a device that measures this pressure (or you;ll need a bypass damper installed) AND that the air handler you have can take instructions from a thermostat not made by Trane.

Be warned - Trane is known for having proprietary equipment and for getting nasty with warranties etc. when you want to introduce products by other manufacturers, OR for charging the living crap out of you if you want something "special".

Rob

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#11

More info for Bill and Denis....

Barry Irby

>Pardon me while I rattle on.

The idea of improving the attic ventilation and also the ceiling insulation is a good one. (Thinking just outside the box as it were)

Bill, If you have not improved the ceiling insulation in your 50 plus year old house, you should investigate it. You might have little or no insulation. Increasing it to today�s local standard or above for your area will dramatically "cool" the second floor in summer and save you money in winter also. Increasing to R-30 or R-38 might have the effect of nearly doubling the "size" of your AC. There may be other energy improvements you can make also.

Denis, Approach the automatic zoning thing carefully. As a Home Inspector I have seen four systems with zoning. It's rare here in the backward conservative South. It does not work the way I would have thought. (At least with a Heat Pump.) The airflow is critical with a heat pump and often difficult to control. The system I'm thinking of reverts to all the dampers being open when the system is off. So, when a zone "calls", instead of those dampers opening, all the others close. There are sensors built in that do not allow the system to run too long with restricted air flow and it may open the other dampers and "dump" the heat out of the system occasionally.

So it might be a good idea to get someone (Engineer) who truly understands the system to design and oversee the installation. Of the four I have seen, three were screwed up to the point they operated poorly and the other one was not actually hooked up and did nothing, but no one had told the owner. In each case it took the installers about four or five tries to get them working well.

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#12

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house *LINK*

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Denis - there may be a way....Here's the t-stat I mentioned: (linked below)

These have the capability to be networked. You probably don't need this. If you scroll down to the top of page 6 in the spec sheet, I believe this is what you'd need (pressure dependent VAV with auto-changeover. The first two diagrams on this page are similar, but they use different actuators - I prefer the analog actuator (over the floating actuator), but they're a bit more money.

Note that for this concept to work properly, each zone needs to know the temperature of the air that's being delivered to the zone. This is accomplished using a temperature sensor mounted in the duct. These stats are also capable of calling for heating or cooling, but this is where you could run into trouble with Trane as they have their own proprietary communications.

However - have a look at your existing system and see if it has the capability of adding a second thermostat (or remote temperature sensor). If so, you can mount the extra one upstairs (assuming your current one is down) and your existing Trane t-stat probably has the capability of averaging these temperatures and acting according to the average.

If so, the air handler will continue to operate the way it is now (it will make it's own heating/cooling decision), but the zoning t-stats will be able to make their own open/close decisions based on the temperature air they have being delivered. If hot air is in the duct and a zone wants cold, it will shut down and visa versa.

What this doesn't address is the duct pressure and I'm not sure of your existing system has the ability to throttle the supply fan speed based on this pressure. As the various zones close, the requirement for air diminishes and the duct pressure will rise. The air handler needs to respond to this by slowing the fan down. This same sequence needs to reverse if the zones start to call for more air.

If our current system can do this, great - if not, it's not the end of the world. In this case a piece of ductwork is run between the supply duct from the air handler to the return duct. In commercial systems we'd employ an actual pressure sensor and an actuated damper to control the air going through the bypass duct, but in thinking about it, you don't need that. You could employ a basic gravity-style damper that uses an adjustable counter weight. When the pressure increases, the damper opens. When it decreases, the damper closes.

Hope you have a big mechanical room!

Rob


zoning thermostat

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#13

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Well, I liked your previous response better :-)

With up to 10 zones, price goes up fast, and then there's the "Trane issue"...

I guess I'll put this idea on the backburner for the moment...

Thanks for all the info,

DC

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#14

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Dennis - I'd question the need for ten zones - that's a lot!

Typically you can collect zones that have similar heat loading. For example - if you have two ancillary bedrooms on a south facing wall, these can be treated as one zone. You'll want a separate zone for the master bedroom and maybe a t-stat in the hallway to do the rest of the space (including any bathrooms etc.). Or, if you have a separate heat source for the bathroom, you won't need a zone for the common areas - these can be a branch off one of the other zones and it gets whatever air is delivered to it. That takes it to two zones upstairs.

In the main part of the house you can collect zones in a similar fashion. If you have a dedicated living room, this can (and should) be it's own zone but if you have a family/room/great room concept, this can be one zone. And as with the upper floor, the common areas can be collected into a common zone - or not.

OR - you don't even need that many. Theoretically you can run a zone for upstairs and another for down - but this makes the concept of zoning a bit redundant.

One thing I never mentioned with that t-stat I aimed you at is that it has the ability of controlling it's own reheat. This can be used to activate electric heat (radiant underfloor??) on a time basis in conjunction with the rest of the system. They also have the ability of using remote sensors to do room averaging etc.

If you want zoning, it's going to cost money. But if it's thought through, it doesn't have to be a lot of money. And if you're going to do this, get the right people and do it right. As I indicated before - most (most, not all) residential installers won't do a good job of this.

Rob

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#15

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Cool Rob, want to visit sunny Hottawa?

I sure could use some help, this is getting way out of my league... :-)

DC

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#16

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I'd call Viconics and ask them who represents their product in your area. Then call those folks and see what they have to say. Chances are you'll get a commercial contractor and most commercial guys don't want to do residential work BUT - if you can wait for the slow season, you may get lucky.

Obviously my "design" is based on the picture of your house that I have in my head. And never having seen your house - your house looks strangely similar to mine :). So don't take my "design" as gospel, but take it as concept and start reading up based on it. It will help immensely when HVAC guys start to hand you proposals.

And no - I'm not coming to Ottawa - but thanks anyways! :)

Rob

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#17

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Ted Wong

>Had the same problem when e moved unto our house. The A/C was installed well after the original house as built. The installation was a real hack job. They installed one

12" x 24" return on the main level and no returns anywhere on the second level. With unlined fiberglass flex duct supplies. Long story short, we installed cold air returns in every room and got rid of the unlined flex duct and replaced it with flex duct w/ liner and made the runs as straight as possible those things just about solved everything.

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

#18

Re: OT: A/C in 2-storey house

Myra in TN

>If there is any sun getting to the top floor windows in your brother-in-law's house, he should seriously consider installing sun-retardant window film on those windows. We had a house of that same vintage once and the temperature upstairs dropped 10 degrees when I installed the window film on the south and west windows.

Read the instructions carefully because some of the films are not suitable for double pane windows. If the windows are old, single pane, and have separate storm windows, install the film on the storm sash.

Of course, this doesn't fix the issues of having only one return vent (which is all we had in that house of ours) but every coping mechanism helps.