Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

OT- MP3 Recommendations?

Posts

OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#1

OT- MP3 Recommendations?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi All,

Okay, An OT post.

Many of you have seen those MP3 players that people wear, well I think I�d like to get one. Looks like I�ll be having a LOT of quiet time soon, I have my total hip resurfacing operation scheduled now for June 6. So, I will be shopping for one this weekend and was wondering what I should look for feature wise, spec wise etc.

I want something that is easy enough for a cave man to operate, I want to be able to down load music and also have an FM tuner (CBC Junkie at large here).

All recommendations and feedback is appreciated.

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#2

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

Chuck W

>A while back I bought a Sandisk 1gig model with fm tuner and voice recording. Sound quality is average and it only takes 1 AAA battery.

I have heard the IRiver models are very good with excellent sound quality. If I was shopping again I would go for an IRiver. However Samsung have good sound and are cheaper.

What I like about the Sandisk is no special interface is needed to transfer music to it. Its a drag and drop interface.

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#3

Sandisk here too.

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Jim, I have a Sandisk too...not sure which model? I didn't break the bank I know that. It's super easy to use and the battery lasts for weeks it seems. If it's easy enough for this cave woman to use....I'm sure you'd have no problem :)

You know we're all going to be thinking good thoughts and sending healthy vibes your way. You'll be up and kicking in no time. I'm certain of it!

Jen

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#4

3 basic types

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Jim, there are three basic types today.

Smallest - single or double line LCD display, between 512MB and 1GB. Limited features, interface a little difficult because you only can see one or two lines, like a car stereo, so you have to use the buttons to manoeuver through songs to get what you want. Plays music and other audio files. Cost 'round here $25-$70

Medium - full screen color display, with a computer-like interface that lets you use a mouselike button to manouver through pull down menus. Much easier to operate. A little bigger (because of the display). Plays music and let's you see photos. About 1GB to 2Gb, about $60-$90.

Large - full screen color display. Same type of full screen menu interface. Plays music, let's you see photos and watch videos. Some are the RAM-based memory 1GB to 4GB and some of the larger ones use a small hard drive (like a laptop) with capacities between 10GB and 80GB. Costs between $150-$350.

The Apple iPod started it all. But even apple has several different ones, iShuffle, iTHis and iThat filling in the previously mentioned 3 categories.

We bought my son a Creative Zen 1GB model for $50 - fits into the medium category, plays music, shows photos doesn't play videos. 2 months later we're looking for another for my daughter and for the same price they have the 2GB model. Wanted to get something smaller for her and for my youngest daughter, and started lookign at the small ones (limited display) but the ones with the full screen are so much easier to use and undesrtand because you can see the menus as your go through them.

Good luck with your surgery!

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#5

Re: 3 basic types

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Mark, my son has a Creative Zen too. He loves it. He can put photos on it as well. Cost a lot more than mine and is much bulkier... not good for working out. I think the other thing to think about too is whether its got a disc drive or a chip. (I think that's right) The disc ones tend to be much more apt to get damaged if dropped. Some have expansion slots so you can use a memory card to create more memory.

Jen

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#6

Re: 3 basic types

Mark Nowicki

>Whatever type you get, I would suggest you upgrade the headphones. The standard seems to be the type that you drill into your ear canal.

I got four MP3 players from TigerDirect.ca. Fast shipping and good selection, iffy after sale service. My wife wanted them to replace, under warranty headphones that, I am sure, my daughter broke. They ignored her request.

Be nice to the nurses, you will need them more than the doctor.

Good luck

Mark Nowicki

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#7

Rats, wrong placement again..

Mark Nowicki

>

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#8

I have a Sansa m250 *LINK*

Hoa Dinh in Alameda

>In fact, I bought 3 of them from Buy.com. I gave one to a friend. My SWMBO uses one during work-out, gardening, cleaning up, .... I use one during mowing, cleaning up, and in the shop (with a pair of computer speakers).

It has 2 GB, sufficient for my modest music need. It's small and durable. I've dropped multiple times and it keeps going. And if I lose it, I'm out $60, not a big deal.

I bought 4 AAA rechargeable battery and a "smart" charger (the one with timer that turns the charger off after 3 hr). A cell lasts me anywhere from 3 days to a week.

-- Hoa


img

Sansa m250 Digital Audio Player 2GB

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#9

RAM = chips

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Yes, the RAM-based (solid state chips) MP3 players are much smaller, aren't as fragile and come in sizes up to about 2GB (or even 4GB these days).

The iPod and the others that start at about 20GB up to about 80 (now higher even) have tiny little disk drives (like a laptop) so they are large can hold much, much more (important for video) but since they have mechanical moving parts they are more susecptible to damage.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#10

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

Hamish

>Jim, you can't beat an ipod. We have a 30Gb photo one that is just great. They are all, ipods I mean, really easy to operate and the larger ones can show photos and movies. The radio comes in the form of an add on remote switch. I would definitely reccomend you check up on these before going else where, you won't regret it.

All the best for a speedy recovery.

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#11

Funny story about kids and MP3 players

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>9 year old boy: Dad, look at that MP3 player. I think I want that one.

Father: Yes, that's nice, isn't it?

9 year old boy: It says it's 1GB.

Father: Yes, that's right.

9 year old boy: So is that double the size of a 512MB one.

Father: Yes.

9 year old boy: And it's 4 times as big as a 256MB one right?

Father: Exactly.

9 year old boy: So this 1GB on can hold 4 times as many songs as that tiny 256MB one. And twice as many songs as that 512MB one.

Father: Yes, that's right.

9 year old boy: Oh, look that 256MG is on sale for $29.

Father: So it is.

9 year old boy: And that 512MB one is $39.

Father: Yes.

9 year old boy: But I like the 1GB, even though it's $69.

Father: It is nice looking, isn't it?

9 year old boy: I have enough money saved up for that one. How much is tax on $69?

Father: Well let's see, 6% on $70 is $4.20 so that makes it......

9 year old boy: How many songs will fit on a 1GB player, Dad?

Father: ... about $73.20.... oh, 1GB? That's about 500 songs, I think.

9 year old boy: 500 songs? That's good. I almost have enough money saved for that one.

Father: Sounds good.....

9 year old boy: WAIT! Look this one is 2GB and it's only $129

Father: But you don't have $129

9 year old boy: But it's 2GB, Dad.

Father: But it's $129.

9 year old boy: But 2GB can hold 1000 songs, right?

Father: Yes, but......

9 year old boy: I need the 2GB one Dad, so I can have 1000 songs.

Father: I think 1GB is large enough.

9 year old boy: I dunno, Dad. That's only 500 songs. The 2GB hold 1000 songs. I think I'll need that 2GB one.

Father: 1000 songs? Why do you need space for 1000 songs?

9 year old boy: 'Cause.... Well, I can save a little more, my birthday is next month and Grampie always sends me $20.

Father: But why do you need space for 1000 songs?

9 year old boy: Cause I like music, and I like songs, and I need space for 1000 songs.

Father: Son, how many songs do you have now?

9 year old boy: Uhhh..... songs?

Father: Yes, songs. How many songs do you have now?

9 year old boy: Uhhhh...... well........ two.

Father: I think the 1GB with space for 500 songs is fine for you. It will take you a while to collect 500 songs. Here, I'll buy another one online here for $0.88 for you, now you have 3 songs.

Happy Woodworking!

Exactly.

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#12

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

JoeW in Detroit, MI

>I have the iPod 20G Video and my daughter has the iPod nano. I like the Apple wheel on the iPods and the iTunes software is pretty good also. Yes, they cost a little more, but I think they are worth it.

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#13

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>Jim, I have the 30GB iPod and love it but know many satisfied Sansdisk users. Hey, best of luck with your surgery and hurry back to the shop and the ice. Take care friend, Fred

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#14

That was cute ;)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I have 16 songs :)

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#15

Re: 3 basic types

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Mark,

You never fail to amaze me! You are better than reading Consumers Reports...you are a treasure, Thank You!

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#16

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations? *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,In Dearborn MI

>Jim

I have a 2GB Muvo2 I bought on Ebay refurbished from the factory,has a rechargable battery and

only weighs about 8 ozs.Attached is a link to their store on Ebay,with careful watching the deals are quite good.I went thru a couple different sytles 20gb(which proved to be too big and bulky) before buying the smaller Muvo.Upgraded to Phillips Noise cancelling ear buds and I love it.

Andy


http://stores.ebay.com/Creative-Labs-Factory-Store_MP3-Players_W0QQcolZ2QQdirZQ2d1QQfsubZ11QQftidZ2QQtZkm

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#17

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

Tom

>My response, maybe a minority here, is to find a cheap one with three features. Find one that has an FM tuner for your requirements, uses a AAA battery and one that uses removable SD cards. You can drag and drop to the flash cards, and use as many cards as you want. Flash cards are cheap. There is a plethora of aftermarket/no-name players like this available for $20 to $30(ebay, or various sites). You can find two 2gb SD cards for $30 shipped. If you drop/lose/kill it, you're not out very much. And you still have your music (assuming it's not lost) on the cards. I have 6 cheap versions here, for me/wife and kids. To me they all sound alike. I like that I can pop whatever card I want with whatever music/fairytale/book on it into whatever player is handy. Yes, you get a nice display with iRiver, Creative or Zen. If all you are going to do is listen to files, I'd go the cheap route. Don't lock yourself into proprietary software, batteries or even non-removable batteries. If you want video, several days worth of music or a fashion symbol, then this is not a good option.

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#18

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

Rusty Miller

>Jim,

I've had a few different iPods since they came out and my favorite is the new 30gig video I have now. I say that because I have really gotten into listening to podcasts (video, audio and audio alone). There are many podcasts available for free on many different subjects (including woodworking).

You can also download audiobooks.

Rusty

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#19

Ordered a Sansa m250

Bartee (metro Atlanta)

>Great price on buy.com

I have been also thinking about this for a long time.

I am in the process of converting about 400+ cds to mp3 on my computer, so I will have plenty of material, that I like....

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#20

Re: Ordered a Sansa m250

Chuck W

>Which program are you using to rip your cd's? I use audiograbber.

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#21

CD's to MP3

Stuart Johnson

>How do you convert CD's to MP3 and then add them to the player? What are the steps?

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#22

Been there!

JRutter

>I had almost the same conversation with my 9 y.o. son, but it was a 20 G iPod to hold his 2 favorite sangs!

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#23

I've had many and the Zune is the best

Chet Kloss from Livonia, MI

>

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#24

Re: CD's to MP3

Chuck W

>Download a program called Audiograbber + download the "LAME" and "BladeEnc" encoders to your computer. Install it Audiograbber then copy the 2 encoders to the same directory audiograbber is installed in. When ripping a CD make sure to select either encoder rather than the default encoder included in Audiograbber. After you have ripped a CD you can "drag and drop" the MP3 files to your player which should be connected by USB at this point. Some players require a proprietary program to do this. Others like sandisk and Samsung do not.

Re: OT- MP3 Recommendations?

#25

Music Match

Bartee (metro Atlanta)

>I have been using Music Match for a while.

I paid the upgrade. Seems really fast.

Works for me...