>I have built two counter tops out of hard Maple. Trying to keep the rustic look I left the knot hole in the boards when I did the glue up I want to keep the holes but fill them with some thing that I can put polyurethane over and still see the hole SWMOB realy likes the look and requested the holed stay and been seen. The hole sizes are 1" and .75" about
I use epoxy and mix in black power, see pic below. I'll take the 5 min Devcon epoxy( $2 at WallyWorld) in the syngines(sp) thingys and mix a pinch of blacken saw-dust, pour into defect and leave slightly proud. Let dry, a few hours, file, sand or scrape level. Works well under all finishes I have thrown at it, oil, varnish and lacquer. My blacken sawdust is: oak, walnut or cherry any hardwood with a high tannin content. Throw some iron filings in with the sawdust, wet and let dry. The iron and tannin in the wood will blacken within an hour or less. Could probably grind up some charcoal(?).
>I am helping my son trim out his house in White oak. We had some beautiful figured boards - one had a fairly large knot right in the center. I didn't have the black Rit dye I would normally use to make the epoxy black so as an experiment, I colored the bottom & sides of the knot hole with India Ink and filled the hole with clear Devcon 10 minute epoxy. When the epoxy had set for about an hour I scraped and sanded it flat. After sanding with 220 grit, we stained the board and wiped the stain (removing all from the epoxy). Then coated the trim with orange shellac. The knot hole looked so neat, my son used it as a top trim board over a wide doorway opening into the kitchen. The epoxy stayed transparent and the hole looks like your looking into a pool of water.