Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

Posts

Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#1

Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>This may be a stupid question, and I think I know the answer, but better to ask here first, right?

I've got a PorterCable 16G finish nailer, 18G brad nailer, and 20G stapler. Very happy with them and will buy another PC, if only to keep things simple.

When the day comes that I get to build my shop, I'll get a Framing nailer and a Roofing nailer. But that day is not here yet.

The day has come to build some fencing first. Regular 8 foot 4x4 PT posts sunk in concrete, 2x4 PC rails and 1x6 slats. Just regular wood fencing.

Last few I built were with deck screws and hammer and nails. Nothing wrong with that but I think I'll be doing more this time round, so I'm seriously thinking about getting a nail gun. $200 for the gun more than offsets the time savings. Time is money, you know.

Then I realized, I'm not sure WHAT gun to get for fencing.

Brad guns, finish nailers, framing nailers, roofing nailers... all are out there for me to buy, but what about fencing nailer? There isn't such a beast.

I know that a 16G or 15G finish nailer isn't strong enough. Right? Okay. And a roofing nailer doesn't make sense. Right?

So is a framing nailer the right gun? Full round head nails, of course.... I don't like the clipped heads. I've only ever seen 3.5" nails for these big guns. Do they make smaller ones. I've never paid attention.

So I'm thinking that a PC FR350A is the the right gun. And I think I should be able to get 2" nails for that gun. I a guess I should I get stainless nails of some sort.

Does any of this make sense? Let me know soon. The summer officially starts this afternoon, and it's the first weekend with NO SOCCER, so I may actually get alot of stuff done. I think I'll head out to the store later today and get a gun, so let me know.

Thanks!

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#2

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

Patrick Schupbach

>A short stainless ringshank in your framer should do the trick. Check Mc Feelys for your nails.

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#3

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

James Fox

>Just finished the fence in back of our house with the PC 350--worked like a charm. Shot larger headed nails for the 2X4 framing and the coated, 6d headed nails for the fence slats w/no problem.

Bought it new on e-bay for $150 + shipping. They go for $200 around here in the big-box stores.

James

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#4

Makita Screwgun

Curly Smith

>I've lusted after one of these, never could justify the $200:

QuikDrive QD2000MSDS Auto-Feed SDS Tool (Makita Screwgun)

Features:

Drive the widest variety of screws available for any auto-feed driving system

Nosepiece for 3" screws installs quickly and easily

Screws load instantly with nothing to adjust

2 interchangeable nosepieces - short nosepiece for driving 1 1/4"

to 2 1/2" screws, and long nosepiece for driving 3" screws

Standard Equipment:

Auto-Feed Screw Driving Unit

2 interchangeable nosepieces

Extension

Screwgun

Tool Bag

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#5

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

Paul Dwight

>I think a stapler works very well for attaching fence slats. Lots of holding power, plus the smaller-gauge "legs" of the staples have less tendency to split the wood when driven near the end of the board.

A stapler wouldn't be much good attaching rails to posts, though. If you're going to rely on fasteners to make that connection, I'd think you would need the framing nailer.

Hey, maybe you need both -- get a medium crown stapler and a framing gun. Yeah, that's the ticket ...

Good luck! -- Paul

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#6

Stainless or galvanized staples?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I was wondering about a stapler, since so much prefab stuff is stapled together these days. I don't LIKE the idea of staples, but the do offer good strenth for a little hole. But one thing is the types of staples. I think I've seen galvanized nails and stainless nails, but are there equivalent staples?

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#7

One more option

Curly Smith

>Sorry, I violated my rule of never posting until I've finished the 2nd pot of coffee...

I've got one of these that I've used to "drive" screws before:

Porter-Cable Palm Nailer

I agree with the other posters that if you use nails then ring shank nails are the way to go. However, I've never had much long-term success with nails in PT wood. Long-term you really need screws. If you don't have miles of fence then a palm nailer will work, if you've got a lot of fence then an autofeeding screwgun is the way to go.

Cost of the Palm Nailer is around $125.

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#8

Galvanize or stainless nails?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Thanks for the info so far.....

I know you can't use plain steel nails (gun or hammer) on a fence due to rust stains dripping down the slats. I think I remeber hearing that even galvanized isn't good enough for cedar fences, and you should use stainless.

But for a run of the mill PT fence, are galvanized nails adequate? Are there different types/qualities of galvanized nails for guns?

Thanks.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#9

Stainless is best, G185 fasteners OK

Curly Smith

>

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#10

there is one for fencing

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>Porter cable makes two that would work for you

http://www.porter-cable.com/index.asp?e=547&p=2618

is the 350 coil nailer, would do the framing and fence boards or

http://www.porter-cable.com/index.asp?e=547&p=2619

the 250 only 6 lb and seems to be for fencing and lighter work

I like the coil nailers, they hold lots more nails 200 to 300 and are available in galvanized box.

The Bostitch is even lighter

http://www.amazon.com/Bostitch-N66C-1-4-Inch-Magnesium-Housing/dp/B0006FKI5G

Just remember to get one that you can locally get nails for.

have fun, Bill

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#11

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

Barry Irby

>Your PT lumber will be ACQ treated and it is rough on fasteners. Be sure that the fasters are "rated" for the ACQ. The copper in it is corrosive to steel and you need either good stainless or excellent (185) galvanizing. There may be some that are ceramic coated that will work as well. These fasteners are not cheap, but not using them reduces your work to crap. I have seen decks nailed with ligthly gavanized fasteners where the deck boards could just be lifted off about a year later. Any fasteners rated for ACQ should be suitable for cedar and not drool rust on your fence.

And another thing. My Grandfather used to say "only a city slicker would set a post in concrete". I'm sure you have him spinning in his grave. You should dig the holes three or four inches too deep and pour in a little gravel, Tamp it with the post, set the post in place and pour gravel (crushed stone) around it and tamp it in place. You will be amazed and how well the stone "locks up" around the post and yet lets the water drain away. Concrete holds water close to the post and encourages it to rot, even the PT stuff tends to rot worse in concrete.

So work backwards. Find the fasteners you need and then buy the gun to drive them, even if it is a screw gun.

I have a big old honking Senco framing nailer and it will drive 8D nails. So, yes, the big guns will drive smaller nails.

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#12

Re: I'd use screws.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have several nail guns - bought my Senco light framer used on the bay. I also have brad nailer's in 23 18 16, and 15 gage - some new some from the bay. I have several staple guns - all from the bay. When I built my shop I purchased a used Grabber automatic screw gun to install the drywall, it has a Dewalt screw gun - cost me around $100 on the bay. It will also handle deck screws. When / if I install fencing like you are describing, I would use the screw gun. It is quite fast, with the square drive, it never slips. Proper screws (stainless steel). The screws aren't cheap - of course neither are the stainless nails, but if your using the new treated wood it is the only way to assemble the fence. A nailer would work but I think the screws would hold much better, they are also easily removable in the event you have to repair the fence later. Another plus is that it is easier to string out extension cords than hose to provide power.

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#13

PS.

Barry Irby

>One disadvantage to galvanized fasteners is that it is possible to chip or knock off part of the galvanizing and leave some steel exposed, opening you up to rust. Nail guns are much less likely to do this becasue they tend to push the nail rather than pound it like a hammer, but it is still possible. Stainless fasteners would be better.

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#14

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

Dustcollector

>Hitachi has phillips head galvanized screws which can be shot with their nail guns (or with any framing gun??). I haven't tried them yet buy I've been thinking about using them for a 200' fence. 'Course, I try a lot of things that don't work...

Anyone used these?

From Hitachi site:

"Nearly twice the holding power and 3 times the withdrawal force rating of a nailer installed screw shank nail

Screw can be unscrewed from material without damage to the subfloor material."


img

Re: Which Nail Gun to buy for fencing???

#15

Amazing!!!!

Barry Irby

>This brings an old memory up to date.

Years ago I hired a carpenter I knew to hang doors. I was stunned to se him driving the hinge screws in with a hammer. He said "Hammer is for putting them in, Screwdriver is for taking them out."

Welcome to the new millinium. Nail gun is for putting them in, screwdriver for taking them out.

Wonder if these woudl work in my big Senco framing nailer? Woudl it overdrive them? How could I set the depth?