Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Sheared screw

Posts

Sheared screw

#1

JL

Sheared screw

JL

>I've got a #12 x 3" screw that sheared off at the junction of the barrel and the threads. Unfortunately it was about 3" deep when it happened. So I still have the threads holding the piece together. So - should I drill it out with ye olde twist bit? Any brilliant ideas?

Any recommendations for bits other than a twist bit?

Re: Sheared screw

#2

Re: Sheared screw

Gary Camp - Bend, Oregon

>Take a piece of steel tube that will just fit over the screw, use a dremel type tool (or a file) and cut some saw teeth on one end of the tube. Use one of your trusty twist bits the same size as the od ot the tube to drill a guide hole down to the broken screw. Slip the tube drill bit in the hole, drill out the screw and plug it. Some of the cataloges have screw remover bits in them, but I haven't seen one big enough for a 3" screw.

glc

Re: Sheared screw

#3

brake line for the tubing maybe?

John in New Mexico

>

Re: Sheared screw

#4

Re: Sheared screw

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon JL,

I'd use Gary's idea before trying a screw extractor. I know screw extractors work for everybody else in the world, but not for me. Having the screw buried so far into the stock realizes a lot of thread friction power, and backing it out must overcome all of that. Far better to saw around it if possible, and then plug it. Alternatively, maybe you could sink another screw beside the first but at a slight angle to it. I've seen #3 son use that trick when he broke buried brass screws while gaining a hinge for me. You may need a rotory burr to countersink and you could plug the hole.

George

Re: Sheared screw

#5

JL

Re: Thanks..

JL

>I guess I'll have to find some 1/4" steel tubing. Auto parts store maybe?

Re: Sheared screw

#6

Re: Thanks..

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>if Auto parts store cant't help, try http://www.mcmaster.com/ and then punch in 1/4" Steel Tubing.

Re: Sheared screw

#7

Adding to what Gary said!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>SInce you indicated that the screw is still holding the top board in place, you only need to drill deep enough witht he tube to free the first board. You should be able to pull off the first board and use visegrips to get the screw out. If you can do this you will have a clearance hole in the piece being held and still have good threads in the piece doing the holding.

Just a note on screw joints...When attaching one piece of wood to another with screws, teh piece being held should have a clearance hole so that the screw can freely rotate in the hole and the threads should not engage in the this piece. Basically the screw should drop into this hole. The second piece should have a pilot hole drilled slightly deeper than the length of engagement of the screw. When the screw is tightened it should pull the first piece tightly against the second piece.

When screwing into hardwoods, pilot holes and clearnace holes are essential and dragging the screw threads across a block of beeswax (not soap) will make the likelyhood of screw breakage significantly less. The beeswax will also make screw driving take half the effort. Soft woods are a little less likely to break screws, but pilot holes and clearance holes will reduce splitting.

Lee

Re: Sheared screw

#8

JL

Re: Adding to what Gary said!

JL

>Thanks for this advice - It is much easier than drilling it out.