Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

Posts

My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#1

My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>In a thread below Ellis expressed the desire to see construction details of my bench, which base is built with 2 x 4's.

Keep in mind here that this bench was built 11 years ago, so be gentle... :-)

At the time I had just separated from my spouse, bought a new house, and had no spare money for "niceties", yet I needed a bench to work on, so this was the best I could come up with at the time.

So here's the ugly duckling:


Base built out of 2 x 4s. I did mention in the previous thread that the legs and stretchers were half-lapped, this is only half-true, as they are half-half-lapped (only one notch in the legs). Here's the bottom stretcher joint:


And here's the top stretcher joint:


These joints are held in place with glue and screws. The ends of the base are panels as per Ellis' suggestion, particleboard screwed in place (that's all I had available at the time).

The top is made of three layers of 3/4" plywood glued together, on top of which 1/4" hardboard is screwed. I made the skirt out of birch scavenged from pallets. The front vise is a Record #52 (I believe), while the end vise is a Taiwanese knockoff of the Record (actually, it works more smoothly than the Record).

Even though the bench is crude, it has some refinements not usually found on a bench. The best one is the mobile base, built out of 1 x 1 steel tubing, and based on the mechanism used by the Ridgid's Hercu-Lift, great system, no bending to raise or lower the bench.

Here's the bench "up and mobile":


In use, one steps on the pedal at the end of the bench, and pulls the hinged locking board using the string attached to it. To release, just push on the locking board while pressing on the pedal, and release. Works great.

Here's the bench up and locked:


Now it is down"


The last interesting feature is the drawer that opens on both sides of the bench. The concept is of "a drawer inside a drawer". Here's the drawer opened on the left side:


And the drawer opened on the right:


Would I build another bench like that? Not today, but 11 years ago it was the best I could come up with (technically and moneywise). I have a pretty solid plan in my head as to how to build the next bench, what features to include, etc., but the fact is that this bench still serves me well enough that I don't want to spend the time building another one. So for the foreseeable future, that bench is "it" for me...

As I mentioned in the previous thread, the bench is very rigid, no racking at all, however it is light in weight (my guess would be about 150 lbs. Since I am not building another one anytime soon, I might end up putting ballast at the bottom shelf.

Thanks for watching,

DC

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#2

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

john lucas

>Dennis Not far from what I built when I was in the same situation. I used 4x4's with draw bolts. After a break in at the house I installed plywood all the way around with locking doors. Now all my small easily lifted power tools are locked away inside. That will stop the casual thief anyway.

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#3

Bob Moffett

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

Bob Moffett

>Dennis, It works and that's what counts. My workbench is one of the first large projects I ever made and it is 30+ years old.

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#4

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

Jerry Gibbs

>The bench looks like it does the job. The lesson I took from the post is beware of "temporary" fixes. Jerry Gibbs

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#5

Ric Taylor

Wanna Trade?

Ric Taylor

>I'm using a folding card table and the top of an old table saw.

Ric

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#6

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>I appreciate all of the repsonses about workbenches after my question yesterday. Right now I am seriously thinking about a 5" thick top like David showed us. I like the mass, and I think it is totally doable for me. I have the Veritas large front vise and the twin screw end vise and I want the bench to be heavy enough that the vise operation will not suffer.

I had never thought to put a panel on the ends of the bench, but I can see how it would greatly improve the stability of the overall unit. I think I will incorporate that idea.

I know it goes against common advice, but I also plan to put some storage cabinets under my bench. The garage is getting crowded, and I need the storage space (especially for my "bench" tools.

Thanks again,

Rob Hix

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#7

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I see nothing wrong with putting drawers in the base, provided that you leave clearance underneath the top for clamps and holdfasts. That's one problem with my bench, I've come to use my holdfasts more and more, and some of the dog holes land over the stretchers or the drawer, making them impossible to use with holdfasts. In fact, I can't even use the regular Veritas round bench dogs, with a 2 1/2" top I have to use the bench pups.

DC

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#8

So... what would you change?

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>> I have a pretty solid plan in my head as to how to build the next bench,

> what features to include, etc.,

If building the bench today with the same money issues, but with your years of experience, what would you do differently?

I like the simple and effective way of engaging the casters, will have to borrow that from you.

Bill

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#9

Re: So... what would you change?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>If building the bench today with the same money issues, but with your years of experience, what would you do differently?

I like the simple and effective way of engaging the casters, will have to borrow that from you.

Bill

I would add a bank of drawers below the top stretcher, that would add storage space and mass. The current drawer that opens on both sides, that's nice if you access the bench from both sides, but in practice I've turned to put my bench against the wall, As Adam Cherubini and Chris Schwartz (and many others, I'm sure) suggest. And that drawer gets in the way of holdfasts and long dogs, as I said before.

I would probably double up the legs, in order to get a stiffer feel when chopping stuff. The top would remain the same, however the current skirt is wider than the top is thick, making clamping stuff annoying. Instead of screwing hardboard on top of the plywood, I would run a groove 1/4" from the skirt's edge, and capture a piece of 1/2" MDF, rabetted to fit in the groove. Currently I have to pay attention where I chop stuff because of the screws, a minor annoyance.

Without a dedicated tail vise, I would move the metal vise at the left end instead of in the middle, where it sits now. Even better, I would add another vise to the right, that could be used as a poor man's twin screw substitute.

That's all I can think of for the moment, if something else comes to mind I'll let you know...

DC

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#10

Re: So... what would you change?

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>Denis, thanks for the reply.

The two way drawer looked interesting, but now that you mention it, my bench will also live against a wall at least half the time so it's a set of drawers below. Now all I have to do is decide on the vice.

Bill

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

#11

Re: My old ugly bench, as per Ellis' request

Pete LaBelle

>We have a couple office furniture makers in town. Each has a "factory outlet store" where all sorts of things show up. They always have a good selection of formica topped ( & bottomed) 1-1/4" thick particle board tops with vinyl banding on them. Costs are $5-20. My benches are made of them and they work great. Undercarriage on the most heavily used one is some salvaged 2x6 maple boards with my first attempt at mortise & tenon construction. Very stout, heavy, and cost less than $25 to build.