Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

Posts

Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

#1

Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

Jerry Hall

>Any experience or thoughts on the WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener? Here is my preliminary take from watching their video and product description http://www.drilldoctorstore.us/ws3000.html:

I use the "Scary Sharp" system and like the clean, no water or oil, inexpensive, flat (with no truing of a stone) a lot. I like also that I can easily bring the kit with me to a job site, not that I do a lot. So I think these guys are right on in building this. I think the WS3000 is priced reasonably. The only automated system I have ever considered is the Makita water based system (very messy,) which this system clearly emulates in many respects. I like the small form factor for the tool. Easy to stow. One downside of rotating disk grinding surfaces is the potential for differential grinding due to differences in tangential speeds. This wouldn't be a practical problem for narrow tools, but might for wider tools. I suppose it can be minimized by moving the tool around. The "under the counter" angle sharpener is clever, but I fear impractical in that all wear will be localized in one circle on the disk and for a 2" wide tool may likely result in differential grinding. I have always liked hollow ground tools, and this machine would produce a flat grind. A flat grind in theory provides more edge support. A hollow grind is easy to touch up by hand. You would have to use this power tool for every touch up. I am not sure I would like that. I like that they have not designed it around proprietary abrasives. There are some marvelous choices in ceramic and other innovative abrasives. I very much like the ability to quickly and easily lap the back of tools, a key factor in "sharp" i.e. two intersecting polished planes. It is PITA to do it by hand and has led me to carpal tunnel on more than one occasion, and hours at the bench. I can't quite comprehend how gouges and the like would be sharpened in a controlled way, or how jigs would be used on the top bar. But I see potential there, and would like to better understand.

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

#2

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener *LINK*

Garrett in Victoria BC

>Hi Jerry

You can read my in-depth review at the link below, and I'd be glad to try to answer any questions, or get answers for you from the Work Sharp people.

You wondered:

1) "One downside of rotating disk grinding surfaces is the potential for differential grinding due to differences in tangential speeds. This wouldn't be a practical problem for narrow tools, but might for wider tools. I suppose it can be minimized by moving the tool around."

You cannot "move the tool around" if using the tool rest. The tool rest fixes it firmly in place at a very specific reference angle to the abrasive.In fact, because the tool is in contact with the abrasive for only a couple of seconds at a time, abrasive life is very good.

2) "The 'under the counter' angle sharpener is clever, but I fear impractical in that all wear will be localized in one circle on the disk and for a 2" wide tool may likely result in differential grinding."

I think - but do not know - that the 'under the counter' approach as you cleverly term it is to facilitate what is an excellent tool rest position that gives you complete control and the small form factor you appreciate.

See preceding para re wear. Not really a problem. Also no problem re differential grinding. I know what you're concerned about, i.e. the slight difference in rotating speed at various points on the disk's diameter, but it has no practical effect.

3) "I have always liked hollow ground tools, and this machine would produce a flat grind. A flat grind in theory provides more edge support. A hollow grind is easy to touch up by hand. You would have to use this power tool for every touch up. I am not sure I would like that. I like that they have not designed it around proprietary abrasives. There are some marvelous choices in ceramic and other innovative abrasives. I very much like the ability to quickly and easily lap the back of tools, a key factor in "sharp" i.e. two intersecting polished planes. It is PITA to do it by hand and has led me to carpal tunnel on more than one occasion, and hours at the bench. I can't quite comprehend how gouges and the like would be sharpened in a controlled way, or how jigs would be used on the top bar."

You can still sharpen on a wheel and finish on the Work Sharp to get the best of both wheels. Plus the Work Sharp enables you to produce a perfect secondary bevel every time and in about 5 seconds.

You can also use proprietary abrasives on an extra glass (tempered) platen. They are dead flat. However, unless you can figure out ho to get those abrasives to adhere upside down, you'll have to use the top of the platen, but at least it will be powered.

Cheers, Garrett


Work Sarp 3000 Review

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

#3

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

Howard

>Garrett or anybody else:

How does it compare with the Veritas MKII? I will only be sharpening chisels and plane blades.

Thanks

Howard

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

#4

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

Garrett in Victoria BC

>Hi Howard

Although I'm a Lee Valley fan, IMO sharpening chisels and plane blades is exactly what the WorkSharp was designed to do. It's simple, fast, and exact. Hard to beat for the cost.

Unfortunately for you, Howard, I don't think it's available in Canada, but if you do want to order one, I can probably help.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

#5

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener *LINK*

Jerry Hall

>Garret,

Thanks for your excellent response to my comments. Your review was great. I had trouble getting it to come up consistently in Firefox or IE7 (Vista) so I published your review in Google Docs (see Link) so my friends can read it without hassle. Hope this is OK. I also hope WoodCentral will add your review to their articles. I notice in July Drill Doctor is going to be selling a WS2000 for substantially less. No details I could find, just a picture. Any feedback on this and how it differs from the WS3000?

Jerry

PS Thanks also for your "Full Disclosure" of your relationship with Drill Doctor.


WS 2000 Review Copy in Google Docs

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

#6

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

Paul Woolson

>I've been a tormek man for years. It had two major drawbacks for me. 1) I don't have running water in my shop so I had to tromp through the house to get it. and 2)I'm not a fan of the hollow grind as I was often breaking off tips.

So I picked up a WS 3000. Let me tell you, this is the bees knees. I LOVE it. The angle grind is much more accurate than a tormek. I went through my whole rack of chisels and took out the hollow grind and made them all the same angle. Took all of 30 minutes.

One word of caution: I used to keep my chisels on a magnetic knife rack. When you start on the courser grits it is removing visible metal "dust" from the tool. Because this dust was magnetic it all collected into a pile. Does anyone know what happens to metal dust when a spark hits it? Yes, I had a little fire in mine. No damage to anything but it scared the heck out of me.

I'd buy this tool again in a heartbeat!

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

#7

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener *LINK*

George (Oxford, NC)

>Current issue of WoodWorker's Journal has two reviews on the WorkSharp

http://www.woodworkersjournal.com/ezine/currentissue.cfm

George


WoodWorker's Journal Worksharp Review

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

#8

Re: Work Sharp WS3000 Wood Tool Sharpener

Garrett in Victoria BC

>Hi Jerry

You wrote: "I published your review in Google Docs (see Link) so my friends can read it without hassle. Hope this is OK."

Sure, but you might want to correct the name.

"I also hope WoodCentral will add your review to their articles."

Since I'm the WoodCentral Editor for Articles and Reviews, I can arrange that.

"I notice in July Drill Doctor is going to be selling a WS2000 for substantially less. No details I could find, just a picture. Any feedback on this and how it differs from the WS3000?"

George Summers has a post in this thread referring to another pair of reviews, one of which mentions the WS2000 as intended for "homeowners" and costing $100 vs $200 for the WS3000. Since the cheaper unit doesn't have the WS3000's terrific tool holder, I think you'd be well served to spend the extra big one up front rather than have a machine that won't perform nearly so well.

PS Thanks also for your "Full Disclosure" of your relationship with Drill Doctor.

It would have been dishonest of me otherwise.

Cheers, Garrett