Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Another Workbench Question...

Posts

Another Workbench Question...

#1

Another Workbench Question...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

As the time draws closer to get a good start on my workbench, I have been contemplating more and more what to do about my top. I was considering buying one vs. making one. If I made one was I going to go for a hybrid solid wood and sheet good top or something else. My fear was in flattening the top. Now that I have been reading up on flattening the top with a router jig, I have almost completely decided to build my top. I figure I can build a much thicker top for quite a bit cheaper that I can buy one.

Now for the question. In order to speed things up and get a bench to going I am considering using pine (yes, as in 2x4s) for my top. This will put me a 3"+ thickness. The only problem I see is the obvious warping issue before glue-up, and that I will be able to leave dings in the top. Can anyone give me anything else that should keep me from doing this? I am guessing in a couple of years I will either make a proper maple top, or make another pine one.

Thanks in advance,

Rob Hix

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#2

Re: Another Workbench Question...

Tony - Memphis

>Don't get too caught up in the flatness issue. You might want to look over at Popular Woodworking. Chris Schwartz has done a lot on just such a workbench. Be sure to look at the blog too. I think there is more info there. I made my top from mdf with a layer of hardboard on top. I added a hard maple edge that is 1 1/2 x 3" for clamping. I really like it. It was inexpensive, it is heavy, and is 'pretty' flat. Good luck with your bench. Its funny, regardless of the materials, our benches become old friends rather quickly. Every spot, every nick and gouge, every stain tells a story or reminds us of when we built that ...

Tony

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#3

Re: Another Workbench Question...

John Lucas

>I went to my local salvage yard and bought a solid oak door. I cut it down to 54" then drilled round holes for my bench dogs. It is very heavy and was already flat.

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#4

Re: Another Workbench Question...

Curly Smith

>Instead of gluing you could drill holes every 3-4' and use threaded rod to pull it together. Lot of holes to drill but easy and quick assembly.

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#5

Re: Another Workbench Question...

Ray Carson in Lawrenceville, NJ

>Hey Rob,

If you can make the trip try:

Bally Block Co.

P.O. Box 188

Bally, Pennsylvania 19503

They sell hard countertop cutoffs at a very reduced cost. I know gas prices are high but I bought a 3 1/4 x 72 x 30 hard maple laminated cutoff for around $75.00.

Do a search in the Wood Central archives and you'll see more information on who to contact and directions. I forget what the shop foreman's name is that you need to contact.

Hope this helps.

Ray

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#6

I did what you're proposing

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>and made mine from 2X4's glued face to face, 3-1/2" thick. I flatten it now and then, not even every year, with my jointer planes, and it's been fine. One of the real advantages of using utility wood like a lowly 2X4 is that your heart doesn't stop when you drop your router onto the top without retracting the bit first :-). Mine has taken a lot of dings and cuts over the last 22 years, and while I might change a thing or two about the layout, I'm still satisfied with it.

Bruce

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#7

I found the foreman's name....

Ray Carson in Lawrenceville, NJ

>.......from the WC archives......

Subject: Re: Source for Bench Tops

Posted By: Scott in Douglassville, PA braedan25@screaminet.com

Date: Friday, 3 October 2003, at 11:53 a.m.

In Response To: Re: Source for Bench Tops (Hank Knight in SC)

No, they don't. But one of the foremen (Russell, IIRC) has the go-ahead to unload seconds for next to nothing directly to people who come to pick them up. Literally. They off blocks which have any significant coloration, delamination, and a few other mild, minor blemishes which have no effect on workbench tops, but do on consumer-targetted countertops.

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#8

Also Recommend Bally Block

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Rob,

My #1 son and I went up there to buy his wet bar top and counter top. They have fine values and its a neat place to visit. And on the way home, you could stop over at my place and have lunch.

George

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: Another Workbench Question...

Dale Lenz

>I built my SYP bench during the summer of 82' pictured below, it has worked well. But, if I could of purchase a hardwood top for 75 bucks, I believe that's a no brainer. Dale


img

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#10

Re: Another Workbench Question...

Ray Binnicker

>I built mine from SYP. I bought 2x12's from one of the home stores. They just happen to have some very nice, knot-free ones, and I ripped them down to 3" and glued them up in stages ( 4 at a time) so I could manage them and run them thru the planner and then glued up the sections of 4 and ran them thru the planner. The final glue up was only 3 sections which wouldn't fit the planner but required very little in the way of flattening. It is a very solid bench top and a lot cheaper than one made of maple.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#11

Re: Another Workbench Question...

wayne

>Another choice is a 1 3/4" Solid Core Hardboard door. They come in different widths and are 6'8" long and most but not all are as flat as a laminate counter top. They clean up easy and if needed can be overlaid with another layer of Masonite. And they are very very heavy. I use one for a makeup table when I clean it off, never have enough places to sit stuff.

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#12

Re: Another Workbench Question... *LINK*

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Check out my website below with pics of a website detailing some of the process I went through building my bench. The top is 20 2x6x12's glued up, into the heaviest bench top I've ever seen... I surface planed all the boards with my uncle's lunchbox planer, then straightened one edge with a wooden joiner plane. Then I ripped each board to width, cleaned it up with the joiner, then glued the whole thing up at once.

Spent some time flattening it, no warping whatsoever.

David


http://mydadandme.net

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#13

Re: Another Workbench Question...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Thanks for the ideas everyone. I like the idea of a maple top, but the cost and psychologial factors that go into the SYP top are very attractive. With SYP I will be careful with the top, but at the same time not feel bad if I accidently poke a hole in it.

David, thanks for the link. I am now considering thicker than 3-1/2" for the top.

When it is done I will be sure to post pictures.

Thanks again,

Rob Hix

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#14

Re: Another Workbench Question...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Over on the handtool side, there are some interesting bench discussions on a semi-regular basis. And some darn fine ideas.

Chris Schwarz at Popular Woodworking does lots of benches. He uses home center 2x12 SYP, normally sold as floor joists, because it's clear and solid, and cuts it down to his desired size.

The bench I built was of Home Depot KD studs and cabinet grade ply laminated three deep for the top. Works for me for 6 years or so now.

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#15

Re: Another Workbench Question...

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Rob,

The thicker top did several things for me: it providing immense stability, helping me overcome the fact that I've never joined such big timber before - my legs are 3 2x6's and the stretchers are 2 2x6's glued up, so those drawbored mortise and tenon joints were by far the biggest things I've ever done. But they came out fine, and I would recommend drawboring them, that worked great. But any misses in the joinery was totally overcome by the massive weight of the top (I could barely lift one end of this top when it sat on sawhorses...)

The stability of the whole bench is just hard to get past with a 5" thick top. I could pound the top with a ten pound hammer and not make the bench bounce; the thickness also gave me some fantastic stability for my Groz quick-release face vise.

David

Re: Another Workbench Question...

#16

Re: Another Workbench Question...

Barry Irby

>Glenn mentioned using larger lumber and ripping it down. I have made a bunch of yellow pine furniture and that is what I did. Two by tens and twelves have much better lumber in them than two by fours. Bigger trees and all that. Also, you rip away that little rounded corner you don't want in this application.

I'd buy them, rip them and put them in the house to dry a while, framing lumber has too much moisture for a bench top.

Another thought, before you assemble the bench top, you could cut some carefully matched rabbets in adjacent pieces and come up with 3/4 by 3/4 (or whatever) square holes for bench dogs.