Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Follow up on Painting and TSP

Posts

Follow up on Painting and TSP

#1

Follow up on Painting and TSP

Barry Irby

>I posted a message here a day or two ago about painting a rental house and cleaning it with TSP. Since the post fell of the bottom and am posting the response I got from Zinsser "at the top".

The place I was trying to paint was grimy. I tried Simple Green and was not happy (Seemed like I was chasing the crud around, but not removing it). On advice from two different paint store and Lowes, I bought and cleaned it with TSP. The real stuff with the Phosphorous. It was stunning. Grime came off to the point I had sediment in the bucket or cleaning water. Was told it did not leave a film behind.

Then I bought Zinsser 1 2 3 primer. Again based on the advice that it was "the real deal" and the best thing going for painting over gloss and dirt and nicotine and whatever. I had washed down the trim and some of the walls, but not the ceilings.

On the label it said "use the appropriate solvent" (Do not use TSP). There was no explanation. The paint store people did not know why. Painters said, "I been using TSP for twenty years, works great" "if it gets washed at all it gets washed with TSP".

This morning I Called Zinsser (not available on the weekend) and there answer was that TSP leaves a residue or film and that the paint won't adhere. That I should have used ammonia and water. The product has some ammonia in it. (Stinks). I suspect the ammonia in the cleaning solution is compatible with the ammonia in the product.

They said that if there were a residue left the failure would be the primer would peel off.

PS, Being the manly man that I am, I had no time to wait on Zinsser to come back from the weekend and I have primed the house. Seems to have worked well. There have been places where I spotted defects under the primer and went back and sanded with a ROS. No problem. That stuff holds on well. The label says it gains bond strength for about 7 days. Should be good to go. Time to move on with this, I hate painting and have had about all I can stand.

Re: Follow up on Painting and TSP

#2

Thanks for the update, Barry

Ellis Walentine, Host

>

Re: Follow up on Painting and TSP

#3

Re: Follow up on Painting and TSP *LINK*

Kirk D.

>Barry,

Sounds like you made out. I hope this link works. I did find out that phosphates are thought to cause damage to the enviroment and I bet that explains why I can't find TSP in my local stores. The link takes you to Savogran were they state TSP-PF is just as good a cleaner as TSP. I have to agree with this statement. I have used both and can find no difference in cleaning power. Also I'm happy not to do additional damage to the enviroment. The old school this is the only way it works attitude is boring and dangerous. I will never use TSP again now that I know it harms the enviroment. At the same time I'm glad my store carries TSP-PF becuase this stuff will clean nasty grime real good. An open mind is a wonderful thing.

Kirk


Savogran

Re: Follow up on Painting and TSP

#4

Re: Follow up on Painting and TSP

Barry Irby

>I probably am guilty of going "old School" on this. I usually try to evaluate Old school versus the latest and greatest and go with what makes sense. I had tried Simple Green (works GREAT for cleaning sanding belts) for this and did not like the results. Just pushed the dirt around.

I do wish Zinsser had put a sentence or two of explanation with the admonition, Do not use TSP. I could not decide if there were a technical reason like "it bursts into flames with our product" or a politically correct reason like "it kills the little fishies". If they had said that there is ammonia in our product and you get better bond strength if you wipe down with water and ammonia, I would have been right there. But, "clean with the appropriate solvent" did not tell me much that was useful. Sort of like when your mother told you, "now you be careful" when you thought using a DOUBLE bed sheet for a parachute was being careful.

I spent a couple of hours on Zinsser�s web site. I would not necessarily have expected a full explanation on the label, but it was the label that brought this to my attention. I could not find a reference to TSP on their web site. Looks like if it made it to the label they could have elaborated on the website. I just wanted to cut through the BS and get on with it. Did I mention I hate painting.