Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

workbench

Posts

workbench

#1

workbench

Peter Quad

>I'm planning to build a workbench for my garage. It will have certain specific functions, and for the space I want to put it in I really would like the dimensions to be 54" wide, 22 inches deep and 42 inches high.

My concern is that with the narrow depth and tall height, I won't be able to make it sturdy. I do plan to overbuild it a bit - 3/4 inch hardwood plywood on top of 2x4s and 2x6s for the top, with 4x4 legs and a bottom shelf framed with 2x4s. I'd rather not anchor it to a wall.

Does anyone have opinions on whether these dimensions can be made sturdy? If necessary I will go out to 24 inches deep, but if it's not necessary I won't.

Thanks for your time,

Peter

Re: workbench

#2

Re: workbench

Curly Smith

>Your dimensions are fairly close to Nova's "Shop Made Lathe Stand". Take a look at page 10 of the below PDF:

Shop-made Lathe Stand

Add the sand to the bottom compartment and it will be sturdy and stable. You can, of course, add cabinets and drawers to your heart's content.

Re: workbench

#3

Center of gravity

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I don't think 2" (22" instead of 24") is going to make any different in stability.

Two things to think about.

Center of gravity, and ground extensions.

Put alot of weight near the base. Extra weight if you have to (sand, concrete, steel).

Wider feet.... If your top must be 22" deep you can put the whole thing on a 24" deep piece of plywood, some 2x4's or some snagle iron or flat stock steel on the floor to give it wider footing.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: workbench

#4

You need end panels

Ellis Walentine, Host

>You didn't mention what your definition of sturdy is. I assume that with a 42" height, you will not be doing a lot of hand planing on this bench (unless you're 7' tall). So lateral rack resistance may or may not be an issue. But, regardless, to keep the substructure from racking, you will need end panels and a back panel securely attached to the legs. Your 2x4 frame will not resist racking in any direction. If you wanted to get a little fancier with the joinery, I would say to use tall (6" highor more) rails with big tenons into the legs. If you did this and pulled the shoulders up good and tight, it would provide enough rack-resistance for most uses.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: workbench

#5

Re: You need end panels

Peter Quad

>Thanks very much for the information. What do you mean by end panels? I was thinking about using what's left of my 3/4" plywood to close off the lower shelf except in the front - would that do?

I will actually be using 2x6s around the top, bolted into the legs, and 2x4s on the bottom (also bolted). I plan to use a 2x6 to have a slight (~2") overhang off the front, and then I will put another 2x6 in the back and a 2x4 in the bottom, and glue and screw (from below) the plywood on top.

I am a very inexperienced at this so I'm trying to keep it simple but still end up with something sturdy. Pressure I am worrying about is pushing up or down on overhang in the front.

Re: workbench

#6

Re: Center of gravity

Peter Quad

>That is a great idea - if I feel it will tilt forward or back I could screw or bolt the bottom of the legs to 2x4s to make the feet wider. I hadn't thought of that, thanks!

Re: workbench

#7

Re: workbench

Peter Quad

>I do plan to put some heavy stuff on the bottom shelf (not sand though). Those plans make me feel a little more secure.

Re: workbench

#8

Re: You need end panels

Peter Quad

>I made a typo in that last message - I meant a 2x6 in the front, one in thae back and a 2x4 in the middle (not bottom).

Re: workbench

#9

That should do it

Ellis Walentine, Host

>That's what I meant, Peter -- plywood around the back and sides, nailed or screwed to the legs. that keeps the bench from racking. Save your 2x6s, as they are overkill for supporting the top. 2x4s should work fine.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: workbench

#10

If you find

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>IF you find that using 2x4's places a tripping nuisance in front of the bench, you can use 3/4" plywood, or even 1/4" steel which is less of a nuisance.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: workbench

#11

Re: I understand plywood, 2x4's, and steel, but...

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Mark,

I understand plywood, 2x4's, and flat steel stock. but what the heck is "snagle iron?" Is that something that you snag at the landfill? As in, "Honey, look what I snagged at the landfill!" Is it only available in Georgia? Can you post a picture? I've not seen it here in the Midwest. He he.

Al

Re: workbench

#12

Its what they mined at Fraggle Rock

John in New Mexico

>

Re: workbench

#13

Re: You need end panels

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Your 2x4 frame will not resist racking in any direction

It can, if "well constructed". My bench has a 2 x 4 frame, but all the joints are half-lapped (about 1/4" deep), glued and screwed (on the long sides). On the short sides I used end panels as you suggested.

I get no racking whatsoever, however the downside is weight, unless weighed down the bench can move a bit during aggressive hand planing.

DC

Re: workbench

#14

Shoulders

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Rack resistance is on a continuum and increases with the width (height) of the rails and strong shoulders, whether on a tenon or a half-lap (which is also a tenon if you think about it). You didn't mention how your half-lapped frame is constructed. Did you attach the long rails directly to the legs, with shoulder against the edge of the leg. That's a better arrangement than just a rectangle of 2x4s screwed to the legs, which relies strictly on the fasteners to resist racking. The important thing, though, is that your design stands up to your work requirements. If it is sturdy enough to resist the punishment you give it, that wins. I tend to overbuild things myself.

Have we seen a photo of this bench?

Ellis

Re: workbench

#15

Re: Shoulders

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I don't think I've ever posted a picture of that bench, as it's not the most beautiful one you've ever seen... I even have a 3' x 6' maple slab in the garage, ready to be turned into a beautiful bench, but two things keep me from building one: time (lack of), and the fact that my current bench does everything I need for the moment...

I'll try to shoot some pics tonight...

DC