Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Posts

OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#1

OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Dan Manturi

>I am going to run some hot and cold water lines and have not done so in a long time but I am pretty experienced at it. Got some sticker shock at the price of copper tubing! As a part time realtor, i am seeing a lot of this new red and blue tubing - I believe it is called PEX. I hear it is better than plastic PVC for supply lines ( I have never used that stuff for supply lines and hear bad things about it in general - it is cheap and easy, though). Has anyone ever used this new PEX stuff? I know a special ring compressor tool is needed, which I am sure I can rent as it is a little pricey.

Comments appreciated in advance.

Regards,

Dan M.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#2

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Grant Smith

>Dan,

The new tubing is indeed very popular. One caveat about it is that the manifold system it uses are pricey. Plumbers like the system, however because it saves so much labor since it can snake around bends so easily.

You can also make up a manifold out of copper and then run the plastic tubing from there, saving some of the manifold cost, yet also saving the labor and much of the copper cost.

I haven't much experience with it beyond research and making the decision to have it used in my new home, which should break ground soon.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#3

New technology

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>My house was built abotu 20 years ago when someone had this great idea to use this new fangled poly-blue plastic pipe for the supply line between the road and the house. Every house in the neigborhood had it burst and replaced (at about $1500) at about 12 years (just after the class action lawsuit expiration I believe).

So I'm a bit wary of any "great new technolgy" for alot of things like that. Since labor is almost always more than the materials I usually stick with the best available quality, or something tried and true. I figure copper has been used long enough. Figure if they come out and say that copper causes cancer they be saying it causes cancer aftyer 50-60 years of use, but I don't want them coming out and saying any new stuff causes cancer in 4-5 years of use. Know what I mean?

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#4

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Dan Manturi

>Manifold. Hmm. Never thought of the "NEED" for that. Thought I could just hook the plastic lines up to existing copper. Thought the manifold was just a nice was to run mains into a place where branch lines could easily be connected. Wonder if these manifolds are a requirement or just a convienience. I have only 2 lines to run / for a clothes washer.

Dan

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#5

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Barry Irby

>The stuff Mark mentioned is Polybutelene (PB). The entrance line was usually Turquoise(ish) and often called Big Blue. PB was a disaster and subject to a recall, which I thought was still in effect. (Do a Google search on PB Pipe or Polybutelene and you will get more than you can ever read)

PVC is only suitable for cold water. CPVC is suitable for both hot and cold. Both use glued connections.

The stuff you are talking about is indeed PEX or Polyethelene Cross (X)Linked. The old standby black pipe that's been around for at least fifty years is Polyethelene but not cross linked and is only suitable for cold water. Somebody figured out how to cross link the polymer chains and made it suitable for hot water.

As a Home Inspector (or maybe as an old fuddy duddy) I am skeptical of the PEX. There were at least two failure modes for PB. The plastic fittings (Delrin or Acetal) failed and the crimped connectors failed and blew off. The industry developed "Go or No Go" gauges for the connections. A piece of plastic with a notch in the edge that would slip onto the connection if it were crimped well enough. (�Crimped� is not exactly the right term, the rings are compressed or swaged, but you get the idea). So the Old F@rt in me does not like the idea that we used to have this gray pipe that failed and now we have this new red and blue pipe that uses what appears to be the same connectors.

The pipe is actually the color of polyethelene (like a milk jug), but they color it red (for hot) and blue (for cold) to help or new generation of plumbers that can't tell left from right. (hot on the left, cold on the right, waste runs down hill). Under houses, apparently they run out and use whatever they have. I don't think the color matters technically.

Two things. Do not use it where ANY sunlight might get to it. Poly is subject to UV degradation. And most manufacturers of plastic pipe recommend between eight and eighteen inches of metal pipe at the water heater (both hot and cold) to keep the relentless heat off the plastic. It works better for intermittent heat, not continuous heat. Also, if you are circulating hot waster through it for heating zones, check to see if it is rated for it, (its not).

Other than being skeptical, I have no evidence it will fail. I�m in the �wait and see� mode. Ask me again in twenty years. Lets do the beta testing on you, not me. That�s probably unfair, but I know copper works except on well water, where my second choice would be CPVC.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#6

Re: manifold not required...

Grant Smith

>Unless you are completely replacing the plumbing, or building new construction.

Sorry for any confusion I may have caused.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#7

One further note on PVC...

John in New Mexico

>Some jurisdictions, like NM, forbid the use of PVC inside the house. CPVC is ok, PEX is ok, but no white PVC. Always good to check with the building department!

John

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#8

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Dan Manturi

>Aha! A home inspector! CPVC is OK on hot AND cold? That stuff is super easy to work with and if it is as affective as copper, that would be a real benefit both from cost and installation perspectives. However, I hear you saying "copper", and I know it is tried and true. Aside from the cost, sweating the stuff is a major pain in the butt compared to the ease of compressing or glue, but maybe I'll just bite the bullet and go with the tried an true. you seem to know a lot about the plastics, have some reservations, and I too am an old f*rt, so I hear you.

Dan M.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#9

On drugs???

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"... they color it red (for hot) and blue (for cold) to help or new generation of plumbers that can't tell left from right. (hot on the left, cold on the right, waste runs down hill)...

That's funny! Reminds me of an ad I heard on the radio. I think it's the voice of Neal Bortz who is advertising either a plumbing or electrical company.... he says they will be out within 60 minutes for emergency work, and that they send a certified drug-free non-ex-convict plumber to your house, so you don't have to deal with anyone giving you problems or messing things up.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#10

Sweating not so hard...

John in New Mexico

>Look for a little green tin of Oatey flux that says "pre-tinning". Its regular flux with ground up solder in it, makes it really hard to overheat the joint.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#11

Re: Sweating not so hard...

Dan Manturi

>That is the whole issue with sweating pipes is the overheating. Yes, I believe I recall having use that stuff and it is pretty effective.

Would not consider PVC. CPVC sounds pretty respected, but I think Copper is the way I will need to go. Have two runs of about 25 feet each. I may be able to keep cost down a little - I have a roll of soft copper (still better than PVC) that can likely span some of that distance. bought it a long time ago. I'd stay away from the PVC on this as it is being hooked up to a washer and that sudden shutoff action of a washer when it senses full is a stress on the pressure. I know that the rest of the plumbing in the home will take some of that stress, but better safe than sorry.

Dan

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#12

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Nat Robison

>I just plumbed a new basement bathroom with PEX with the help of my neighbor, who's a plumber. He had all the 90's and the crimper. A 10' piece of 1/2" PEX costs about $3 at Lowes so it completely beats copper on price (I think the same piece of copper is about $18-$20 around here right now). I'm not sure about the cost of the fittings but I have to imagine you'd be able to buy the length of PEX plus a handful of fittings for less than the copper pipe alone. You might be able to buy the crimpers and still come in cheaper than buying the copper.

He just tied it into tees off the main supply lines. We plumbed a shower, toilet, and sink in about 90 minutes. It won't turn 90 degrees but you can definitely bend it some.

As far as being a proven product, I guess that remains to be seen although my neighbor has no qualms about using it. I guess I'd like to think a product like that wouldn't make it to market nowadays without some strenuous testing.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#13

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Dan Manturi

>Wow. $3 for 10'. Pretty cheap. Crimpers (as someone noted, they are really compressors) are about $100. Good investment for a plumber, not so good for a homeowner who will not need them again for 10 years. They have these cheaper crimpers that you use with a vise grip, but if I use this stuff, I'd rent the reap ones.

Dan

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#14

PEX in our new house.

David Sophusson, Custer Wa

>This shot was taken about 2 months ago at our new home. It took only 1 day to do all the rough in plumbing for 2 bath, kitchen, laundry, and hot water tank. Now that all the walls are up and the roof is on, top out plumbing will be done either this week or next which will take less than a day. I like the stuff, if you ever want to make changes it�s easy and fast. My dad was a plumber from the old copper and cast iron days and had no use for plastic in plumbing but hey times change. He would probably be rolling in his grave if he saw how things are done now. Pex is pretty much the standard in new construction around here now.

Sophie, still around but has a lot going on right now.


img

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#15

Here's my 2�, soup to nuts.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>According to This Old House, although PEX hasn't been around in North America all that long (although I think it has to be at least ten years now), it's apparently been in use in Europe for a couple of decades more, as I recall. So it's not like we're the bleeding edge beta group.

PVC—when my daughter moved into their house in Jacksonville I was surprised to find that the copper pipe had been replaced by PVC/CPVC. How does copper fail? Anyway, we redid a bathroom and I had some plumbing to do in there so I went to the local box and was surprised to find out that PVC/CPVC seems to be the preferred flavor for supply in Duval County. One thing I learned is there is a difference in gluing pipe that will be pressurized (supply) and pipe that isn't (DWV). There was an incident. I don't think I care to use PVC/CPVC for supply lines again.

Copper. There is nothing difficult about sweating copper. There are three rules and no step can be omitted:

  1. Clean the pipe and fittings. Plumbers use emery cloth, I've used a cloth backed 220 wet/dry. Plumbers also use special twisty things (like wire brush bottle cleaners and battery terminal cleaners). So do I. If you don't clean you're guaranteed a failure.
  2. Flux the pipe and fittings. If you don't flux you're guaranteed a failure.
  3. Heat the fitting, not the pipe. I can't believe I'm hearing overheating. Lot's of plumbers and I use MAPP gas instead of propane because it's hotter. Some plumbers use acetylene. In either case it's not really for more heat, per se; it's for heat more quickly. If you heat the fitting until the solder wicks into the joint, you don't need any more heat. If the solder doesn't easily and quickly flow into the joint once hot, you haven't properly done steps 2 or 3. More heat won't help.

Sweating copper is much more reliable for me than gluing supply lines.

Rod

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#16

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Bart Castleberry

>I've done several of my rental houses with it and it is great. It also has a 20-30yr track record in Europe of performing well. It's not new at all its been the pipe of choice for radient heating for many years. I'm suprised no one knew this, esp the inspector, it's common knowledge.

I'd reccommend the stainless crimp rings and tool, they cost slightly more, maybe a few cents, but one tool will do 3/8"-1" pex other wise you need a different tool for each size. The stainless crimp tool I got cost about $100. Well worth it. You will have to go to a contractor's plumbing store, I have not seen the stainless crimps in a big box store. There are a couple different brands too.

PEX is also more resistant to freezing than most. It will freeze and stretch rather than break in most cases. I like that a lot, tenants are not always smart.

The problem with PB (Polybutelene) was mostly the plastic fittings used with metal crimps. PEX uses metal fittings and metal crimps. PB also had some installation problems with bends being made too tight (PEX has specs on this too) PB pipe also occasionally burst, but this is somewhat rare, the platic fittings were by far the most commom faliure points. That's what I have learned anyway.

You don't have to use manifolds at all and can make your own with pex fittings if need be.

For 2 25 foot runs I think you are wasting you time learning a new pipe material. The time you will have in running around getting and learning what you need for pex, you could have sold a house and paid someone to run the copper. Copper is not hard to sweat. so for 2- 25ft runs, you have $50-75 in it max, that's not much. if you want to start switching, then great get the PEX. I rarely replumb with copper now, any time anything fails, PEX goes back. But still in houses that are all copper, and say a valve goes bad, it will get a copper valve back, I'm not going to splice copper with PEX unless it's prone to freezing. Anything else that comes out goes back with PEX.

The time savings is well worth it if you do much plumbing wether it you or your plumber doing the work. I am going to redo all the supply lines from galvanized to PEX on a 2 br 1ba house when the current tenants leave, I expect I'll get it all done in 3-4 hours.

I don't know that copper or pex are better than the other, no question that copper has a more trusted rep, but most people would say the same on metal vs plastic. In some areas of the country, espcially with wells, the water is corrosive, you can't use copper and pex is clearly superior and v/v. All depends on your use.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#17

How copper "fails"...its a mystery

John in New Mexico

>In some areas you get pin hole leaks after a decade or so. No one seems to know why, and it only seems to be since the 1990's (though I may be wrong about that). Lots of talk and speculation on the FHB forum about it.

As to overheating, it's just the common novice mistake, once the flux burns the solder won't wick in. Doesn't take long to teach someone to sweat, but trying to learn by oneself can be frustrating, and the tinning flux makes it as easy as glueing. A novice using a presto-lite or similar torch probably wouldn't have as much trouble, since it does heat so much faster.

John

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#18

Re: How copper "fails"...its a mystery

Dan Manturi

>Well, i got a full bag of info. I can tell you as a part time real estate agent (formerly full time but I hated it) that all the new start homes are being plumbed out in PEX. Copper is not hard to sweat, not at all, but sticking a ring on a hunk of plastic hose, slipping it on a fitting, and compressing the ring seems technically simple as compared to measuring, cutting, fluxing, sweating, soldering. I worked as a plumbers apprentice way back when (1960's) and did a lot of it. My mind is that copper is the best way to go, most expensive, most labor intensive. Seems the PEX is getting pretty good press. Will probably call a plumbing supply and check out the stainless rings.

Thanks, all!

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#19

Re: Copper failure--What I found

Henry Higginbotham

>I had to repair some 60-year-old copper lines a couple of years ago. This was "soft" copper tubing but had sweat fittings. A pinhole had developed and caused quite a bit of damage before being discovered.

The hole was near the fitting, so I thought I'd just cut off about three inches, wrestle the remaining tubing around, and install a new tee. The pipe collapsed under the tubing cutter, and I had to go back two or three feet to find solid tubing.

Once I had the problem fixed, I split the removed section down the middle (well, sort of), and found that running water or minerals or something had eaten the copper away from the inside, leaving what sort of looked like termite trails. Sort of like washboarding on dirt roads--I don't know HOW it happens, but I know it does.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#20

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Bill White

>I just finished plumbing the new home with I-PEX. This one has the metal liner sandwiched between the layers. I did not use the manifold system. Just ran the I-PEX same way that you would use copper.

The plumber finally 'fessed up that he DID like working with the new stuff. That ought to tell you something.

Best part? It was 1/3 the price of copper.

Bill

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#21

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>HI Dan,

If you're still deciding, I would chime in on the side of PEX. I am sold on it! I have been using it for years. I have completely retrofitted our home and one cabin with it, and and have done the complete install on another cabin. I also ran all the PEX tubing for the radiant heat in my shop (24 x 40).

This is not a new product. It has a good track record in Europe for about 40 years. It is lightweight, flexible, and durable. It has great resistance from damage by freezing, which is why I put it in the cabins. As mentioned before, it is subject to UV degredation, so keep it our of the sunlight.

If you are looking at a whole house plumbing system, pressure drops in long runs are affected more by the number of fittings than almost anything else. In PEX systems, you have one fitting at one end, another at the other end, and an unbroken length of tubing in between. So pressure drop is less of a problem. Once I have made a connection between the PEX and a fitting, I have never had a leak in that connection. I can't say that about my connections using copper. Any plumbing failures I've had were at the fixtures, and had nothing to do with the PEX. For instance, we opened our cabin this past Saturday after sitting all winter unheated, and the only plumbing failure was a kitchen faucet that went bad.

For your purpose, running a hot and cold line to plumb for a washer, nothing could be simpler than using PEX. Put a T in an existing line, mount a PEX fitting on the T, then run the PEX to where you need it, and connect at each end to the fittings. If you accidently kink the PEX, pull it out, heat it up with a heat gun until the kink relaxes, and then when it cools the kink will be gone. You can't turn sharp corners with it, as it will kink (just like any other material).

Different manufacturers use different methods to make the mechanical connections. Most use some kind of a compression type fitting, or some kind of crimp method. I don't really care much for these (personal preference), and I use Wirsbo PEX which uses a connection method that has you expanding the PEX so it slips over the brass fitting, and it then shrinks onto the fitting, making a very sure connection. But if I were you, I would use one of the compression type fittings available where you buy the PEX.

I hope this helps!

Scott.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#22

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Dan Manturi

>Whole lot of closet plumbers on this web site. Makes you wonder - woodworking is a profession and a hobby, but plumbing - well, not many hobbiests! Like - what is your hobby? Plumbing. Sort of sad..

Anyway, I have heard enough pro - PEX stuff here to give it a go.

Thanks all!

Dan

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#23

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

Bart Castleberry

>Yeah there are a lot of closet plumbers here as you said. Most of the less expensive but not jack leg plumbers get around $40 an hour. Frankly they are well worth it and probably more. But still when I'm inclined or have an emergency, I don't mind saving some of that. It just depends on how busy I am, and what I feel like, some times of the year if I pick up tools I want to have fun, not fix. Sometimes a new renovation project is fun, sometimes it's not. I sell real estate full time, have a propery management business and invest, so somtimes like now, I am happy to pay any good trades people I can find and usually need more.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#24

Re: Copper failure--What I found

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>I recall a TOH episode where the plumber and some factory "scientist" were exploring pinholes in copper. I THINK I recall them explaining that using too much flux while a joint is soldered would cause the flux to run inside the tube and collect. Over time, the flux reacts with minerals in the water to corrode the copper, with the result the copper slowly dissolves.

Re: OT-Plumbing - Hot and cold lines

#25

PEX

Kirk D.

>I used Pex for my underground airlines. Connecting four buildings on my property. Has been under constant pressure 125 psi for several years with zero leakage. I can not say enough good things about PEX.