Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Cabinet saw opinions please

Posts

Cabinet saw opinions please

#1

JL

Cabinet saw opinions please

JL

>Opinions on the 50-260 M1 General Int. 10" Cabinet Saw? This is the left tilt model General International model w/ 50" fence.

Versus

Steel City Model 35623 10" Deluxe Cabinet Saw - right tilt model. (50" fence).

Or should I just save up my pennies and look for a deal on a Delta Unisaw (36-731)?

I would prefer a left tilt. I have considered the Grizzly G1023SL.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#2

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

Ron Jones

>I have used a right tilt Unisaw and a PM66 (left tilt) in my work. I didn't like the Unisaw at all due to the right tilt, but I didn't realize I didn't really like it until I was familiar with the 66. When I decided I needed a cabinet saw for my home shop, I shopped, compared and finally decided on Shop Fox with the Classic fence. I've been well satisfied and would buy it again.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#3

Table saw

Allen Hunt; Edwardsville, IL

>If if were getting a new table saw I would save and get the SawStop. The safety factors sell me on the saw, and and the quality is supposed to be top flight.

Allen

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#4

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I've had my left-tile JET for 7 years, and have absolutely nothing bad to say about it; when it bit me, it was my own damn fault. 12 sutchers and several years later I still have all 10 (pretty much), but if I were shopping for a cabinet saw, there would be no question that a SawStop would be sitting in my shop. All I need do is remember the days of intense pain thinly veiled by the drugs to make my choice in table saws. It helps, of course, that the SawStop received very high ratings for performance.

mm

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#5

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

HC Sakman

>Hi JL,

I'd stay away from Delta. Did you consider Laguna TS? Yes it's more money but you get more for your $. I haven't seen the PM 2000 (? is that the right model #? Anyway, the new 66) but from the pictures it looks well refined. I've seen and played with Sawstop, besides the unique safety feature, it's a very well made saw. Pay up once, cry once, then laugh all the time. That's my philosophy. I wouldn't buy anything less UNLESS the tool will be used in an abusive environment or for very rough work. Just my 2 cents.

Chico...

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#6

Grizzly 12"

Mike Fitterling

>Grizzly has their new 12" cabinet saw on sale right now for $1595 plus shipping. This is the new 12" one with riving knife. I would seriously consider that saw. Long rails, outfeed table, etc.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#7

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

Jim Dillon

>JL,

I have had for 10 years the right-tilt General 10 inch cabinet saw (Model 350 ??) made in Canada and I love it (except for the dust collection which is non-existent; the newer models are improved) . Having said that - and ignoring the companies politics and business model - I would seriously look at the SawStop if I were shopping today. If it were a piece of junk, I would not consider it - especially at that price. But all the reviews I've read and the posts on WoodCentral indicate it is a quality tool with an excellent fence. Yes, it costs quite a bit more, but the safety advantages are significant IMHO. If you are a family man, talk this over with family (including any pets 8-)). For me, the left-tilt vs right-tilt is not really that significant and there are usually work-arounds. My 2 cents.

Jim

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#8

JL

Re: Money is somewhat of a consideration....

JL

>I can get a new (in box) SC-35623 (Steel City right tilt Cabinet Saw) for $1280 (plus gas). I can get the 50-260 M1 General Int. 10" Cabinet Saw (display model) for $1065 (plus gas).

As I am now officially "retired", I have a limited budget for new tools. I would like a cabinet saw - anything is better than my old Sears C#@>$man. Last time I priced the Sawstop, it was maybe $3500 with a 50" fence. Yes, I realize that a visit to the emegency room would cost a bit. I suppose I could talk it over with my "financial advisor" and see what she says. She is aware of my desire for a cabinet saw.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#9

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

Jesse in New Mexico

>No experience with the General, but I've used the PM, the Unisaw, and the Sawstop. In my opinion, the sawstop is the best performer, but they all do a first rate job.

Try craigslist for a used unisaw. I've seen some great bargains and the older ones are better than what they are making now!

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#10

Bart Goldberg

I'd save up and get the Saw Stop

Bart Goldberg

>

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#11

In that case..

Bri in Mtl

>..and at that price I don't think you can go wrong with the General. I have one(right tilt) and know 4-5 owners that have either the left or right tilt version and we all have no regrets.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#12

General for me

Charles R. Smith in Victoria

>I owned a Delta Unisaw for years (and still do). I picked up a left-tilt General a couple of years ago when I wanted a new cabinet saw. It's the best saw I ever used. It is characterized by good workmanship, and it gives consistently great cuts. (And my bias is not because it is about the only one still made in North America.)

Charles in Victoria (who likes big, solid, green machines made in Quebec)

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#13

Re: Money is somewhat of a consideration....

Jim Dillon

>JL,

In that case - and to muddy the waters a bit - consider the other end of the money spectrum, i.e. the Grizzly line. There are a few WoodCentral folk who have looked under the Grizzly hood and believe that it cannot compare to the more expensive table saws. Fair enough, but it's sorta an apples and oranges comparison, money wise. On-the-other-hand, there are a lot of WoodCentral folk who have the Grizzly 10 inch TS and love it. For value, it seems to be a good deal IMHO. And I would guarantee (well almost 8-)) that, with a good sharp blade, you cannot tell the difference between a joint cut with a Grizzly or a higher priced saw. And then there are all those tablesaws in the middle of the price-range to tempt you. Not an easy choice to make, but is sure fun doing so.

Regarding the SawStop, I think people who buy it are taking the long-view on safety and what it would cost to go to a hospital for surgery - and not on performance of the saw since that seems to be well-regarded. Yes, there is a bit (maybe a lot!) of promotional "fear factor" regarding the selling of the SawStop. But each potential buyer (of any saw) must look at their own circumstances in arriving at their decision. Fortunately, probably any of the saws you mentioned will do a great job in the hobbiest workshop. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#14

Re: Getting What You Pay For.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Once you rule out a SawStop which is in a separate class for obvious reasons, I think you need to assess what your needs in a saw are. As was mentioned, most any of the cabinet saws will, properly adjusted, produce a precise cut. The differences come out over time and use. The PM has always been a production machine whose mass and precision insure that its settings will remain constant cut-after-cut, all day or all week. That kind of quality and stability is required in a production shop, where the saw pays back more than its price in labor cost savings. While I might like to say "I have a '66", I clearly don't need one, and in my hobbyist's basement Shoebox Woodshop, the JET, at less than half the price, will do just as well for me. After all, its not the tools but what they produce that makes you a craftsman. I started out with a Crapsman C-saw that I had to measure and set the distance from the blade to the fence at both the front and rear of the blade for every cut. When I make a cut on the JET, I set the indicator on the fence and nothing more, because I know that what I set is what I get. I also know that if I were shoving stuff through that saw for 8 hours a day, I'd be checking its set up far more often than I do now.

In that context, the Griz may be all the saw you need, just be willing to spend more time keeping it tweeked and tuned. I know a local pro who makes pool tables. He burned up a pair of Uni's, and now only buys Griz saws about every 4 years when they start to give out. He calculates from the cost/benefit side that he's ahead of the game that way.

Just remember that a properly tuned saw is the primary prerequisit for safety. How much time you will need to spend keeping it that way may be directly proportional to how much you'll use it and how much you spend on it.

Too bad none of the mags does a saw comparison by setting up a cut on each machine, then repeating that cut 1,000 times, and measuring the first and last pieces for variation.

mm

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#15

Re: I would not buy a SawStop

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Politics aside, I would not spend the extra $1000 - $1500 dollars for a Sawstop. I have a Unisaw. I have a set of Gr-Rippers - I never get my hand near the blade with them. I don't need or want a saw that will destroy my blade (and an expensive cartridge) if I hit a piece of metal. I Have an 8" joiner, its DANGEROUS, I have a 4.8 Hp bandsaw, it's Dangerous. I have a large drill press and a 1 hp PM lathe - they are dangerous. I also drive a Van - its MORE dangerous than all the mentioned tools. I am positive I could live safer, but I like to woodwork and drive. I have had reaction wood (6/4 white oak) close up on my microjig splitter and pull it out of my saw insert. With care - a sharp blade and plenty of saw hp, I forced the wood on through without kickback. I am not saying the Sawstop isn't worth the money - maybe to some it is, but if I felt safety was really that much of an issue with a standard saw - using sensible precautions, I would either work solely with hand saws or stop woodworking and start fishing (with dull hooks). Don't mean to start an argument, just stating my views.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#16

Fishing with Dull Hooks

Dustmaker Mike

>that is what I do so I can drink more Adult Beverages and not be bothered by those pessky fish.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#17

Re: Yeah, and since the hooks are

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>dull, you don't want to be use worms. It would be inhumane to force them onto the dull hook. - so saves bait money. Then you can buy a few more refreshments, right.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#18

Re: Bait?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You guys us bait?

Worms? On hooks? Ewww, icky!

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#19

Since Money is a consideration....

Charles Sharp

>Stand back and watch the flames.

I have one of the Craftsman cabinet saws and love it!

3 years ago when they were somewhat new my wife purchased one for me for Christmas (the one with the Biesmeyer fence).

I have cut 2" maple without a problem.

The only thing I would change is the length of the arbor. I can only cut dados about 3/4" wide, 7/8" doesn't leave very many threads for the nut.

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#20

Re: Since Money is a consideration....

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Unfortunately some people detest Craftsmen products because of the label. When I started woodworking many years ago Craftsmen products were all that were available to me so that is what I bought. I still have and use some of them but others have been replaced over the years. Looking back I am not sorry that I bought what I did when I did.

Howard

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#21

I'm with you , Larry, even if I had the money.

Henthorn

>My gosh, I even get out of bed each morning and face the day. How dangerous is that? (G)

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#22

Ditto... Buy a POWER FEEDER!!!

dwr

>

Re: Cabinet saw opinions please

#23

Each Of My 7 Sons Is A Power Feeder!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>