Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Grrr, Bearings!

Posts

Grrr, Bearings!

#1

Grrr, Bearings!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

Follow up to my helical head project. Everything went really well. I got the jointer back together with no problems. I set the tables up and jointed some maple and cherry, it was so NICE!

Well, nice except for the screaming noise��..from the bearings�Rummmmmbbbleeee��Weeeeeeeeeeeee!!!

My heart sank when I turned it on and heard that. So new bearings��maybe today if I can find some locally.

My question, I was wondering if I damaged them myself when I was installing them on the spindle shaft, using the bearing housing to contain the bearings and a block of wood and a hammer to �press� them on.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

The bearing are sealed , Nachi 6204NSE, the exact same ones that were on the old spindle. Any thoughts on quality replacements?

Take care,

Jim

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#2

Yep

Henry Higginbotham

>If you pressed them on or off by pushing or beating on the outer race, they're probably toast.

Try using a piece of plastic pipe or plastic electrical conduit that will slip over the shaft and contact the inner race to drive the new ones on.

My biggest problem in installing the Byrd head was getting the horizontal spacing correct--the outside cutters kept hitting things they shoudn't. The problem was eventually corrected and the head's been great. You'll love yours, too, once everything works.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#3

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

Curly Smith

>My guess is that the bearings are either not properly seated or that you damaged the bearing cage when installing them on the shaft, and from what you said bearing damage is the more likely situation.

You should consider using a bearing driver for the size of bearing that you're installing. Bearing drivers are made from mild steel (wood is really not a good choice) and are designed to prevent contact with the cage. You can make one or buy one.

I'd take one or more of your old bearings apart and use the hub as part of the driver and a socket as the other part. Slide the new bearing on the shaft, slide the old hub on, slide a socket on the shaft and tap on the socket with a hammer to drive the bearing into position. If desired, you can omit the old hub but I think it's good protection.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#4

Re: Grrr, Bearings! *LINK*

Mark Nowicki

>Jim:

All the mechanics I know heat their bearings beforehand.

Regards

Mark


SKF

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#5

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

Todd Doherty

>Heat the bearing or freeze the shaft. Sometime you may need to a little bit of both.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#6

Bridging the Gap

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Jim,

A bummer indeed! Are that jointer and cutter head solely North American products? Is it possible you could bridge the gap between Asian and North American tools by getting the Barings Strait?

George (backing away at full throtle)

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#7

Socket wrench for bearing pusher?

John in New Mexico

>Haven't read all the replies, so maybe someone has suggested this already. Anyhow, they work great if they're long enough.

John

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#8

Global Sourcing

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>George,

You are one in 6 billion!

:-)

Indeed I messed up my bearings (Japanese), I have a new set to replace them....SKF (Thanks Mark), made in Argentina... Got them from NAPA of all places..

Take care,

Jim

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#9

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Thanks for the Link Mark,

You helped me with this, I was able to find a guy locally in Oakville today who had what I needed..

Take care,

Jim

I'll look at this again next week..

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#10

Re: Global Sourcing

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Glad you got your bearings straight. :-) Sorry, George made me say that.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#11

Sorry Guys

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>I couldn't resist it.:<)

George

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#12

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

Frank G

>Sealed bearing have a plastic shield. Shielded bearings have a metal shield. If your never planing to grease get sealed. In your case you would have had to heat the housing you were putting the bearing in to. If you pressed or beat the bearing in it should have been on the outer race.

Disclaimer: I don't know nothing.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#13

You Know...

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>I'd be in a spin with anything less Joanne and George!!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#14

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Jim, never use the outer race to seat the inner and never use the inner race to seat the outer. You will and have damaged the bearings. If you are seating the bearings in the Outer hub, you must press or drive them in using the outer race only. When seating them on a shaft you need a hollow tube (socket wrench works ok if you have one large and long enough. A piece of pipe works ok if you keep the ends cut square. You should not need to heat the bearings - I have probably replaced a thousand or so without heat. If you do heat be careful as "sealed" bearings use a plastic insert that will probably melt at < 400F. You also take a chance of losing the grease with too much heat. Heat is only needed with very large bearings or ultra precision. Normally I then froze the shaft with either CO2 or liquid nitrogen & if necessary heated the outer retainer for the bearing (left the bearing at room temp. Some 3 to 6" shaft diameter bearings will require heat to expand them prior to installation ( like 200 to 500+ HP motors etc. - but normally those are not sealed bearings and require greasing prior to use anyhow.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#15

A way to press bearings without special equipment

wilbur

>As said above, and as you've learned, a hammer, even with a piece of wood is not the best way to seat bearings. Replacing them is your best bet. As far as a replacement, a quick Google search found this page:

http://www.nachi-fujikoshi.co.jp/eng/jik/pdf/147-158.pdf

that says that the bore for this bearing is 20 mm, the outer diameter is 47 mm, and the width is 14 mm. There are many manufacturers that make a replacement bearing of these dimensions. Try McMaster-Carr. Your particular bearings have one contact seal as well, so you'll want to match that. But there's nothing wrong with getting another set of Nachi bearings. They're good quality bearings, and no bearing should be expected to stand up to being seated with a hammer.

One way that I've seated bearings on a shaft without specialty equipment is to bore a hole in two pieces of scrap wood (2x material is great) that will just fit over the shaft and that will clear the width of whatever else is on the shaft (In this case, your spiral head. By the way, I'm jealous). Put the bearing on the shaft, and slip the two pieces of wood over the shaft on opposite ends. Then use clamps on the ends of the two pieces of wood, start twisting the screw mechanism of the clamps one at a time, and slowly press the bearing on. If you want to get fancy, you can make a 3 or 4-armed version of the wood pieces. Woodworking clamps make surprisingly good bearing press mechanisms. I hope that made sense.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#16

Another way to press bearings w/o special equipmen

wilbur

>Take a look at the picture in this thread on the OWWM forum:

http://owwm.org/viewtopic.php?t=22079

Basically, the same idea as mine, except using steel plates instead of wood, and threaded rod instead of clamps.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#17

Locally owned auto parts store.

Basil

>One that handles parts for light trucks and farm equipment especially should have a press and the other required equipment for removing and installing bearings. Probaly can get your replacement bearings there also.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#18

Thanks WiIbur

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Thanks Wilbur,

I read the link and look at the bearings, You have been kind to help, Thank You!

Take care,

Jim

My dad's middle name was Wilbur :-)

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#19

Re: A way to press bearings without special equipm

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>You are correct Wilbur, however if the bearing is only driven on using the race that is "tight" and it will move without resorting to a sledgehammer, you are very unlikely to damage the bearing just driving it home carefully ( being sure you don't cock the bearing on the shaft or in the housing during the operation). I have several different bearing pullers and a Dake press in my shop (Drill press will also work if the parts will fit in the opening) so normally don't resort to driving the larger bearings with a hammer. The local Auto Parts store has a large hydraulic press (I think 20 or 50 ton) and will also press on a bearing for around $5. As they also have an assortment of tubes and spacers that will fit most shafts / bearings, it is sometimes worth taking the item there. When I was working I had access to a fully equipped tool room and maintenance shop so did anything I needed there, I have driven automotive wheel bearings with a hammer - with no detrimental effects.

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#20

Re: Thanks WiIbur

wilbur

>HI Jim,

Obviously, your dad must have had excellent taste to choose Wilbur as a middle name. :@)

Amazingly, everyone I've met or heard of with the name Wilbur spells it "Wilbur". On the other hand, when I tell someone my name, they spell it every way EXCEPT how it's spelled: Wilber, Wilbert, Wilburt, using 2 "L"'s. etc.

Wilbur

Re: Grrr, Bearings!

#21

Bite the bullet, here comes the salt in the wound

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Jim, I have been following your travails with the new cutter head.

This afternoon, I removed the cutter head from my Sunhill 8" jointer and replaced it with new helical head I bought from the Sunhill people. The entire process took 1 hour and 45 minutes. Most of that time was spent working the two V-belts free. The motor mounts were not too friendly.

My head came with a new set of bearings already installed on the cutter shaft, so all I had to do was to put a new pulley on the shaft and screw the mounting rods into the bearing cases. The assembly was a piece of pie. Once I got the belts back on, I grabbed the impact wrench to tighten the motor mounting screws, I should have used it when loosening the mount earlier.

So it is up and running and will edge joint a board. Ta-da! Did I mention that it only took 1 3/4 hours to do?

Jim, I am just toying with you. I would have most likely done exactly what you did if I were in your place.

Happy saw dust,

Ken