Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Exterior wood doors (what is best)

Posts

Exterior wood doors (what is best)

#1

Exterior wood doors (what is best)

Todd Doherty

>I have been asked to make exterior wood doors out of Poplar due to it's price. I'm concerned about movement over time and was wondering if anyone had experience with this and if there is another option that should be consider like Bass or White Pine......

He plans to paint the outside and dark stain the inside.

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

#2

Ok for paint...

John in New Mexico

>Same as pine, if they use a high quality paint and keep it sound. Might be ok for a stained finish if it never gets direct sunlight or rain, but if there's much exposure you can't really depend on a clear finish to protect the wood. I wouldn't expect movement problems in a well built frame and panel door. Out here I pay about $2/bdft for poplar and $4/bdft for white oak, and an entry door will take on the order of 100 bdft, is $200 really going to break the deal?

John

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

#3

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

Brian Philipp

>I would never make an exterior door out of Poplar.......it hates moisture. If your customer demands it, make sure you get a water damage waiver from him. Think white oak, mahogany, or cypress instead !

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

#4

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

Todd Doherty

>I suggested Mahogany but he does not want to pay the price. He choose Poplar only because of the price. The only other option I have about the same price is Ash and that is still $1 more per bdf. What about a Cedar or Fir( I believe it is much more expensive?

White oak is not that much more but it is still double that of poplar and will weight alot more.

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

#5

My thoughts....

Bryan in Broad Ripple, IN

>I built a storm door from poplar last year.

For rot and weather resistance, most any wood will work as long as the proper finish is applied. For poplar, you'll need to paint it.

For durability/toughness, poplar is not the best choice. It dents pretty easily. My door gets a lot of abuse since it leads down to my workshop into the basement. As a result, every time I hit it with a errant piece of wood or with a tool, etc. it results in a dent or a ding.

Regardless of what wood you select, you'll want to use quarter sawn wood to minimize expansion and contraction of the door with respect to the door frame. A nice uniform gap around the door in the wet months can lead to a whopping huge gap in the dry months if you are not careful. Remember, this is an outdoor project, and the seasonal humidity swings will probably be much greater than the indoor swings that we woodworkers are used to dealing with.

Where I live, our INDOOR humidity varies from 35% in the winter to 65% in the summer. Our OUTDOOR humidy varies from about 30% to 100%. That translates to twice as much wood movement for an outdoor project. Keep in mind that the frame won't move much, but the door will. Soooo....The door-to-frame gap must accomadate all of this movement.

As it stands, my door gap varies from about 1/16" in the wet months to a 1/4" gap, in the dry months. As a result, the latch barely engages during the dry season. If your neighbor is fussy, he may not find this acceptable.

Good luck!

-Bryan

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

#6

Re: My thoughts....

Mark Nowicki

>The client sounds like a cheapskate. Add "fussy" and this project has all the makings of a major PITA.

IMO, the best wood would be teak.

Mark

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

#7

Not to be contrary

Curly Smith

>but if he's that worried about price why isn't he buying the door from a big box store? IMO, your best bet is to take him shopping, help him hang the door, and walk away.

Can you build it out of poplar - yes. Should you - probably not. But, if you do you might consider giving the door a protective coat of the Behr epoxy that's been mentioned here

Re: Exterior wood doors (what is best)

#8

Staved construction

Bill Hylton

>I built a pair of 1 3/4"-thick traditional panel doors to close off my shop from a storage room. Used poplar. Shop's in the basement. Fit great in winter, but swelled enough come summer to thwart closing them. By late fall, they fit fine again.

Before I built, I nosed around the web and found some interesting articles on making doors at woodweb.com. I can't direct you to them straightaway, but you should be able to find them.

Of interest is what's known as staved construction. You dress 5/4 stock to about 1" thick. Rip it into 1 1/2"-wide strips. Then glue the strips face-to-face, forming rail-and-stile stock 1 1/2" thick and however wide you need. After surfacing these staved pieces, you veneer both faces. Several makers talked about using poplar for the staves and white oak for the veneers. The construction method yields a more stable rail/stile.

Subsequently, I discovered the website HistoricDoors.com and realized that the shop was only a few miles from me. Guy builds magnificent doors for some notable clients--including Yale, Princeton, U of P, Notre Dame, City of Milwaukee, etc. Got a brief shop tour. They use staved construction.

FWIW.

Bill

PS--I'm going to use staved construction on the next door I build.