My thoughts....
Bryan in Broad Ripple, IN
>I built a storm door from poplar last year.
For rot and weather resistance, most any wood will work as long as the proper finish is applied. For poplar, you'll need to paint it.
For durability/toughness, poplar is not the best choice. It dents pretty easily. My door gets a lot of abuse since it leads down to my workshop into the basement. As a result, every time I hit it with a errant piece of wood or with a tool, etc. it results in a dent or a ding.
Regardless of what wood you select, you'll want to use quarter sawn wood to minimize expansion and contraction of the door with respect to the door frame. A nice uniform gap around the door in the wet months can lead to a whopping huge gap in the dry months if you are not careful. Remember, this is an outdoor project, and the seasonal humidity swings will probably be much greater than the indoor swings that we woodworkers are used to dealing with.
Where I live, our INDOOR humidity varies from 35% in the winter to 65% in the summer. Our OUTDOOR humidy varies from about 30% to 100%. That translates to twice as much wood movement for an outdoor project. Keep in mind that the frame won't move much, but the door will. Soooo....The door-to-frame gap must accomadate all of this movement.
As it stands, my door gap varies from about 1/16" in the wet months to a 1/4" gap, in the dry months. As a result, the latch barely engages during the dry season. If your neighbor is fussy, he may not find this acceptable.
Good luck!
-Bryan