Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Stripped hinge screw question

Posts

Stripped hinge screw question

#1

Stripped hinge screw question

Barry Irby

>I have been refurbishing a rental property. Some of the hinge screws in the door jambs were stripped or worn out. One thought I had was to replace the existing hinges with larger ones that have four screws instead of three. (I am replacing the doors and hinges anyway.)

Then it occurred to me that I could drill out the holes and insert a matching plug and glue it in. Use a plug cutter, make 3/8 or 1/2" plugs, drill out the ruined holes and fill them. Does this seem like a good and permanent solution? Will the plugs hold? Any better ideas?

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

#2

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

Charles McCoy

>A plug should have plenty of strength. I've been filling holes with tooth picks and golf tees for years and never had one fail. :)

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

#3

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

Jim Dillon

>Morning Barry,

Should work just fine although I have never done it for screws that large. Make sure to let the glue dry overnight as you don't want the plug breaking loose when you drive the new screw in.

Jim

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

#4

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

Phil Thien

>That (plug, or a dowel) is how Tommy on Ask This Old House did it.

I have a heavy front door and the top screws on it had pulled out of the framing. I tried toothpicks and golf tees and everything. Nothing worked.

Finally, I removed the inside trim on the hinge side of the door, and drilled two holes perpendicular to the hinge screws. I put stainless wing-nuts into the holes and threaded machine screws (flat-headed bolts) through the hinge and into the wing-nuts. Has worked perfectly.

For lighter, interior doors, I'd try the plugs or dowels first.

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

#5

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

John Veerkamp

>Barry,

The easiest fix is just to get longer screws of the same size, ie no 10, that are long enough to reach the framing 2X . Usually a 3" screw is long enough. For entrance doors this also provides an extra measure of security especially if you replace the striker plate screws the same way.

John

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

#6

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

Keith Newton

>Barry, I use longer screws like John for the back two, although often the outer ones only hit drywall.

for those, I go up a couple of sizes on screw gauge, and enlarge the hinge with a counter-sink bit. Also, I keep thin cyanoacrylate glue on-hand, and if you saturate the inside of the hole, it will soak up and down the grain and turn it into a much tougher material than it started out.

The CA glue also works great for MDF, and other fiberous materials that suffer from poor screw holding strength.

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

#7

two suggestions

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I have fixed a pile of doors like this.

1. Just whittle a stick, put glue on it and drive it into the old screw hole.

2.The screws that come with doors are uselessly short. Replace the screws with something that reaches through the jam and well into the framing. I have been known to use 3 and 4" screws for an entry door.

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

#8

And...

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>Drill the plugs exactly for the size screw in the hinge. Since most door frames are pine, I use hardwood for the plugs.

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

#9

Re: Stripped hinge screw question

Jim Swank

>I've fixed many a loose screw with either wood toothpicks or matches. Dip in white glue, shove in hole, cut off with diagonal pliers, and trim with chisel when dry. You can still drill out for plug or dowel if it doesn't work.